Unionist voters may back SNP to block Reform, expert says

Anas Sarwar, John Swinney and Malcolm Offord dominate the Channel 4 leaders' debate. <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Anas Sarwar, John Swinney and Malcolm Offord dominate the Channel 4 leaders' debate. (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Pro-Union voters could back the SNP to keep Reform UK out in some Holyrood contests, a polling expert has said.

Professor Ailsa Henderson, who leads the Scottish Election Study, said there is growing evidence tactical voting at the 2026 election will not follow the usual Yes-No split.

While the “bulk” of tactical voting is still expected to be aimed at defeating the SNP, she said Reform’s emergence as a major force could disrupt that pattern, with some voters willing to cross the constitutional divide.

Speaking on the BBC’s Sunday Show, Prof Henderson said: “Most of the tactical voting in Scottish elections has been anti-SNP tactical voting.

“It reached over 80%, it was 83% in 2021, and it does look as if that will remain the bulk of tactical voting, but more than half of it will be anti-SNP tactical voting.”

However, Prof Henderson pointed to recent polling by Norstat, which tested how voters would behave in head-to-head contests between parties.

Sign up to Unspun Election Briefing – our 8am Holyrood campaign newsletter

“And mostly we see the continued within-constitutional-bloc tactical voting, but the exception is SNP versus Reform contests," the academic said.

In those scenarios, she said, a large share of pro-Union voters indicated they would back the SNP rather than Nigel Farage's party.

“We see that two thirds of Labour voters and three quarters of Lib Dem voters say that they would rather cast a ballot for the SNP than they would for Reform,” she said.

“It could be that the arrival of Reform is causing a breakdown of that within-constitutional-bloc tactical voting,” she said. “So that would mean we’re in a very different situation from 2021.”

Prof Henderson said the Scottish Election Study had found 15% of voters already planning to cast a tactical ballot earlier this year — a high figure at this stage of the campaign.

Previous elections have seen pro-Union voters shift between Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats in order to maximise the chances of defeating SNP candidates in individual seats.

“In all cases, that was pro-Union voters shuffling across different pro-Union parties, reducing the non-competitive parties to less than single-digit support so as to put all their support behind the party that they felt was best placed to defeat the SNP,” Professor Henderson said.

Recent Scottish Election Study analysis suggests Reform is highly polarising, with around two thirds of voters indicating that they would never consider casting a ballot for the party.

At the same time, the broader political landscape appears increasingly fragmented, with no party enjoying much in the way of broad-based appeal across the electorate.

Public opinion has also become notably more pessimistic about the direction of the country.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos