Pilgrimage: the Road to Holy Island, BBC Two, Sunday-Tuesday
three stars
It was the best of times for celebrity reality shows, it was the worst of times. Or to put it another way, this Easter weekend, one group of vaguely familiar folk was eating animal body parts in I’m a Celebrity … South Africa, while another was in Northumberland feasting on tales of early Celtic Christian saints.
Let’s not argue about who had the better time. This is the eighth series of Pilgrimage, a programme that is everything commissioning editors might deem dull - nice, polite sorts discussing all faiths and none while yomping across the countryside. Yet it works.
This year’s seven include the dancer Ashley Banjo, Hermione Norris of Spooks, a couple of comedians and someone who made it to the final of Strictly. The most ab fab booking of all is the actor Patsy Kensit, who describes herself as an “a la carte Catholic”.
Kensit was the last to arrive. “I think it’s another comedian,” said radio presenter Jayne Middlemiss as Patsy appeared, Omar Sharif-like, on the horizon. In fairness, she was wearing a bobble hat.
Off they set on the 242-mile trek. The youngest pilgrim, Tasha Ghouri, TV presenter, gravitated towards Patsy to form a Patsy-Saffy partnership (if Saffy and Patsy had liked each other). Patsy doled out advice like the best big sister ever. “You don’t have to marry all your boyfriends,” said the former Mrs Kerr and Mrs Gallagher.
Each had their own reason for being on the trip, some more spiritual than others. Not to be snarky, but it can’t do any harm to have the prestige Pilgrimage on one’s CV. Look at Harry Clark, who went from winning Traitors to Pilgrimage to his own documentary about meeting the Pope.
More of a problem is the rather dull script. Even the tale of St Hild hurling snakes over a cliff failed to set the heather alight. Fortunately, the comedians were funny. One in particular, Hasan Al-Habib, a Muslim from London and Birmingham, we'll definitely be seeing again.
It’s hard to say how or why pilgrimage works. Maybe just seeing people out and about in nature, talking seriously about life, is a welcome break from the frenzied norm. As Father Jack might say, it's an ecumenical matter.
Read more
- Your Friends and Neighbours review: What Mad Men's Don Draper did next
- Jo Nesbo's Detective Hole - sorry Harry, it's no Dept. Q
- Treated like royalty by the BBC, arrogant Edwards flew too close to the Sun
- Babies review: Don't miss a minute of this heartbreaking yet hopeful drama
Secret Garden, BBC One, Sunday
four stars
What do you get a beloved naturalist for his 100th birthday? If you are the BBC, a suite of special programmes, including this five-parter looking at gardens around the UK.
There’s one in the west of Scotland, but unless you watch on iPlayer, you’ll have to wait for that. Being a prime example of slow, beautifully shot television, Secret Garden is probably best savoured at a leisurely hedgehog’s pace anyway.
First stop for Sir David Attenborough is a mill house in Oxfordshire, where the garden is home to kingfishers, otters, deer and bank voles. It looks idyllic. I’d have been quite happy to park myself on the riverbank and watch the wildlife go by. However, this being an Attenborough documentary, there are “extraordinary dramas” playing out.
So we hear about picky Doris the duck, how she’s “the garden’s resident heartbreaker”. If that’s too sugary for your taste, there’s also an extended scene in which Doris’s nine ducklings attract the attention of an otter. Personally, I can do without the jeopardy in wildlife documentaries, but it usually goes with the whole circle of life, eat and be eaten territory. The Secret Garden, I’m pleased to say, is a refreshing change from all that. Airing at 6pm, long before the watershed, it’s relatively free of peril (hungry otters and robot lawnmowers aside) and safe for all ages to watch.
There are some stunning scenes, from the sublime (the flight of the mayflies, kingfishers feeding) to the horrific (mice running over the roof, picked out by night vision cameras). The “secrets revealed” section at the end showed how equipment usually deployed on African shoots was repurposed here to spectacular effect. Tell that to Sam the cameraman who sat in the river for three days trying to get a sight of an otter. His (drier) colleague bagged the shot instead; Sam was consoled by scenes of a kingfisher feeding.
While all the “drama” was going on, the human residents were seen in the background, reading the paper or just pottering in the garden. Their reward was a sneak peek at the hidden world living on their doorstep. I imagine they were just as thrilled to have played host to Sir David.
Read more
Share