Arran care home crisis: Sector leader shares solutions

Arran has only one care home, run by the local authority <i>(Image: Martini archive)</i>
Arran has only one care home, run by the local authority (Image: Martini archive)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Care home providers would "be insane" to open a facility on the isle of Arran, the head of Scottish Care has said.

Dr Donald Macaskill, chief executive of the body that represents the independent social care sector, said it would be incredibly difficult to make the numbers add up due to the high number of residents reliant on local authority funding.

It comes after The Herald highlighted the care crisis affecting the island that has led to campaigners considering pursuing court action.

With a population of around 4,618 the island now has just one care home, the last run by North Ayrshire, and beds at Montrose House have gradually been cut from 30 to 15 and then in August last year to 10.

The local authority says it is unable to find enough staff to run any greater capacity at the home and that the cost of agency staff was contributing to "significant and unsustainable financial pressures on the service".

Montrose House was built to house 30 residents but has never achieved its full capacity (Image: Google Maps)

It has led to more than 45 elderly people having to leave the island and an action group says it is prepared to pursue a Judicial Review to reverse the bed cuts.

Dr Macaskill said it was not normal for an island of Arran's size to have just one care home.

He said: "Arran used to have more than home.

"In my time I think there were two independent homes - there was certainly one which was a good care home, well run and always did really well but it struggled to get staff and struggled to make ends meet.

"That is just indicative of everywhere, with what was being offered in terms of the National Care Home Contract (the annual agreement in Scotland between Cosla and care providers, setting standard weekly rates for residential and nursing care).

"Most island communities don't have a significant number of people who can't fund their own care.

Arran has only one care home, run by the local authority (Image: Martini archive)

"In my own homebase on Skye, when I started this job there were six care homes and there's now effectively only two and it's the same with the Western Isles.

"Independent providers, be they small family run or even some of the biggest corporates, can't make the sums add up and the big thing is staff.

"There are legal requirements for how many staff you need to have. If you can't supply that staffing through the indigenous island population or even through international recruitment then you've got to get agency staff and that just absolutely destroys a small operator."

He said he wasn't surprised that private providers had not come forward with any plans for the island.

"I think you would be insane, to be quite honest," said Mr Macaskill. "If you are solely dependant on what the state pays you and you can't have self-funders.

"Arran would have some self-funders but it's not a guaranteed market in the way it is on some of our mainland communities.

Donald Macaskill says it would be difficult for any private provider to make the sums add up on Arran.

"You cannot make the sums add up. The city of Edinburgh has a risk matrix and if you have more than 30% of residents on the National Care Home Contract you are a high risk in terms of quality and sustainability.

"I often use the analogy about one of the communities where you can see Arran from the front door. When I started 10 years ago, 80% of the residents were national public funded and now it's 20% because they can't make the sums add up and that's a charity.

"It's all down to that factors of workforce availability and cost, not sufficient incentivisation to hold on to the local community.

"Things like housing and support with energy and transport all need to be looked at in order to attract and hold onto people."


Read more:


Islanders say the shifts offered to potential employees at Montrose House were "too restrictive".

"That's certainly an issue," said Dr Macaskill.

Donald Macaskill, chief executive of Scottish Care (Image: Newsquest)

"You will find that successful care homes even in the Highlands and remote communities try to be as flexible as possible with shift patterns but there is a fine balance to be got between a shift pattern which is fairly regular and continuous and allows a continuity of care with residents and significant staff alteration [which] doesn't actually help them. It may help the individual staff member.

"On the other side of the coin there is getting sufficient continuity of work that people are able to earn enough by a reduced shift.

"If you are simply talking about the National Contract and the living wage you've got to do an awful lot of hours in order for that to be a realistic wage, particular in an island community.

"What people like me have been saying is that we need to introduce a system for the highlands and islands not dissimilar to what has happened in London and some rural parts of England where you accept that you only address the issue of delivering social care in island or remote communities by incentivising people and that's through making social housing available, it's through weighting the amount of money that people get in terms of the salary take home pay.

"There's a desire in some parts of rural communities and I saw this in Australia where you change the registration process for work so that somebody might be able to do an early years piece of work in the morning and then a residential or home care piece of work in the afternoon or evening.

"At the moment it's not possible for us to use reduced staff in an island community in that way.

"Simply using the same model that works in Ardrossan or Troon, it's not going to work on Arran."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos