COLIN MCLEAN

Business funding must be priority for Scottish Government

The Stockholm-based Nasdaq Nordic platform is home to hundreds of smaller growth companies <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
The Stockholm-based Nasdaq Nordic platform is home to hundreds of smaller growth companies (Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Scotland has long struggled to turn its innovation into lasting businesses that grow, create jobs, and stay Scottish.

Entrepreneurship and the ability to scaling up matter more than ever as Scotland feels the impact of weak global growth. But Scotland has a structural funding gap that is starving its most promising businesses of the finance they need to grow. Can the capital markets be made to work for Scotland? In May, this challenge should be a priority for the new Scottish Government.

The raw numbers on business formation tell a sobering story. Scotland had 809 businesses per ten thousand adults in 2025, compared with 1,020 across the UK as a whole. While the number of private sector businesses operating in Scotland is growing, the structure of the sector is more troubling. The registered business stock - those employing staff or trading above the VAT threshold, and therefore the businesses most likely to grow and create jobs - remains below its pre-pandemic peak of just over 179,000 despite two consecutive years of modest growth.

Scotland is also more reliant on large employers: large businesses account for 44% of Scottish private sector employment, against 40% across the UK. Most of the growth in numbers is in unregistered and small businesses, which is encouraging as Scotland needs to catch up on early stage business formation. They should be Scotland’s future medium sized growth firms, but it is a difficult stage to get finance for growth.


Read more:


The contrast with comparable northern European nations is striking. Denmark, with a similar population to Scotland, has long maintained a dense ecosystem of small and medium-sized businesses supported by accessible credit markets, active domestic equity investment and a culture of patient ownership. Sweden has one of the highest rates of technology unicorns per capita in the world. Finland punches well above its size in innovation rankings. These countries combine generous social safety nets with competitive conditions for business formation, creating an environment where risk-taking is encouraged and rewarded. Scotland's business density deficit is at least partly a product of capital scarcity.

Developing a young business has never been easy but the current environment seems particularly uncertain. A well-run firm that is expanding may find that growth itself is the enemy of financial stability. If that business is entirely self-financed - and many Scottish businesses are - the profits needed to fund that expansion are being squeezed at exactly the moment they are most needed.

Even for a service business focused on people rather than physical assets, additional working capital is needed to take on more customers. Cost pressures across energy, wages and supply chains have compressed profit margins across much of the private sector over the past three years, reducing the retained earnings that should support growth investment.

Across northern Europe, the comparison is instructive. Sweden, Denmark and Finland all operate domestic exchanges with a culture of listing smaller companies and a retail investor base that actively participates in supporting them. Stockholm's Nasdaq Nordic platform is home to hundreds of smaller growth companies.

Scotland, by contrast, lacks such an exchange of its own, and is entirely reliant on a London market that is struggling to keep the companies it already has, let alone attract new ones. Scotland’s regional stock exchanges were absorbed into the London Stock Exchange in 1973. Since then, despite advances in technology, no successor to the lost exchanges has developed.

Scotland’s recent economic performance is not consistent with a country of Scotland's talent, its university base, or its natural resources. A significant part of the explanation lies not in ambition or skill but in access to money. Scottish businesses - whether early-stage tech firms or established enterprises - face a capital market that is structurally tilted against them. Fixing that is not simply a matter of business policy. It requires a sustained, coordinated effort across public investment, private markets, pension reform and banking, and it requires public recognition of the issue and political will.

The problem does not stop at the public markets. For Scotland's emerging entrepreneurial economy the challenge of securing private equity and venture capital is just as pressing. Some Scottish firms have been able to find early funding from local business angels and accelerators, but often hit a wall at the scale-up stage, when they need larger sums to expand and compete internationally.

The Scottish National Investment Bank (SNIB) was created to address part of this gap. Its mandate is to deploy patient, long-term capital into underserved areas - such as net-zero transition, place-based economic development and scaling technology. SNIB has now invested over one billion pounds, with the total impact more than doubled by additional investors alongside the public money. But does SNIB have the scale and backing to match Scotland ‘s ambition, particularly as the Scottish Government faces budget constraints on what is available to promote innovation, enterprise and entrepreneurship?

Scotland is seeing good business formation in technology, with momentum particularly strong in AI, data science, and green engineering. But scaling these young businesses is challenging. SNIB's financial firepower should be materially increased in the next parliamentary session to allow more support for these high growth businesses.

The recent KPMG survey of private businesses found that 40% are now more willing to explore new sources of capital, such as private equity, to support innovation and accelerate growth.

Scotland should work to influence any decisions about UK-wide capital allocation. Westminster's pension reform agenda has the potential to boost private capital and infrastructure investment. Significant new funding could emerge from the British Growth Partnership, but Scotland must actively compete for that capital. We should also be pushing hard for London stock market reform to reduce the cost of smaller company listings.

Scottish firms have ambition – they deserve the finance to grow and innovate. Whoever wins in May should make closing Scotland’s funding gap a priority, not an aspiration.

Colin McLean is a director of Barnton Capital

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos