Insight

Holyrood 2026: What the election means for independence

A young girl running with a Saltire at an independence rally <i>(Image: Colin Mearns)</i>
A young girl running with a Saltire at an independence rally (Image: Colin Mearns)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

At a lunch in Edinburgh attended by politicians, academics and diplomats back in January the talk in the room was about Donald Trump and his quest, at the time, to take over Greenland and impose new tariffs on the UK and six other European countries which opposed the move.

Hope was expressed by some attendees that there would be a new EU referendum amid fears the UK could end up isolated in a tense world.

There was also a degree of bemusement that faced with increasing global uncertainty John Swinney was demanding a new vote on Scottish independence.

"Why is the First Minister stepping up the independence demand now?" one puzzled European visitor asked me.

John Swinney at Edinburgh's Bute House last year (Image: Gordon Terris)

To many outside Scotland it seemed a curious moment to be choosing to fight for national sovereignty but through the lens of domestic politics of course the timing made sense.

As observers quickly noted Mr Swinney's new drive for independence - putting the constitution at the heart of his offer to voters with a pledge that a majority of SNP seats will be a mandate for indyref2 - is essentially a strategy to motivate the party's core voters to back the SNP on May 7.

If the SNP leader can next month persuade a large section of Scots committed to independence to support the party his path to Bute House is eased.

But what of independence? Is independence closer should the SNP achieve its ambition of returning to power once again, and with a majority, for a record fifth term?


Read More:


The blunt answer is that whatever the result on May 7, SNP win with a majority, SNP win, SNP defeat, an independence vote is no closer.

This is for the simply reason that Sir Keir Starmer's UK Labour Government will not budge in its opposition to a new vote whatever the result.

Dr Fraser McMillan, lecturer in Scottish Electoral Politics at the University of Edinburgh, did not think that position will change under a new Labour Prime Minister should Starmer be forced to stand down as his leadership comes under increasing pressure in the ongoing controversy over his appointment of Peter Mandelson as the UK ambassador to the US.

"The outcome of the election won't put pressure on this UK government either way. They've been very clear that they won't entertain the idea of a second referendum and are dealing with massive international and domestic challenges, not least the likely economic impact of the new Gulf War," Dr McMillan told The Herald.

"Labour are obviously also facing internal difficulties, with the replacement of Starmer looking more a question of when not if. I can't see any scenario in which they agree to an indyref before the next general election."

And what would be the consequences for independence if , as most polls suggest, the SNP win the election but not get a majority of seats?

Scots go to the polls on May 7 to elect a new Scottish Parliament (Image: PA)

Dr McMillan said such a scenario would provide the First Minister with perhaps an welcome opportunity to pause the debate.

"The First Minister's pledge to pursue a referendum only if the SNP won a majority served two strategic purposes: to signal to their core pro-indy voters that they still cared about the issue and to provide a pretext to kick it into the long grass after the election on the assumption they wouldn't win a majority, bearing in mind this seemed quite unlikely at the time," he added.

Should there be such a pause in what seems like indyref2 constant demands it could be a chance for the SNP to recalibrate and update its arguments for independence in a world much changed from 2014.

In terms of the goal for an independent Scotland to seek entry into the EU, the Scottish Government updated its case last year.


Read More:


Dr Kirsty Hughes, an EU expert and fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, said the 2025 paper presented a good overview of the process for joining the EU as an independent member state which remains valid today.

However, she added it failed to tackle a number of key issues.

"What the Scottish Government did not address in that paper was how Scotland would handle the twin transitions of leaving the UK and joining the EU," she said.

"It is normal for a state in accession talks with the EU to agree an association agreement with the EU to cover relations with the EU before actually joining.

"There is then also a question of what happens in the period of a few months after independence when Scotland is no longer in the EU-UK trade and cooperation agreement and doesn't yet have an association agreement. Perhaps Scotland could stay in the EU UK deal somehow. In our unstable geopolitical times being clear on the transition years is vital."

European Union flags outside the European Commission building (Image: Carl Court)

Dr Hughes went onto add that the Scottish Government may find "handling the necessarily informal politics and diplomacy" with EU states which now have a more positive relationship with the UK Labour Government than in the days when the Conservatives were in power at Westminster.

"This will be trickier than two years ago as UK EU relations are much better. And in these difficult geopolitical times, EU leaders would be wary of the UK fragmenting," she added.

"The more positive EU understanding of Scotland's independence in the face of Brexit ten years ago is less so now. Simply, the politics and the world have moved on."

So what then about the other big change since 2014 - geopolitics. Twelve years ago the world was considerably more calm.

Now we have a new Gulf War raging, a US President ambivalent about Nato and a Russian invasion of Ukraine which shows little sign of ending.

Ed Arnold, senior associate fellow at the Royal United Services Institute in London, said defence and security would feature much more significantly in a future independence referendum than in 2014.

He thought it would be impossible for the SNP to argue, as it did 12 years ago, to get rid of Trident at Faslane and for an independent Scotland to become a member of Nato.

"They [the SNP] will absolutely have to change their policy on the nuclear deterrent. I don't see any other option. They would be saying we don't want the UK deterrent but we are happy to be covered by the Nato nuclear deterrent," he said.

"Nato members would not look favourably on a Scottish Government which would effectively make Nato's job much more difficult."

He added removing Trident could also antagonise Nato EU members meaning John Swinney or a future SNP leader would have to convince his party to reverse its position on Trident.

"It would be difficult for him to sell, but back in 2014 some of these things were theoretically. Finland and Sweden have just joined Nato in record time due to the international environment," he said.

"The countries that make up Nato are focussed on potentially going to war with Russia in the next couple of years which would have a nuclear dimension.

"Therefore Nato would strongly oppose anything that puts a question mark over the nuclear deterrent."

So if the SNP use the remaining years of the UK Labour Government to update the case for independence when could a new vote happen?

The current stalemate seems set to continue for the next few years but there may be an opportunity after the next general election.

Polls currently point to Nigel Farage's Reform UK winning the next general election, ousting Labour from power at Westminster.

Nigel Farage and Malcolm Offord launch Reform UK's Holyrood manifesto (Image: Colin Mearns)

Mr Farage has taken a notably softer stance than both Labour and the Conservatives to the prospect of a second independence referendum.

Back in March, he opened the door - and raised a potential timetable - for a second independence referendum in just over a decade.

"People were promised here in 2014 that the referendum on separation from the United Kingdom was a once in a generation thing, which would mean about 25 years," he said during his party's manifesto launch in Bishopton though he added he doubted "there will ever be a popular will for a vote to break up the United Kingdom".

Dr McMillan noted the scenario and that previous polls have pointed to support Scottish independence rising if Mr Farage became PM.

"The landscape could change dramatically in 2029 and [the SNP] will be very aware of that and position themselves accordingly," Dr McMillan said.

"If Nigel Farage becomes Prime Minister, you'd expect that to have an impact on public attitudes to the constitution, and Reform have signalled that they aren't completely opposed to the idea of another referendum eventually."

Such a situation presents the prospect that the SNP could benefit from Mr Farage winning the 2029 election.

It is a situation neither the party nor its leader wish to contemplate.

Asked earlier this month by The Herald's Political Editor Andrew Learmonth if he would welcome a UK Government run by Reform in a bid to get a second independence referendum, the First Minister simply said: "I think the best way to get an independence referendum is for the SNP to get a majority on 7 May."

So it seems that unless Labour change its opposition to a new independence vote after 2029 - which seems unlikely given its opposition to date - the SNP's ambitions for a second independence referendum within the coming years looks like they will rest on the fortunes of their arch opponents.

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos