Did the SNP keep its promises from the 2021 manifesto?

John Swinney taking part in CBI hustings in Edinburgh last Saturday <i>(Image: PA)</i>
John Swinney taking part in CBI hustings in Edinburgh last Saturday (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

In the run up to the 2021 Holyrood election, the SNP published a manifesto that included more than twenty specific and explicit pledges related to the Scottish education system – but how many of those promises have been kept?

With the 2026 election now just a few weeks away, The Herald has analysed each of the commitments to determine whether or not they have been achieved, either fully or in part.

Out of more than 20 individual promises, just 5 have been fully delivered - and one of those promises was met thanks to work by an opposition MSP.


Pledge: Recruit at least 3,500 additional teachers and classroom assistants - over and above the 1400 teachers recruited during the pandemic - allowing teachers more time out of the classroom to prepare lessons and improve their skills.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: The original pledge was unclear about the specific balance of recruitment, but the SNP used the first Programme for Government to clarify that it would increase teacher numbers by 3,500. In order to achieve this, the total number of teachers in Scotland had to reach 56,900 – in reality, the most recent stats confirmed that there are just 53,475 teachers across the country. This represents an increase of just 75 teachers.

The total number of ‘Pupil Support Assistants’ in Scotland currently stands at 16,908. Although this figure has fallen for the past two years, it remains more than 500 higher than was the case in 2020.

 

Pledge: Reduce teachers’ daily contact time by an hour and a half per week to give them the time they need to lift standards.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: There have been no changes to class contact time since 2021, and workforce modelling on the number of teachers that may be required to achieve the promised change was only published in 2024 – closer to the end of the parliament than the start.

Councils claimed that the policy had not been properly funded, and were reluctant to agree that the full 90 minutes of additional preparation time would be left to the discretion of individual teachers.

The government’s failure to make progress on the delivery of this pledge almost led to nationwide school strikes. Industrial action was only avoided after the government agreed that it will now “fully fund” the reduction in contact time – the total cost for this remains unspecified.

A new outline implementation timetable was agreed between the government, councils, and the EIS, which is the country’s largest teaching union, but has been rejected by the SSTA, which represents secondary school teachers.


Pledge: Build a wraparound childcare system, providing care before and after school, all year round, where the least well-off families will pay nothing.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: In government, the SNP has continued to support the expansion of funded childcare, with all three and four years olds, as well as some two year olds, eligible for 1140 hours per year; however, no system of ‘wraparound’ childcare in line with the manifesto pledge has been developed.

Instead, the SNP now says that, if elected once again, it will “extend childcare for every child in the country from nine months old to the end of primary school.” Some details of this plan have been provided, but a number of significant questions about how such a pledge might work in practice have remained unanswered, despite direct enquiries to the SNP from The Herald.


Pledge: Invest a further £1 billion to close the school attainment gap.

Result: Partially achieved.

Analysis: Over the course of the last parliament, the Scottish Government did indeed make this investment, spending a further £1bn as part of the Attainment Scotland Fund, which supports the Scottish Attainment Challenge, taking the total input to £1.75bn.

However, the party has still failed to “close the school attainment gap” – a pledge dating back to 2015 under former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, who claimed that her party would “eliminate” the difference in outcomes between rich and poor pupils.

Although key gaps in literacy and numeracy have been slightly narrowed, progress has been extremely slow, and it remains the case that pupils from affluent backgrounds are much more likely to achieve expected levels than those from deprived families. The issue is complicated by concerns about the reliability of this data after the SNP scrapped a national-sample based model and replaced it with a more subjective approach.

In other areas, attainment gaps have actually increased. This is true in the case of school leaver qualifications, with some of these divides having grown since 2015, and even where improvements have been seen the actual gaps remain huge: for the metric of pupils leaving school with at least one level six qualification (which includes Highers), the attainment gap stands at an enormous 37.7 percentage points. 


Pledge: We will provide free school breakfasts and lunches to every primary school pupil in Scotland, all year round, and for all children in state-funded special schools in Scotland. Looking longer term, we will pilot the provision of free nutritious school breakfasts in secondary schools, and, based on the findings of the pilot project, explore the feasibility of universal breakfast provision in secondary schools.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: Free school lunches are now available on a universal basis to all pupils until the end of primary 5, but the SNP U-turned on the commitment to extend this until the end of primary school: as a result, provision for pupils in primary six and primary seven is still means tested.

Breakfast clubs have not yet been introduced in every primary school. The SNP has indicated that it does intend to fund this policy, but that it will not be introduced until August 2027.

The proposed pilot of free breakfasts in secondary schools does not appear to have taken place. Changes introduced by the Scottish Government do mean that a few thousand more secondary school pupils have become eligible for a free school lunch, but this is once again means tested, applying only to those in receipt of the Scottish Child Payment benefit and who also live in one of eight council areas.


Pledge: During the pandemic, we focussed on connecting children most in need, but we will now provide every child in Scotland with a device to get online, including a free internet connection and the support to use it.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: According to an FOI response issued in 2025, the Scottish Government moved away from this universal commitment this universal commitment in 2023, describing the U-turn as a “change in approach”.

Although many councils have invested in digital technology for students, with some also providing devices on a one-to-one basis, the SNP pledge explicitly stated that the government would provide a device and free internet connection to every single child in the country, regardless of background or level of need, and entirely in addition to any Covid-era spending. There is no evidence this has been delivered in full. 


Pledge: We will support schools to provide inclusive trips and activities for all and ensure consistent practice across Scotland. Going forward we will ensure that less-well off families do not face costs for curriculum related trips and activities and that all pupils are able to attend.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: The SNP claimed that an election victory would lead to the Scottish Government “ending the exclusion of poorer pupils from trips and practical activities by ending charging for less well-off families”, but it is not clear that any specific action has taken place, or funding provided, to achieve this goal.

Many schools do seek to support families with the costs of school trips, but there is no “consistent practice across Scotland”, and such activity is often enabled by fundraising.

In 2023, the Scottish Government told The Herald that it was “working towards” its manifesto commitment, and suggested that some schools may choose to use Pupil Equity Funding to cover the cost of trips for some pupils.

 


Pledge: We will also introduce a minimum entitlement for all secondary pupils to attend at least one ‘optional’ trip during their time at school so that all pupils get to benefit from these enriching learning experiences.

Result: Achieved – but not by the Scottish Government or SNP.

Analysis: Thanks to a Bill passed by the Scottish Parliament in 2025, all secondary school pupils will now be entitled to at least “one course of residential outdoor education”, which will involve at least four overnight stays in locations such as outdoor centres, youth hostels, camps, and sailing boats.

In effect, this ensures that the SNP manifesto commitment has been met, but the Bill was not introduced by the Scottish Government – instead, this work was led by former Scottish Conservatives MSP Liz Smith.

Furthermore, the Scottish Government initially looked set to block the policy by declining to provide the necessary financial guarantees, but was forced into a U-turn following an outcry.


Pledge: Increasing the school uniform grant to at least £120 in primary school and £150 in secondary school.

Result: Achieved.

Analysis: In June 2022, the Scottish Government updated information on the school uniform grants to confirm that the levels were now set at those specified in the SNP manifesto commitment.


Pledge: As part of our drive to ensure everyone gets a fair start, and drawing from the experience of online education during the pandemic, we will expand our digital learning offer to develop a National Digital Academy. This will form part of a new Community Learning and Development Strategy and will allow learners to access the full higher curriculum, regardless of school or location. This new approach would end the postcode lottery of subject choice, and enable people to study for their Highers later in life, in their own time, fitting it around work or caring commitment.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: In 2023, education secretary Jenny Gilruth claimed that the government was “developing options for a National Digital Academy”, and that “details of timescales and funding will be available when these are complete.”

Education Scotland also commissioned a short research survey about the potential development of a National Digital Academy, but this appears to have been entirely limited to an offering for school pupils, which falls considerably short of the original SNP pledge.


Pledge: To ensure consistency across the country, we will develop statutory guidance on school uniform policies - ending expensive insistence on exclusive suppliers – and support automation of school clothing grants in every local authority to remove barriers to application and boost uptake.

Result: Partially achieved.

Analysis: The Scottish Government did issue new guidance on uniform policies for schools, but U-turned on the commitment to make this statutory, instead issuing advisory information that is not legally enforceable.

An initial draft of the guidance obtained by The Herald made clear that it was to become statutory before the end of the parliamentary term, but this statement was completed deleted from the final document. At the time, the government claimed that this had been “agreed with stakeholders”, however, stakeholders indicated this was not the case: in fact the groups involved in developing the guidance – one of whom represented businesses selling branded school uniform items – were simply “informed” of the decision, which they were told had been taken directly by Jenny Gilruth.

Initial enquiries by The Herald suggest that schools and councils across the country have not followed the new, non-statutory guidance, with some still insisting on branded items and blazers despite (non-binding) instruction to the contrary.

School clothing grant systems have also not been automated, with families still having to manually apply for financial support.


Pledge: Abolish fees for music and arts education, including instrumental music tuition in schools. To support this we will accept all recommendations of the Music Education Partnership Group, mainstreaming music as a core subject in Scotland’s education system and ensuring Scotland’s school-based instrumental music teachers receive GTCS registration and accreditation - creating a professionally-recognised national music teaching force.

Result: Partially achieved.

Analysis: The Scottish Government provided funding which allowed for the abolition of fees for music and arts education in schools, but the other two parts of this commitment have not been delivered.

Despite repeated assurances, the government did not ensure that instrumental music instructors receive full accreditation with the GTCS, Scotland’s national regulator for the teaching profession. Furthermore, no curricular changes have taken place that would make music a “core subject”, and it is not entirely clear what this would mean as Scotland’s curriculum is built on core curricular areas rather than individually mandated subjects.


Pledge: Taking the widely acclaimed TIE campaign as a model, we will create a new programme of anti-racist education in schools, including support for teachers’ professional development, allowing every school to access high quality anti-racist education. To track progress, we will improve the reporting and publication of data on racist incidents in schools.

Result: Partially achieved.

Analysis: A number of initiatives have been developed as part of the Anti-Racism in Education Programme (AREP), including the publication of new guidance in May 2025, and the provision of a range of resources related to anti-racism curricular principles entitled ‘Breaking the Mould’.

However, there appears to have been little progress on the pledge to “improve the reporting and publication of data on racist incidents in schools.” Although guidance on this matter has been issued, it simply advises schools that they must “regularly evaluate their approach to responding to racism”, noting that “establishing prevalence of racist incidents is the first step in evaluating progress.”

National information on the prevalence of racist incidents in schools does not appear to be published, and a link to the Racism and Racist Incidents Sub Group of AREP opens an inactive page on the Scottish Government website.


Pledge: We remain committed to Erasmus, and will continue to advocate for Scotland’s inclusion in the programme. Until then, we will create a Scottish programme of exchange to provide mobility and cooperation opportunities in higher education, vocational education and training, school education (including early childhood education and care), adult education, youth and sport.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: The Scottish Government faced explicit criticism for failing to deliver on this manifesto commitment. Pressed on the shortcoming during a parliamentary committee session, then-minister Graeme Dey MSP said: “We are where we are.”

The government did fund a very small pilot of a Scottish Education Exchange Programme, but its contribution was capped at just £1m; in contrast, the government in Wales invested tens of millions of pounds in its own exchange programme.

The UK will rejoin the Erasmus+ programme from 2027.


Pledge: We will produce a new International Education Strategy that will promote education alliances with other countries across Europe and the world.

Result: Achieved.

Analysis: A new strategy document was published in February 2024.


Pledge: We will encourage the creation of new GME primary and secondary schools across Scotland, backed by investment to increase the number of teachers who can teach in the medium of Gaelic. This will be with a view to strengthening the range of subjects that can be taught in GME for both a broad general education and in the senior phase of secondary school.

Result: Partially achieved.

Analysis: The Scottish Government has supported the expansion of Gaelic Medium Education (GME), with the national school-building scheme approving a bid for a new school in the Calton area of Glasgow. In June 2025, former Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes MSP announced an additional £2m in public funding to ensure that the Bun-sgoil Ghàidhlig a’ Challtainn project is completed.

The government also confirmed in 2025 that parents would have the right to request, although not demand, the establishment of a GME school in their area.

It is not clear whether any specific additional funding has been provided to increase the number of teachers able to teach in Gaelic, and the range of secondary school subjects which can be taught and examined in Gaelic has not increased.


Pledge: Providing free bikes for all children of school age who cannot afford them. Ensure every child in Scotland leaves school with the ability to cycle safely.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: In response to an FOI request in July 2025, the Scottish Government confirmed that it had spent nearly £9.5m on the Free Bikes programme since August 2021.

The total number of bikes distributed throughout this period stands at 13,244.

If this had delivered on a one-bike-per-child basis then it would have supported less than six percent of all children living in poverty in Scotland; however, the programme actually includes bikes “purchased as part of fleets, for example by schools, and used by multiple children for purposes such as cycle training.”

Although many schools offer lessons on safe cycling to pupils, there seems to be no evidence that the government has managed to “ensure” that “every child in Scotland” has acquired these skills before leaving school.


Pledge: We will further expand medical school training places by at least 100 per year and double the number of places on the Widening Access to Medicine programme to help create a more diverse medical workforce.

Result: Partially achieved.

Analysis: According into the Scottish Funding Council, the intake target for medical school places has increased by 300, rather than 500, over the past five years, and there was no recorded increase in this figure in either of the past two academic years.

However, a doubling of the number of Widening Access places has been achieved.


Pledge: We will make Active Schools programmes free for all children by the end of the parliament and continue to improve nutritional standards for food and drink in schools.

Result: Achieved.

Analysis: Since 2021, SportScotland worked with councils to remove charges for all Active Schools activities, with the manifesto commitment achieved by the beginning of the 2024/25 academic year.


Pledge: We want to make it as easy as possible for people to get the financial support they are entitled to. To do that, we believe some benefits should be linked so that if you receive one benefit as a result of having a low income, other support is automatically made available to you. We will do this wherever we can and support local authorities to do the same, for example using the Scottish Child Payment to trigger free school meals and the school clothing grant.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: It remains the case that families have to apply for support such as free school meals and the school clothing grant, even if they are in receipt of Scottish Child Payment as a qualifying benefit.


Pledge: Work with local authorities to develop a fully funded free school milk scheme which provides for children’s dietary needs.

Result: Not achieved.

Analysis: The Scottish School Milk Subsidy Scheme has been established since August 2024, but this only provides a total of £1m in funding, with each of Scotland’s 32 local authorities eligible to receive a share of the money. According to an Equality Impact Assessment, the programme provides councils with a contribution “towards their local school milk schemes”, rather than full funding. A survey carried out by the government also confirmed that many councils do not operate a school milk scheme.


Pledge: Learning from New Zealand, we will introduce a School Leavers’ Toolkit to equip school leavers with practical skills for life such as financial literacy, budgeting and information on how to exercise their full civic and democratic rights.

Result: Partially achieved.

Analysis: An online School Leavers’ Toolkit has been launched via the My World of Work platform from Skills Development Scotland. The website provides links to support and information from organisations including Young Scot, Job Centre Plus, SAMH, and Shelter Scotland.

However, the service provided in New Zealand is significantly more extensive, also incorporating a teacher-facing website and curricular integration frameworks to ensure that the toolkit can be incorporated in wider school life.


Pledge: We need more young people and women to want to be farmers and land managers but the role is changing. We will therefore undertake a root and branch review of land-based education from early years to adulthood to provide opportunities and qualifications through school, college, university and apprenticeships for more people, and specifically more women, to work with and on the land, particularly in green skills.

Result: Achieved.

Analysis: A review of land-based learning was carried out by an independent commissioner, and the Scottish Government issued its response to those findings in April 2024.


 


In response to The Herald’s queries about the outcome of 2021 manifesto commitments, the SNP issued a statement from a spokesperson which began:

"The SNP is improving the opportunities and educational outcomes of Scotland’s young people with spending on schools across Scotland increasing by more than £1 billion in real terms over the past decade – with the SNP in government committing to spend £3.5billion on education and skills committed to in the budget for 2026/27."

The statement then claimed that “literacy and numeracy attainment are at the highest levels on record, the poverty-related attainment gap was at a record low level last year, and near record levels of young people are going into work, education or training.” The Herald has previously analysed these claims, noting that data on literacy and numeracy goes back less than a decade, that some measures of the poverty-related attainment gap have increased, and that data on post-school destinations remains problematic.

The statement also noted that teacher numbers have “increased by more than 2,700 over the last decade”, but neglected to mention that this followed a significant fall after the SNP took office in 2007, and that total numbers have never returned to the levels that the party inherited.

The spokesperson also referenced the 2026 manifesto pledge to establish year-round childcare provision, but did not address the fact that a similar, unfulfilled promise had been included in the 2021 manifesto.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos