Graeme Roy

Scottish Budget faces largest reckoning since devolution

Devolved fiscal outcomes are never determined solely by decisions made in Holyrood <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Devolved fiscal outcomes are never determined solely by decisions made in Holyrood (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Last month, figures confirming how much Scottish income tax was raised in 2024-25 were published.

This might appear to be a largely technical update. In one sense, it is. But the figures point to a provisional £728 million reduction in the funding available for the 2027-28 Scottish Budget, the largest reconciliation since devolution . It also tells us something important about the risks built into fiscal devolution and how they can be best managed.

Income tax enters the Scottish Budget through a process built around two forecasts.

First, at the Scottish Fiscal Commission (SFC), we forecast how much income tax will be raised in Scotland. That forecast determines the amount included in the Scottish Budget for the year ahead.


Read more:


Second, the Office for Budget Responsibility forecasts equivalent revenues in the rest of the UK (strictly speaking just England and Northern Ireland given that Wales also now has income tax devolution). This determines something called the income tax block grant adjustment.

Why? When income tax was devolved, the Scottish Government began keeping those revenues raised here. So, in return, an equivalent amount was deducted from the Scottish Government’s block grant from Westminster – "an adjustment" – with the size of that adjustment year-on-year determined by the growth of rUK income tax revenues.

The difference between Scottish revenues and that adjustment is the net tax position. If Scottish revenues grow more quickly than elsewhere in the UK, the Scottish Budget benefits from a positive net tax position. If they grow more slowly, it loses out.

But both figures are forecasts. The Budget is initially set using estimates. Around two years later, once the actual figures are available, the accounts are corrected. The difference is then applied to a future Budget: a so-called "reconciliation".


Read more:


Forecast errors are inevitable. What matters is their size and how, in combination, they affect the net position. This year, that combination has been particularly unfavourable.

Scottish income tax raised £18.6 billion in 2024-25, an increase of 9% compared to 2023-24. But revenues in England and Northern Ireland grew by 10.2%. Relative to the forecasts used when the Budget was set, Scottish revenues were £209m lower than forecast, while the block grant adjustment was £519m higher.

Together, they produce the reconciliation of £728m. That exceeds the Scottish Government’s forecast borrowing limit. Even if Ministers maximise their borrowing, the reconciliation will still reduce funding for public services. Remember too that all borrowing must ultimately be repaid.

This is why the figures matter. Whilst they are technical corrections, ensuring that the Budget eventually reflects the revenues actually raised, their significance lies in their knock-on implications for overall funding.


Read more:


But reconciliations should not be confused with the underlying health of the tax base. A more fundamental issue is long-term economic performance. Here the latest data highlights another risk.

The Scottish Government has used its tax powers to raise more revenue, particularly from higher earners. But the full benefit has been eroded because earnings and employment have grown less quickly than in the rest of the UK. The latest outturn means that this tax-base performance gap is likely to be larger than previously expected.

For 2024-25, relatively slower revenue growth from high earners appears to be part of the explanation.

The distinction between policy control and economic outcomes matters beyond Scotland, as Andy Burnham seeks to deepen devolution in England. In principle, devolution allows decisions to reflect local circumstances.


Read more:


But institutional design matters too. Meaningful devolution transfers risk: greater reward when local performance improves, but greater exposure when it does not.

A risk to manage carefully is that devolved fiscal outcomes are never determined solely by devolved decisions. In Scotland, weaker income growth in areas connected to North Sea oil and gas has affected tax performance, even though many forces shaping that transition sit outside Holyrood’s control.

Devolution is often discussed in terms of the powers it gives politicians. The latest income tax figures are a reminder that policymakers must look beyond the formal transfer of powers to how those powers interact with the economy and wider funding system.

That means focusing on the underlying economic conditions that allow the tax base to grow, while building sufficient flexibility to manage shocks and forecast errors that will inevitably emerge.

Graeme Roy is professor of economics at the University of Glasgow’s Adam Smith Business School.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos