Anas Sarwar has called John Swinney “a bit of a crank” after the First Minister questioned why the UK Government blocked a Chinese-backed turbine factory for Scotland on security grounds.
The Scottish Labour leader accused the First Minister of peddling a “conspiracy theory”.
Ming Yang had planned to build a £1.5 billion manufacturing facility at Ardersier in the Highlands. The project backed by the Scottish Government but vetoed by Westminster on national security grounds.
Read more
Ming Yang warns decision to block Scots turbine factory could hike energy bills
'Not a coincidence' Swinney questions timing of UK Government decision on Ming Yang
What are the security risks behind blocked Chinese turbine company deal?
“If that’s not an anti-Scottish move by a Labour Government, I don’t know what is.”
In an interview with BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, the First Minister insisted he was seeking transparency rather than questioning the existence of security concerns.
Stock image of a wind turbine. Image: Unsplash/Abdulaziz Alfaleh
Asked if he wanted Scotland’s power in China’s hands, Mr Swinney said: “Well, I want Scotland’s power in Scotland’s hands, and I want there to be manufacturing benefit from the generation of renewable energy in Scotland coming to people in Scotland, with the development of the manufacturing capacity to develop the infrastructure that’s required.
“And of course, what I don’t have from the United Kingdom Government is an explanation of why they have blocked the development of that manufacturing capability by the Chinese company Ming Yang.”
Asked if he believed the UK Government was inventing security concerns, the First Minister said: “Well, what I want to understand from the UK Government is why they have taken the decision that they’ve taken, because there’s been no transparent explanation to me.”
The First Minister said his frustration was at the lack of detail.
“Forgive me for wanting to have a bit more information about what is the rationale for that, and what alternatives have been looked at to try to make sure that those security considerations could be overcome, because there are many voices that say that that could be the case.
“Because what I’m interested in is making sure that Scotland, unlike the experience in North Sea oil and gas, actually reaps the reward of the use and development of our energy resources, because £350 billion has gone from the North Sea sector to the UK Treasury, and Scotland has got nothing in return. And I don’t want a repeat of that situation.”
In a later interview with BBC Scotland, Mr Sarwar said national security needed to take precedence over inward investment.
He described the First Minister’s comments as “a pretty strange conspiracy theory”.
“The First Minister was arguing that somehow the national security services were trying to do down Scotland’s economy on an investment coming, for example, from China.
“I can give you a cast-iron guarantee I will not do crankery or conspiracy theory as First Minister. I will always accept national security advice because our first duty as a government would be to protect the great citizens of this country.”
Chinese and Scottish flags (Image: derek mcarthur)
Asked about Chinese money going into other projects, such as the Hinkley nuclear project, he said: “Well, all these projects will have national security briefings. A national security briefing was received that said there was a national security risk for an investment and are we honestly saying that a first minister would reject national security advice?
“I can tell you quite categorically if a national security briefing comes to me I will not ignore it, because I will put the national interest before political interest.”
“For a first minister to suggest that our national security services have some kind of deliberate do-Scotland-down approach sounds like the height of conspiracy theory and actually a bit of a crank, to be honest, and I’m not sure that’s what the First Minister intends.”
Speaking to the Press Association at a campaign visit in West Calder later on in the day, the First Minister said: “I’ve no explanation from the United Kingdom Government about their decision to refuse £1.5bn of investment in renewable energy manufacturing and capability in Scotland, other than the explanation it is about national security.
“I have no more detailed understanding than that simple statement from the UK Government.
“And I think that is unacceptable because there is Chinese investment, Chinese development being embraced and welcomed in other parts of the United Kingdom – there’s a Chinese super embassy going to be built in the heart of the city of London.
“And I just cannot understand and fathom the decision of the United Kingdom Government, which is supposed to be interested in developing manufacturing capability in the United Kingdom, to block an investment of £1.5bn which could support and sustain the development of manufacturing capability in Scotland.”
Read more
Reform UK could take 'outright power' at Holyrood in 2031, Nigel Farage insists
SNP reveals plans for new national arts company to showcase traditional music
Russell Findlay calls for 'woke nonsense' to be 'excised' from public sector
Shortly after the decision. Ming Yang warned the decision would push energy costs higher and slow the shift to renewables.
The company insisted it had spent more than two years addressing security concerns, including around data and cyber risks, and said its plans would have created up to 1,500 jobs.
Hinkley Point C was approved in 2015 under David Cameron, when Chinese investment in new nuclear was actively encouraged.
That policy shifted in 2022 under Rishi Sunak, with ministers moving to exclude further Chinese involvement in nuclear projects on national security grounds.
The Labour government has maintained that position.
Share