Sir Tom slams independence as 'distraction' after election

Sir Tom Hunter issued a call for unity after the Scottish election <i>(Image: Scottish Prostate Cancer Initiative/PA Wire)</i>
Sir Tom Hunter issued a call for unity after the Scottish election (Image: Scottish Prostate Cancer Initiative/PA Wire)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

One of Scotland’s best-known business figures has declared that it is “time for radical thinking” to kick-start the Scottish economy following the election that has delivered victory for the SNP.

Entrepreneur turned philanthropist Sir Tom Hunter attacked the SNP for presiding over “19 years of stagnation at best, and decline in health, education and the economy at worst” - despite the party's sustained electoral success - and slammed the prospect of independence for Scotland as a “distraction”.

Urging people to “come together and build a better country” following an election campaign that betrayed deep divisions within Scotland, he offered to establish a “business council” of “exceptional talents” to support ministers in the next parliamentary term. This council would put “Scotland first, politics second", pledged Sir Tom, who made his fortune after building up Sports Division and selling it to JJB Sports for £290 million in 1998.

The business leader said: “For the love of Scotland can we all come together and build a better country? Today we herald in a new Government, after 19 years of stagnation at best, and decline in health, education and the economy at worst – so it’s time for radical thinking. More of the same will offer an appalling legacy to our children so are our politicians up for it?

“My offer is to deliver a business council to support them – a council of exceptional talents; Scotland first, politics second.


Read more:


“Patently we have a lot of new MSPs with little or no business experience, so I’d hope that offer is accepted. Independence is a distraction, the loss of Barnett a £50 billion cost – what we need is competent Government focussed on economic growth. How else can we pay for the challenges ahead?

“With a gaping £5bn black hole in our economy looming for 2030, whoever is in power has to have answers.”

Sir Tom tabled a series of recommendations to improve Scotland’s fiscal position, with item one a call for government and business work in partnership to “truly ignite a growth trajectory that will deliver economic growth and more funds to support those most in need”.

He offered to fund a review of the current tax system through The Hunter Foundation, the vehicle for his family’s philanthropic work, and define with government a “fair, equitable and growth tax alternative” to the existing arrangements.

“No more nurses losing £1,500 to their English counterparts when earning £50,000 or more,” he said. “And ending the absurd clamp on productivity with workers shunning overtime and promotions for fear of entering the ‘broadest shoulders’ regime.”

In a proposal that will likely win support from the hospitality and retail sectors, Sir Tom hit out at the current business rates system, calling on the new Scottish Government to “release the handbrake on growth and employment that was the non-domestic rates review complete with scandalous increases until a fair and transparent system can be designed”.

And he made an impassioned plea for the North Sea oil and gas licences – a reserved power – to be opened up to address the energy crisis.

Sir Tom said: “My ask of whoever is in government now is this: what’s your 90-day plan and does any of this feature in it?

“Today we have an opportunity to either think radically or do what we have always done, and we know where that has left us – with a £5bn black hole.”

Sir Tom declared there should be more support for scaling businesses, stating that "if we added 50% more in five years we’d add over 100,000 jobs and up to £18 billion to the Scottish economy", and called for planning applications for any housing development over 500 houses to be fast-tracked to address the housing crisis.

Sir Tom also made the case for a “radical culling of duplicate agencies and staffing in the public sector”, for frontline NHS staff to have play a role in improving the health service, and to allow “head teachers have autonomy to run their own schools”.

Meanwhile, Scottish hospitality chiefs wasted no time in ramping up calls for the next administration at Holyrood to put business rates reform at the top the agenda.

Both the Scottish Licensed Trade Association and Scottish Hospitality Group outlined the urgency of reform as many outlets contend with potentially unmanageable rises in rates bills following the most recent revaluation of non-domestic property. Some businesses are facing increases in the range of 400% to 500%,

The SLTA also called for the appointment of a dedicated tourism and hospitality minister, for the 'new deal for business' to be kick-started, and for a freeze or delay on further legislation or regulation that impacts on businesses.

Colin Wilkinson, managing director of the SLTA, said: “Nothing on our wish list is new – it’s what we’ve been calling for over many years now. However, the Scottish Parliament election presents us with an opportunity to reiterate to the new Scottish Government that the licensed trade and hospitality sectors really do need some help.

“And as we all look forward to a fresh start, we urge the new government to accept that the time for talking shops is over – it’s action that’s required now, not words."

Stephen Montgomery, director of the SHG, called for the revaluations that form the basis of business rates to be halted and for an emergency summit involving government and industry representatives. He said: “The elections are now over, MSPs have been elected, and the focus must immediately turn to the real issues affecting businesses across Scotland.

“Hospitality cannot afford to wait any longer. Across the sector, businesses are facing enormous financial pressures, but the issue causing the greatest fear right now in Scotland, is the horrendous non-domestic rates hikes many operators have received.

“Some businesses are facing increases of between 400% and 500%. These are not manageable rises; they are potentially business ending.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos