The Scottish Government has overturned a decision by Edinburgh councillors to block the construction of student accommodation as part of the city's multimillion New Town Quarter.
The 2.37 hectare site, which is bounded by Dundas Street and King George V Park, was last occupied by the Royal Bank of Scotland.
First reported in the Broughton Spurtle, planning consent will be granted once a Section 75 legal agreement is reached between City of Edinburgh Council and co-developers Izar V Lux S. à r. L and Fusion.
“For the reasons given below I am minded to allow the appeal and grant planning permission subject to the conditions listed below,” government planning reporter Declan King wrote last week.
The huge site is being prepared for the construction of hundreds of homes. (Image: Newsquest)
Requirements include the provision of £647,956 for additional primary-school capacity, £1,047,956 for additional secondary-school capacity, £508,165 for trams improvements and expansion, and a commitment to 35 per cent affordable housing.
Councillors had already approved plans to build around 300 residential units on the six acre plot of land, but developers later applied to build a 591 bed purpose-built student accommodation (PBSA) on the site.
In October 2025, work began on the already approved plans.
Mr King wrote: “[The proposal] includes several changes to the previously approved development, while generally retaining its overall built form. Blocks 1 to 5 and the mid-market rental block would be retained for residential use. Block 6 would be developed for residential rather than office use.
“The two sections of the permitted development that hold permission for build to rent residential development would instead be developed as purpose built student accommodation (PBSA).”
Last winter, Edinburgh councillors voted 7-4 to withhold planning permission for the updated development, against the advice of council officers.
Ross McNulty, the development director at Ediston Real Estate, which is managing the development process, said at the time: “We’re obviously disappointed with the outcome of the committee meeting.
“We’ll take some time to reflect on the outcome and the debate at committee about the proposals before we decide how to respond.”
He added: “We can’t help but observe that the committee missed an opportunity that would have delivered many new homes quickly that would help tackle the housing emergency.”
Hundreds of responses were received in opposition to the proposal, leading the council to reject the proposal in December 2025.
Read more:
- Appeal lodged over refusal of Scottish city centre's largest new homes site
- New Town Quarter: Work starts on Edinburgh city centre’s major new housing project
- 'Disappointing': Plan for hundreds of new homes at former bank site refused
Mr King wrote: “Concerns have been raised by the council and objectors that the density of the proposed development would be out of character with its surroundings.
“Concerns have also been raised that the density of the development could have an adverse impact on local amenities, including King George V Park.
“I disagree,” Mr King added. “The location of this site, in proximity to local services, public transport provisions and within walking distance of the city centre, lends itself to a high density development.
“The high density layout proposed conforms to the provisions regarding local living and 20 minute neighbourhoods …”
Share