Rising costs at home and abroad are weighing heavily on sentiment in the Scotch whisky industry, amid concern that the difficulties could put some distillers in severe financial distress.
Just 37% of whisky businesses reported feeling optimistic, compared with 56% of firms across the wider food and drink industry, in the latest annual survey carried out by accountancy firm Johnston Carmichael.
The survey, which was undertaken shortly before oil and gas prices surged in the wake of the current conflict in the Middle East, underlines the raft of challenges facing the Scotch whisky industry, from UK duty hikes and high labour costs to Trump tariffs and downturns in key export markets such as the US and China.
The report identified labour as Scotch whisky distillers’ biggest source of cost increases, cited by 42%. Distillers also expressed concern about ongoing geopolitical uncertainty and unpredictability, with the impact of US tariffs cited by 37% and taxation by 47%.
The survey comes shortly after the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) cited the impact of tariffs, currently set at 10% for the bulk of UK goods entering the US, as figures showed the volume of Scotch exports to America tumbled by 9.2% to the equivalent of 120 million 70cl bottles in 2025. The value of exports to the US fell less sharply, declining by 4% to £933 million. The overall value of Scotch Whisky exports fell by 1.8% to £5.3bn in 2025, with the volume falling by 4.3% at 1.3bn 70cl bottles.
Read more:
- Owner of prestigious Scotch whisky club falls to loss amid woes in US
- Scotch whisky giants open talks over blockbuster merger
- Shares plunge in drinks company as chiefs highlight 'immediate' funding need
- More than 100 jobs go as Tennent's Lager owner buys 'well-loved' Scottish beer brand
As well as highlighting concerns over tariffs and other geopolitical tension, the SWA has expressed concern over duty increased in the UK and new packaging taxes. It said the latest rise in spirits tax put through by the UK Government in January meant that duty had increased by 17% in three years.
In addition, companies in the UK have been contending with increases in employer national insurance contributions and the national living and minimum wage which came into effect in April 2025.
Grant Roger, audit partner and director of the Whisky Finance Director Club at Johnston Carmichael, said the level of pessimism found by the firm’s latest survey was not surprising.
“You have got such a challenge with the labour force," Mr Roger told The Herald. "You have got changes with minimum wage legislation [and] national insurance changes. You have got pressure from a taxation perspective. Duty is one that comes out certainly from our survey as an area of frustration. I think [there is a feeling] across the sector that they are not getting that support from the government. There is the constant challenge around the tariffs. None of these are new areas or things that were a surprise.
“But it comes through in our survey and the results and when you break it down, it is those areas. It is that constant cost pressure and trying to manage raw material costs [and] energy costs. From a whisky sector perspective it is a bigger concern than even just the wider food and drink sector, given the nature of the process and the production run. So, you know, it is interesting that there is a bit less optimism than maybe there was last year. There is that continued challenge.”
The downturn in the Scotch whisky industry in recent years has led to redundancies in certain cases and some distillers taking the decision to slow or suspended production.
Some 21% of distillers which took part in the survey said the cost of energy had risen more sharply than any other overhead, compared with 9% for the food and drink industry as a whole, with Mr Roger declaring that the conflict in the Middle East has “exaggerated that challenge”.
He noted that the particular difficulty for Scotch whisky producers was that “you don’t want to be turning off production”, observing that spirit being distilled now will be for sale in “five, 10, 15, 20 years’ time”.
“There is always a bit of a gamble in switching it off in times of pressure,” Mr Roger said.
Asked if there is a risk that some distillers may fail in the current climate, as costs rise while the volume of sales in the wider market is declining, Mr Roger said: “Without being overly negative, there will be.”
He noted: “It is sad to see when you look at the number of distilleries that there are in Scotland and how important the whisky industry is to Scotland and the UK as a whole. But in these challenging times there potentially will be some casualties, unfortunately.”
In other challenges, the survey highlighted ongoing concern over trading with the European Union following Brexit. Just 21% of respondents reported more positivity on this front than last year, while 58% reported either the same or less positive sentiments.
The Scotch whisky industry was also found to facing difficulties in retaining staff. Respondents said 37% of people who have left the industry did so because of stagnant salaries, with 27% citing a lack of opportunity for progression.
More optimistically the survey, which gathered the views of 98 UK food and drink businesses, 78% of which are based in Scotland, found that 79% of respondents are investing to develop new products and innovate.
Mr Roger said: “The resilience of the UK food and drink industry should not be understated and there is positivity in the levels of innovation and new product development. But while the sector as a whole faces challenges, whisky distillers are experiencing major obstacles above and beyond what many others are.
“Whisky is crucial to the UK food and drink industry and remains the runway for all other producers to flourish. However, insights are clear that amidst widespread global uncertainty the sector craves greater clarity and stability.”
Share