Scottish Greens defend Q Manivannan over rape comments

Scottish Greens MSP Q Manivannan <i>(Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)</i>
Scottish Greens MSP Q Manivannan (Image: Jane Barlow/PA Wire)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Scottish Greens have backed under-fire Q Manivannan after the MSP claimed there is a “spectrum” and a “demonisation” of rape.

There is growing pressure for Manivannan to be suspended, with politicians and charities responding with fury over comments made by the Scottish Greens MSP on a podcast last year, before being elected to Holyrood.

The Scottish Rape Crisis Alliance (SRCA), made up of support centres in Ayrshire, Glasgow, the Western Isles and Lanarkshire, said the comments could be “harmful” to survivors of sexual assault.

Manivannan claims the comments have been “clearly misrepresented”, stating that they were not minimising or excusing serious sexual assault.

But there are calls for the Scottish Greens to investigate the Edinburgh and Lothians East Region MSP’s comments, which could see the party whip removed.

What did Manivannan say?

Speaking on the Subjective Space podcast, in newly surfaced footage, Manivannan discusses rape in the context of a debate about rehabilitation.

Manivannan, who is a survivor of sexual abuse, said: “I think our distaste towards rape is towards rape. It’s towards the idea and the act of rape, not towards the myth of this monster rapist as we’re born to thinking of it that way.

“Because there definitely is a demonisation of rape, in the sense of it is a spectrum.

“As much as I don’t seek to lighten [rape], it is a spectrum: none of which is less or more worse, but it is a spectrum of things that constitute that one homogenised word: rape.”

Manivannan has since said that the point of the comments was to state that “not all rapists fit a stereotype”.

An open letter signed by the SRCA said Manivannan and the Scottish Greens must be “unequivocal” not to “create hierarchies of harm” or “normalise sexual violence”.

Scottish Greens MSP Q Manivannan inside their Holyrood officeScottish Greens MSP Q Manivannan inside their Holyrood office (Image: Duncan McGlynn)

The letter said rape “fundamentally alters a person’s relationship with their body, their safety, their relationships, their mental health and their ability to move through life”.

Comments 'deeply irresponsible'

The organisations “fundamentally” rejected any claim that society is “demonising” rape.

The letter added: “We are not demonising rape. We are naming it. We are naming the harm caused by sexual violence. We are naming the fear, humiliation, trauma and loss of control experienced by survivors.

“We are naming the reality that women and girls continue to live with the threat of male violence.”

There is, the organisations said, concern over Manivannan’s description that rape exists on a “spectrum”.

“Of course, sexual violence happens in different circumstances,” the rape crisis centres said.

“There are different forms of coercion, manipulation, intimidation and control. Perpetrators may be known or unknown to the survivor. Sexual violence can occur within relationships, friendships, families, workplaces and communities. Survivors may respond in very different ways, and the impact of sexual violence can vary enormously from one person to another.

“But recognising complexity does not require us to make rape itself ambiguous. There is no hierarchy of rape.”

The number of reported sexual offences in Scotland increased by 48% in the last decade, with Police Scotland recording a further 10% increase in 2025-26.

Manivannan – and all other politicians – have been told to reflect on the “language” used around rape.

Nicola Love, of Rape Crisis Scotland, described the comments as “deeply irresponsible”, warning they “reinforced harmful rape myths”.

Will the Scottish Greens remove the whip?

The Scottish Greens has defended Manivannan, arguing that the comments were “deliberately taken out of context”.

A spokesman said: “The Scottish Greens unequivocally condemn rape, harassment and sexual violence. 

“When sexual crimes against women and girls too often go unpunished, and where many victims feel scared to report for fear of not being believed, the language we use and the way we represent the views of others matters.
“As Q’s previous statement has made clear, the clip being circulated this weekend was deliberately taken out of context from a longer conversation in order to misrepresent them.

“In the full interview Q argued strongly that too many men get away with this crime because of the assumption that rapists all match a narrow stereotype. We will only tackle this epidemic of sexual violence if that dangerous stereotype is consigned to history.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos