Insight

Has Sturgeon given the Greens a route to damage the SNP?

Former First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon <i>(Image: Jane Barlow/PA)</i>
Former First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon (Image: Jane Barlow/PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Nicola Sturgeon did not just deliver a scathing assessment of John Swinney’s leadership of the SNP. She gave their rivals on the left - the Scottish Greens - the greatest political advantage.

The former first minister praised Ross Greer and Gillian Mackay, the co-leaders of the Scottish Greens, for standing up for the issues they believed in.

She also claimed the Scottish Greens were the biggest threat to the SNP, warning that, had they stood in more constituency seats, they would have taken numerous seats from her party.

The Scottish Greens won two constituency seats but only stood in six, with 13 more elected to Holyrood through the regional list.

Sturgeon said the SNP was ‘lucky’ that the Greens did not contest more constituencies, warning the SNP’s “tally might well have been lower”.

While the SNP’s vote share declined on both the constituency and regional ballots, the Scottish Greens increased, with one percentage point increase on the constituency and almost six on the regional list.

Her relationship with the Scottish Greens has always been positive, taking the party into government in a historic powersharing deal.

But these comments came out of the blue for many within the party.

Dr Fraser McMillan, political scientist at the University of Edinburgh, told The Herald that Sturgeon is admired by many on the progressive left who typically vote Green.

And he said that her comments could damage the SNP electorally, warning the former first minister may have given the Greens the “best political advice” they needed.

He said: “The Scottish Greens could be more of a threat to the SNP on their left flank. They did them a favour this time but might not be so inclined to do that again.

“Many think Swinney has ended up somewhere between Sturgeon and Salmond in terms of his policy agenda. There’s obviously a bit of continuity from Sturgeon’s era but he has tried to break out a bigger tent approach and leave some of the progressive social policies to the side.

“The Scottish Greens could cause real damage to the SNP given Swinney has moved away from the Sturgeon agenda.”

Not everyone in the Scottish Greens is enthralled by Sturgeon’s ringing endorsement.

One said they would give up their membership of the party if Ms Sturgeon joined, warning the former first minister “could not be trusted”.

The Greens activist told The Herald: “Nicola Sturgeon dismissed views of members who raised concerns around SNP finances. She repeatedly shut these discussions down. That doesn’t align with what the Greens believe in.”

Scottish Greens co-leader Gillian Mackay at the hustings todayScottish Greens co-leader Gillian Mackay (Image: Colin Mearns)

The source is referencing a leaked video from a 2021 National Executive Committee (NEC) meeting of the SNP’s ruling body.

She warned members to be “very careful” in suggesting there were issues with finances. That led to resignations from senior figures, including Joanna Cherry and former SNP treasurer Douglas Chapman.

Ms Sturgeon subsequently rejected the claims, adding that she had no knowledge of any wrongdoing.

Former SNP chief executive and her estranged husband Peter Murrell admitted embezzling more than £400,000 from the party.

The Scottish Greens manifesto runs to 168 pagesThe Scottish Greens' manifesto. (Image: STEVE WELSH)

Ms Mackay, one of the co-leaders of the Scottish Greens, returned the praise for Ms Sturgeon, stating she was her “favourite” former first minister.

Writing for The National, Ms Mackay said the former first minister’s significance was undeniable.

She said: “Despite the headlines, I can confirm she has not joined our party, or decided to swap her yellow rosette for a green one.”

She said the “bold, ambitious policymaking” of Ms Sturgeon’s era has “slipped into reverse” since she left Bute House in 2023, taking aim at reports the SNP could back new oil and gas drilling in the North Sea.

Amongst SNP activists, there is growing concern.

One source told The Herald that there will be tough questions posed to the SNP leadership at its annual conference in October.

There is a “widescale feeling” that Mr Swinney will not be the man to lead the party into the 2029 UK general election, or the 2031 Scottish Parliament elections.

“We didn’t get that emphatic mandate that we needed,” the source said. “There are open questions about whether Stephen Flynn is ready to lead – or indeed whether he is the right man to take us forward, or whether we need to look to the left of the party.”

The immediate danger for Swinney is not that Sturgeon’s intervention will prompt a Green surge on its own. It is that it reinforces a growing sense that the SNP no longer has a convincing answer to voters who want both independence and a distinctly progressive agenda.

By praising the Greens’ clarity while questioning the direction of her own former party, Sturgeon has given a public voice to a private anxiety within the SNP.

And if that anxiety hardens before the next election, the Greens may find that the space to the SNP’s left is no longer merely open - but expanding.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos