Having spent five years relentlessly pursuing the Scottish Government over the so-called "Salmond Files", Scotland's information commissioner is about to have Operation Branchform in his sights.
David Hamilton was scathing about the administration's reluctance to publish documents relating to whether former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon breached the ministerial code over her handling of allegations into her predecessor Alex Salmond.
The senior Irish lawyer concluded in his report in March 2021 that Ms Sturgeon did not breach the ministerial code.
But, in a two-page note, he underlined his frustration with a considerable number of redactions that were made to the document ahead of its publication by the Scottish Government.
Earlier this year, the Scottish Government was found in contempt of court by the Court of Session over its delay in releasing the heavily-redacted material first requested back in 2021.
Read More:
- Scot Gov told to release evidence into Nicola Sturgeon probe
- Files reveal 'Hamilton probe into Sturgeon was a cover up'
- Salmond feared prosecution over sharing evidence with Sturgeon probe
- Sturgeon legacy: SNP wins, Branchform, Salmond, gender
Now in an interview on Sunday, the information commissioner said the reluctance to release the Salmond Files was an illustration of what he described as a wider culture of institutional secrecy and accused the Scottish Government's legal directorate of acting as a "praetorian guard" for the First Minister John Swinney rather than serving the public interest.
But to me what was most eye-catching in his intervention was his call for prosecutors to be more transparent about key decisions in Operation Branchform, the long-running Police Scotland investigation into SNP finances, including why Ms Sturgeon was never charged.
While he was clear he was not claiming incorrect decisions had been made, he said apparent contradictions between the police and Crown Office in their public statements “merits further scrutiny”.
Read More:
- Sturgeon’s legacy will be shaped by Murrell's crimes
- Sturgeon’s book tour is resuming - the SNP won't be happy
- Inside Murrell's motorhome - driven for only four miles
The Crown Office has suggested that police assessed Ms Sturgeon should not be charged. However, police have denied making any recommendation about charges or otherwise and insiders have said detectives wanted to ask Ms Sturgeon more questions about her involvement but never got the opportunity.
Operation Branchform ultimately led to Ms Sturgeon's estranged husband and former party chief executive, Peter Murrell, being sentenced to more than five years in prison for embezzlement.
"The Crown Office is an interesting one, because never more has there been questions about some of their decisions," Mr Hamilton told The Sunday Times.
"Now, I'm not saying they're the wrong decisions. But 'no, we're not telling you' is not a good look.
"And when they did say some things it went contrary to what Police Scotland were saying, which raises interesting questions. These are totally conflicting versions of events, which merits further scrutiny."
While Freedom of Information decisions by the Crown Office cannot be appealed to the commissioner under current law, Mr Hamilton confirmed he is prepared to use his statutory powers to compel bodies like Police Scotland to release materials where it serves the public interest.
Potential disclosures could include Ms Sturgeon's lengthy written statement to police after she gave a no comment interview under questioning after her arrest in June 2023.
The former First Minister, who has always strenuously denied any criminality or knowledge of her husband’s crimes, suggested she might publish the statement after Murrell’s guilty plea, but later backtracked.
One aspect of the now looming FoI saga, which has been overlooked to date, is that the member of the public who eventually partially won his battle against the Scottish Government over the Salmond Files, is behind a request to Police Scotland seeking documents relating to Operation Branchform.
Transparency campaigner Benjamin Harrop wrote to the force seeking the written statement Ms Sturgeon made to officers after she was questioned by detectives.
Police Scotland last month refused his request but Mr Harrop asked for the decision to be reviewed - and indicated in a social media post that if the force continued to refuse, he would be taking the matter to the Information Commissioner.
He told me today he did so on Monday, appealing to Mr Hamilton for Ms Sturgeon's police statement to be made public.
With the Commissioner stating on Sunday that Branchform decisions "merit further scrutiny" he seems to be indicating that he would take an open-minded approach.
It is not a position Police Scotland is likely to accept and should the watchdog back Mr Harrop's appeal I would not be surprised if there would be a legal challenge.
Who would win is hard to know, but judging by the length of time the battle over the Salmond Files took, Ms Sturgeon's police statement is unlikely to be published anytime soon.
Share