Exclusive

Call for review of all students sanctioned for AI-cheating

 <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
(Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Scotland’s only exam board is facing calls for an investigation after admitting it cannot be sure that a “fair and robust process” was followed before a student was punished for cheating through the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI).

Qualifications Scotland (formerly known as the SQA) has now reinstated the student’s full grade following an appeal, but an opposition MSP has called on government ministers to “urgently order a review of every pupil sanctioned over alleged AI use” and questioned whether the public can trust the body charged with overseeing exams across the country.

Many Qualifications Scotland courses require students to submit coursework in some form, with that material then assessed and graded as part of the overall award for those subjects

The Herald recently reported that the exam board had been accused of treating pupils in a “grossly unfair” manner due to its decision to punish pupils for use of AI without being able to be certain that they had cheated.

Now one student who was accused of malpractice with respect to their Higher English portfolio has been informed of a U-turn.

The Higher English course requires students to submit one piece of writing that is either creative or discursive. Up to fifteen marks are available for this submission, with that score representing 30 percent of the final grade. An initial draft of the essay is completed in class, and the final version must remain solely the work of the individual student – direct support from tutors, family members, or generative AI are not permitted.

The student in question, who wishes to remain anonymous, was accused of using AI to help develop the essay in their portfolio, as well as receiving assistance from a family member that fell outwith the rules.

Qualifications Scotland advised that the portfolio essay was to be rejected, meaning that the student would lose the full 30% of the overall marks available. This would have made it almost impossible to achieve an A grade, despite the student in question working at this level throughout the year in all five Higher courses they were studying.

However, in a letter to the student’s headteacher, Qualifications Scotland has now confirmed that an appeal has been successful. As a result, the sanctions have been cancelled and the exam board has declared that “no finding of malpractice will remain in place.”

The decision was made by interim Chief Operating Officer Catriona Campbell, who states that the original decision of the Candidate Malpractice Panel, which imposed the penalty, “appears to have been based on an initial candidate malpractice referral from a marker who suspected AI use.”

Ms Campbell also refers to “AI detection software indicating the presence of AI generated text in the learner’s submission” as well as “information from the malpractice investigation stating that a family member had provided direction that informed the final submission.”

However, she goes on advise that she has “identified concerns regarding whether all relevant evidence was fully considered” during this process. She notes that the panel was not in possession of additional examples of the student’s writing, despite requesting them, and that its notes about the weighting it gave to the professional judgement of the student’s teachers were “unclear”.

Ms Campbell goes on to state that her role is not to judge the authenticity of the work in question, but rather that she “must be satisfied that the panel reached its decision through a fair and robust process, taking account of all relevant evidence.”

She continued: “In this case, I cannot be satisfied that the correct process was followed or that all relevant evidence was appropriately considered before the panel reached its conclusions.” As a result, she adds that she is “unable to conclude that the malpractice decision was reached is sound.”

The letter subsequently confirms that the student’s writing portfolio will be included in their final Higher English grade, but does not include an apology.


READ MORE


Speaking exclusively to The Herald, the affected student said that the exam board’s conduct had affected them throughout the exam period and sharply criticised Qualifications Scotland’s communication during this time.

They said that the “whole process was incredibly stressful and emotionally draining”, pointing out that the allegations were first raised in May but have not been resolved until mid-July, after the conclusion of the exam period. This, they said, had affected them as they studied for and sat their Higher exams.

They added: “The thing that worried me most was the thought that I might have to resit Higher English. I was constantly thinking about how it could affect my plans for next year and whether I’d still be able to move on to my Advanced Highers. Instead of being able to focus on my exams like everyone else, I was carrying this with me every day.

“What made it even harder was that English has always been one of my strongest subjects. I got A grades in every Higher English test and prelim I sat, and my predicted grades were As in every one of my Higher subjects. Even with that, I still had to spend months trying to prove that my work was actually mine.

