'This is not a marginal service - it's a critical artery'

With the right investment and imagination our ferries could do more <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
With the right investment and imagination our ferries could do more (Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A Highland community has warned that prolonged ferry disruption is putting businesses and livelihoods under threat.

The Mallaig to Armadale service has been operating at around 10% of the normal capacity due to vessels being diverted to other routes.

CalMac say "difficult decisions" are having to be made in order to prioritise some routes.

The long-running disruption is said to be causing growing economic and social harm to both the Mallaig and Skye communities.

Described as a critical "economic artery," the ferry carries more than 200,000 passengers annually and forms a vital part of the popular "over the sea to Skye" tourism circuit.

Weeks of disruption are said to have resulted in cancelled trips, lost bookings, and reduced visitor numbers, leading to mounting financial losses during a key part of the tourism season.

The Mallaig community has also been hit by a delay in the running of the Jacobite steam train. West Coast Railways is currently waiting to find out if they will be granted an exemption to run the service ahead of installing central door locking.

The MV Coruisk and Loch Fyne would normally take in excess of 300 vehicles a day to Skye from Mallaig - around 1000 passengers - and the same on the return journey. 

The current provision can only allow for four vehicles at a time, plus driver, and is running three or four times a day but it is not always operational.

Passengers are using the Larven from Western Isles Cruises and Miss Marley and Spanish John from Milligan transport.

A spokesman for the Mallaig Community Council said: "This is not a marginal service - it is a critical economic artery.

"Treating it as expendable puts the future of our rural communities at risk.

"We refuse to be invisible in this crisis.

"The Lord of the Isles has not returned either to do the Mallaig-Lochboisdale run - which is also a big blow to the communities on both sides."

Businesses on both the mainland and Skye say they are being overlooked and currently do not qualify for the Scottish Government’s compensation schemes, which are limited to island businesses only.

The community council has called for formal recognition of the crossing’s importance, a full impact assessment, access to financial support for all affected businesses, investment in dedicated relief vessels, and an end to routine vessel redeployment from the route.

Communities believe the disruption highlights a long-standing trend of the service being deprioritised in favour of other routes.


Read more:


A CalMac spokeswoman said: “Due to our services being stretched while several vessels are unavailable, it’s not currently possible to provide the level of service we would like to. This is understandably frustrating for customers and local communities, and we are sorry for the disruption.

 “Mallaig-Armadale is a valued service, and we recognise how important it is. We are working hard to ensure that the route is covered in these difficult circumstances, but we must make difficult decisions when it comes to prioritising other routes which don’t have any alternative options to and from the mainland.

 “We have chartered replacement vessels for Mallaig-Armadale until MV Coruisk returns but recognise that there has been a significant reduction in their service delivery.

"The intention had been for MV Loch Bhrusda to operate on this route, but the vessel must remain on the Sound of Harris service while MV Loch Portain is delayed in annual overhaul.

"MV Coruisk is also required on the Oban-Craignure route to meet booking demand."

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos