Scottish Labour is facing fierce criticism after Anas Sarwar signalled he would not pursue abortion law reform in the next parliament, putting the party at odds with expert recommendations and a position previously backed by its own members
The Scottish Labour leader has told The Herald his party is "not planning" on "changing abortion rights in the next parliament" if they come into office.
The intervention has sparked backlash from pro-choice group Back Off Scotland which expressed disappointment at the party’s position.
Lucy Grieve is co-founder of Back Off Scotland and policy and engagement manager at the British Pregnancy Advisory Service.
She told The Herald: “We are disappointed that Scottish Labour's women's manifesto does not include commitments on abortion - a routine healthcare procedure that one in three women will undergo during their lifetimes, and a right which has been under political attack around the world in recent years."
Lucy Grieve, Co-Founder of Back Off Scotland, and Policy and Engagement Manager at the British Pregnancy Advisory Service (Image: supplied)
Responding to Mr Sarwar's comments, Ms Grieve, whose campaign group successfully called for the introduction of anti-abortion buffer zones outside hospitals and clinics in Scotland, added: "It is not enough for politicians to say that standing for the status quo on abortion puts you on the side of women.
"Every four days a woman travels hundreds of miles to England to access abortion care that she is legally entitled to receive in Scotland but cannot access. Just last year an expert group established by the government found that Scotland's abortion laws are outdated, out of line with best practice, and in need of reform.
"These are urgent matters for women’s health and rights that the next Scottish Government must engage with.”
READ MORE:
- Sarwar: Labour manifesto admits 'we got it wrong’ on single-sex spaces
- Expert group urges sweeping reform of abortion law in Scotland
- Scottish Government accused of missing abortion care solutions target
- Labour MP calls for Scotland to decriminalise abortion
- Mackay: Decriminalising abortion is my next Holyrood goal
Mr Sarwar told The Herald this week that Scottish Labour has not planned to pursue legislative change on the issue as he unveiled his party’s 'Women’s Manifesto':
The Scottish Labour leader said during a trip to Cumnock on Monday: "We are not planning any changes to abortion rights in the next parliament. We will protect the existing protections in law."
He added: “We will keep the provisions and protections around abortion rights in the next parliament.
“I am happy to engage with campaigners, I'm happy to engage with individuals. This is the democratic process we went through as a party and our plans are not to change abortion rights in the next parliament.”
The party’s manifesto commits to “protect women's reproductive rights, ensuring they are able to access the full range of reproductive services, no matter where they live”.
Mr Sarwar said the document had been developed with “leading women’s voices within our party” and had received "unanimous" backing at a Clause V meeting, Labour’s internal process for formally signing off election manifestos, indicating the stance has full support from the party’s leadership and affiliates.
The position comes despite Scottish Labour members previously backing calls for abortion law reform.
Delegates at Scottish Labour’s 2023 conference voted in favour of a motion committing the party to help build a campaign for the decriminalisation of abortion in Scotland, aligning it with advocacy groups and medical bodies calling for abortion to be removed from criminal law.
Senior Labour figures have also previously backed calls for reform. In 2019, Monica Lennon lodged a parliamentary motion supporting the decriminalisation of abortion, backed by colleagues including Jackie Baillie and Pauline McNeill.
Lennon has also submitted evidence to Holyrood committees in support of changing the law.
Scottish Labour MPs, including Katrina Murray and Lilian Jones, have also called for the decriminalisation of abortion in Scotland after MPs voted to do so south of the border.
Last month, peers in the House of Lords backed the plans to decriminalise abortion.
Mr Sarwar's remarks also come amid increasing pressure to modernise Scotland’s abortion laws more broadly.
An independent Abortion Law Expert Group, commissioned under the Scottish Government’s 2023–24 Programme for Government, concluded last year that the current system is “not fit for purpose” and should be reformed to treat abortion as a healthcare matter rather than one governed by criminal law.
The panel recommended sweeping changes, including removing criminal sanctions and allowing abortion on request within gestational limits, while maintaining the 24-week limit - proposals backed by a wide range of medical bodies and reproductive health organisations.
In its report, the group said: “Criminal sanctions against abortion should be removed unless they are deemed necessary and proportionate…”
Adding: “There should be no offences for anyone ending their own pregnancy and any common law offences should be repealed.”
Scottish Labour has said they are committed to protecting women's reproductive rights.
Asked if the party currently supports the decriminalisation of abortion, a party spokesperson said: “Scottish Labour is committed to protecting women’s reproductive rights, ensuring they can access the full range of reproductive services no matter where they live.
“Positions are adopted through the policy forum process, designed by members, and agreed through our specific policy conference.
“It has never featured in a Scottish manifesto or policy paper.”
Share