With life expectancy stalling and inequalities widening, Scotland’s NHS faces mounting pressure - but do any of the parties have a plan that matches the scale of the challenge?
Scotland’s health is deteriorating - and the warning signs are no longer subtle.
Healthy life expectancy, the number of years a person can expect to live in good health, has fallen over the past decade, now standing at just 59.1 years for men and 59.4 for women in the latest 2022–2024 figures.
Behind the headline numbers lies a stark reality: people in the country’s most deprived communities are living shorter, sicker lives, with little meaningful progress in closing that gap in recent years.
As the 2026 Holyrood election approaches, the question facing voters is no longer whether Scotland’s health system is under strain, but whether any political party has a credible plan to reverse what many now see as systemic decline.
Inequality at the heart of the crisis
Health inequalities remain one of the most entrenched challenges facing Scotland. Experts warn that without structural change, outcomes will continue to worsen.
Professor Andrea Cameron, of Abertay University and Chair of the Council of Deans of Health, Equality, Diversity and Inclusion strategic policy group, argues that workforce pressures are central to the problem.
Professor Cameron told The Herald: “Health inequalities cannot be tackled without a strong, sustainable workforce of nurses, midwives and allied health professionals. Our research shows that cost-of-living pressures are forcing too many students out of healthcare training, creating a ‘leaky pipeline’ that weakens the NHS’s ability to deliver equitable care, particularly in deprived and underserved areas."
Professor Andrea Cameron, Professor of Professional Practice in Health Education at Abertay University and she is also the Chair of the Council of Deans of Health Equality, Diversity and Inclusion strategic policy group. (Image: Supplied)
She added: "High upfront costs such as travel, childcare and placement expenses are proving a real barrier, even where tuition is funded. Widening access to healthcare education and recruiting locally from areas of higher deprivation is essential if the workforce is to reflect the communities it serves."
Ahead of the election, the Council of Deans of Health Scotland is calling for joined‑up action across government, education and the NHS to ensure workforce planning is aligned with the shared goal of reducing health inequalities.
Professor Cameron's warning reflects a wider concern across the sector: that the NHS cannot address inequality without first addressing who delivers care - and where.
'The divide between health and social care is artificial'
For frontline clinicians, the issues are immediate and visible.
Dr Chris Williams, a GP and Vice Chair of the Royal College of GPs, believes political debate has become too narrowly focused on headline metrics like waiting lists.
“For all that waiting lists can sort of capture the attention of people, those are things that are easy to count and there’s also some inherent problem with waiting lists that mean there’s sometimes a very good reason for why someone is on a waiting list rather than not had an operation yet.”
Instead, he points to deeper structural failings, particularly in social care.
“Some of the big priorities lie in general practice and social care, especially.
"Without seeing improvements in the social care workforce, without improvements in terms of availability, especially in more rural parts then I think we will still find people stranded in hospital beds or not in the place where they need or want to be.”
During a night in corridor care las year, I saw with my own eyes the deep cracks in Scotland’s NHS. There were patients waiting hours for treatment, elderly people left on trolleys overnight, and staff working relentlessly in a system stretched beyond capacity.
That experience underscored how pressures in social care, staffing and capacity are converging at the sharpest point of the system.
Dr Chris Williams, Vice Chair (Policy) of Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) and a GP in Highlands. (Image: Stewart Grant)
For Dr Williams, the fundamental issue is how services are organised.
“I think increasingly the divide between health and social care is artificial," he told The Herald.
He pointed to the stalled National Care Service as an example of the challenges in delivering that integration.
Dr Williams said Scotland had made “very good” progress in bringing health and social care closer together, but added: “I was very sorry that the National Care Service work didn’t bear all the fruit that was needed and I guess that would be something that the next parliament whatever its colour and flavour, that will be an immediate priority.”
He added that any renewed plans would need to involve early engagement with the social care workforce and a focus on improving conditions and status within the sector.
That disconnect has real-world consequences. In rural communities, he says, patients without strong support networks are particularly vulnerable.
Dr Williams, a GP in Grantown-on-Spey, said: “I’m in a rural area and we have many elderly patients and many people who are ageing. Some who have relatives nearby but some who don’t have a good network of social support and that can be very challenging for them.”
A system under strain
The pressures extend beyond staffing into infrastructure and technology.
Dr Williams highlights a growing mismatch between workforce expansion and physical capacity.
“We’ve seen an increase in the number of different types of staff who are working from general practice from primary care. It’s great to see an increased skill mix but there is then competition for space.”
“One of the big issues my GP colleagues across country report is the lack of consulting room space that we have.”
Workforce has been a major issue in Scotland's NHS. (Image: Supplied)
Digital systems, too, are lagging behind.
“As a GP, we are ever more dependent on our IT systems and again the investment in the IT systems hasn’t kept pace with the IT needed.
“When you consider what you can do with your online banking, that far outstrips what you can do online to manage your health.”
For patients, this translates into fragmented care and repeated explanations of their conditions – a symptom, he argues, of poor interoperability between systems.
GP walk-in clinics
Recent plans to expand GP walk-in centres have been presented by the Scottish Government as a way to ease pressure on family doctors and tackle the “8am rush” for appointments. The centres are expected to operate seven days a week, largely between 12:00 and 20:00.
However, Dr Williams questioned whether they would deliver the intended impact.
“These walk-in centres are not going to be staffed just by GPs. There may be a GP there but people will be seen by whatever staff can be found and it will not have the level of efficiency that normal general medical practice has and it will not provide the continuity that normal general medical practice can do.”
He said that while the centres may be useful for minor conditions, they were unlikely to address underlying demand.
“Specifically this notion of the 8am rush. It cannot solve the spike in demand that we see where there are more people seeking input from a GP than there is GP availability.”
Dr Williams argued that improving access ultimately depends on increasing GP capacity and reducing bureaucracy, adding that resources may be better directed elsewhere.
“The money that’s paying for these might well buy you a whole lot more care and better care, if it was directed into core general practice.”
Hospital ward. (Image: PA)
Doctors call for “radical reform”
Medical bodies are increasingly blunt in their assessment.
The British Medical Association (BMA) has warned that the NHS faces a pivotal moment, calling for “serious long-term and radical reform that finally puts our NHS on a sustainable footing for generations to come”.
Its analysis suggests that incremental fixes are no longer sufficient. Waiting lists, GP access and workforce shortages dominate public concern, but the underlying issue is sustainability.
“Too often, solutions offered to the problems the health service faces do no more than tinker at the edges,” Dr Iain Kennedy, chair of BMA Scotland has said, urging politicians to move beyond short-term thinking.
Central to the BMA's recommendations are long-term workforce planning, a shift toward community-based care, and improved IT infrastructure – concerns that closely mirror those raised by frontline clinicians.
What the parties are promising
While there is broad agreement on the scale of the challenge, the parties are offering competing visions for how to fix the NHS.
Scottish Conservatives
The Scottish Conservatives have focused on access and system performance, with pledges to deliver faster GP appointments and increase NHS funding, alongside a broader push to cut bureaucracy and redirect spending to frontline services. They argue that failures in social care and delayed discharge are central to current pressures.
Scottish Conservative health spokesperson Dr Sandesh Gulhane said: "The SNP have run our NHS into the ground over the last two decades and John Swinney's been at the table at the whole time.
"On his watch, A&E waiting times have soared, it is next to impossible to get GP appointments and their failure to eradicate delayed discharge is having devastating knock-on effects across the NHS.
"What is most shameful is that it is our most deprived communities that have been betrayed the most by the SNP.”
Scottish Labour
Scottish Labour has set out a more structural reform agenda, centred on reducing waiting lists, improving GP access and expanding care in the community.
Key pledges include ending the “8am rush” for GP appointments, guaranteeing faster access to care, creating neighbourhood health hubs and increasing social care capacity with additional step-down beds and home care packages.
Scottish Labour’s health spokesperson Jackie Baillie said: “After 20 years of SNP government, it's absolutely clear many parts of the NHS in Scotland are broken and we need to take urgent action to fix it.
"Scottish Labour will fix the mess by ending the 8am rush for a GP appointment and bringing back the family doctor.
"We will drive down NHS waiting lists, using capacity wherever it is available and tackle bed blocking, with 300 step-down beds in care homes and 1,000 more care at home packages.”
Scottish Liberal Democrats
The Scottish Liberal Democrats have prioritised social care reform as the key to easing pressure on hospitals. Their plans include expanding the care workforce, introducing a seven-day discharge model and improving pay and conditions, alongside measures to reduce GP workload by expanding multidisciplinary teams.
Scottish Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton said: “We will fix care to fix the NHS. People are facing catastrophically long waits at A&E because hospital beds are full of patients who are medically ready to leave but can’t because a shortage of care workers and care packages prevents them from getting home.”
SNP
The SNP, meanwhile, is campaigning on its record in government while promising further expansion of services.
Its commitments include increasing the number of GP walk-in centres, reducing waiting times, expanding diagnostic services in the community and maintaining high staffing levels, alongside wider policies aimed at tackling poverty.
Clare Haughey, SNP candidate for Rutherglen & Cambuslang, said: "Waiting times are down, operation numbers up, we have more GPs per head than south of the border and we haven't lost a single day to strikes in our NHS - the SNP has a plan for our NHS and it's working.
"Of course there remain challenges though and that's why we will go even further - GP walk-in centres are springing up across Scotland…”
Scottish Greens
The Scottish Greens place a strong emphasis on prevention and inequality, arguing that health outcomes are shaped by wider social and environmental conditions. Their manifesto includes commitments to increase NHS staffing, invest more in public services and shift focus toward early intervention and community-based care, funded in part through higher taxation on wealth and polluting industries.
Reform UK
Reform UK has pledged a more radical overhaul, centred on cutting waiting lists and restructuring public services. Its manifesto frames NHS reform alongside tax cuts and economic changes, arguing that improved efficiency and growth are necessary to restore performance.
The need for consensus
Despite political differences, there is notable overlap in diagnosis: workforce shortages, access to care, and system inefficiencies are widely acknowledged.
Yet experts caution that agreement on problems does not equate to agreement on solutions.
The BMA’s call for long-term reform suggests that meaningful change will require politically difficult decisions – particularly around funding, workforce planning and the balance between hospital and community care.
This is a defining election for Scotland’s health.
For Dr Williams, the priority is clear: move beyond surface-level debates and address the structural issues underpinning the system.
Dr Williams said: “There’s lots of people that think the NHS should do different things and currently, we don’t have a good shared view across the public, the staff and the government about the limits of the care that the NHS can offer or, indeed, what types of care or circumstance the NHS is built for.
“If we can find consensus on that then there will be less frustration and less disappointment.
"We need some bravery from our politicians in being able to lead those discussions.
“Before an election I don’t think is the time to find the consensus, but after an election may well be.
“We need solutions that go beyond parliamentary terms and that multiple parties can either agree to or not argue about.”
His concern is that without sustained focus on social care, workforce conditions and infrastructure, Scotland risks continuing on its current trajectory.
And that trajectory is already visible in the data – falling healthy life expectancy, widening inequalities, and a system struggling to keep pace with demand.
With the NHS once again at the centre of political debate and high on voters’ priorities, after the May election, there will be a defining test of whether the next Scottish Government is prepared to confront the structural causes of its worsening health outcomes.
Whether it becomes the “watershed moment” doctors are calling for will depend less on the breadth of manifesto pledges than on the next government’s willingness to make difficult, long-term decisions on workforce, social care and funding.
Share