“My folio was about abuse and gambling addiction and how they can destroy lives and families. It was a persuasive and informative piece where I used statistics, but I also shared my own personal experiences. Writing it was already incredibly difficult because I had to relive things that had happened in my own life. When I finally finished it, I felt so relieved. It honestly felt like something inside me had healed.

“To then have that piece of work flagged as AI was one of the most hurtful parts of the whole experience. It felt so insulting because those were my experiences and my words. I had opened up about something so personal, and then I spent months having to prove that I had actually written it. That was heart-breaking.”

They went on to say that although they are “very relieved that the appeal was successful”, the communication from Qualifications Scotland has been “poor” – noting that there were “long periods where I had no idea what was happening, and the waiting just made the stress even worse:

“I really hope my experience makes people realise how much this kind of accusation can affect a student. It doesn’t just impact your grades. It affects your confidence, your mental wellbeing and your future. I don’t think anyone should have to spend months defending work that they know is their own, especially when it’s based on their own life.”

Commenting for the Scottish Conservatives, education and equalities spokesperson Meghan Gallacher MSP said: “This is a damning indictment of an SNP education quango that was supposed to represent a fresh start after the failures of the SQA.

“Instead, pupils are facing potentially life-changing consequences from a process that Qualifications Scotland itself cannot even guarantee was fair or properly followed.

“The SNP cannot simply slap a new name on a discredited organisation and pretend the problems have disappeared. Mairi McAllan as the new education secretary must urgently order a review of every pupil sanctioned over alleged AI use and her predecessor Jenny Gilruth should explain how she allowed such serious questions to arise over the fairness of Scotland’s exam system.

“After nearly two decades of SNP mismanagement of Scottish education, pupils, parents and teachers deserve far better than yet another failing quango they cannot trust.”

Duncan Dunlop MSP, education spokesperson for the Scottish Liberal Democrats, said that those sitting exams "expect to be treated fairly", and that it "must be very tough to be dragged over the coals accused of cheating when you did nothing of the sort."

He added that the widespread use of AI "makes it all the more important that decisions are reached through an appropriate process", and that "reviewing how the candidate malpractice panel assesses the use of AI would be a sensible step."

In addition, Laura Moodie, education spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, said that the "integrity of Scotland's qualifications system is hugely important" and that it is "right that Qualifications Scotland investigates concerns about the misuse of AI."

She added:

"Any decisions affecting a young person's future must be made through a process that is fair, robust and based on all the available evidence. Young people need to have confidence that they are being treated fairly, and teachers need to know that their professional judgement is being given proper consideration.

"I welcome the fact that concerns about the process have been identified and acted upon through the appeals system. Qualifications Scotland should now take the opportunity to reassure students, families and schools that its procedures are being applied consistently and fairly in every case.

"As AI becomes a bigger issue in education, maintaining public confidence in both the integrity of qualifications and the fairness of decision-making processes is essential."

Qualifications Scotland has been asked to confirm how many students were facing some form of sanction for the use of AI in coursework submissions, how many of those appealed, and what proportion of those appeals had been successful. The exam board was also asked to confirm the number of students potentially affected by this issue.

Officials declined to provide this information, which they advised would be released later in the year.

The exam board was also asked whether it could be sure that other students had been treated fairly, and what actions had been taken to address any concerns about the reliability of the work of the Candidate Malpractice Panel.

A spokesperson said: “Malpractice processes are an essential part of ensuring the integrity of our qualifications. We cannot comment on individual cases but acknowledge that malpractice investigations are stressful for those being investigated. We therefore always seek to resolve cases as quickly as possible but they can be unavoidably complex and time-consuming. Candidates' right to appeal a malpractice outcome is an important part of the process.”

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “Qualifications Scotland operates independently from ministers and is responsible for its own operational decisions, including investigating instances of potential malpractice. There is also an appeals process in place for those affected.

 “AI is increasingly part of all our lives, and the Scottish Government published guidance earlier this year which aims to support children, young people, and teachers to grasp the opportunities and navigate the challenges of AI.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos