Unspun 🗳️

Why Scotland’s violence against women policies keep falling short

John Swinney has put tackling violence against women and girls at the heart of his Programme for Government, but campaigners warn the real test will be whether years of policy promises finally translate into delivery. <i>(Image: Derek McArthur)</i>
John Swinney has put tackling violence against women and girls at the heart of his Programme for Government, but campaigners warn the real test will be whether years of policy promises finally translate into delivery. (Image: Derek McArthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter.


John Swinney has diagnosed Scotland’s problem on violence against women and girls. The harder question for him and his government, however, is whether they have learned how to fix it.

The First Minister has promised his “personal leadership” on what he calls an “epidemic of male violence”, a new Misogyny Bill, an end to the postcode lottery in specialist services, multi-year funding and a public health campaign aimed at boys and young men.

The Programme for Government also pledges Scotland’s first Victims and Witnesses Commissioner and the establishment of a trauma-informed Sexual Offences Court.


READ MORE:


It is one strand of a much broader Programme for Government, which couples sweeping public-service reform with promises on childcare, housing, NHS waiting times and economic growth – but repeatedly makes “delivery” the test of whether those ambitions amount to more than policy.

All promises around tackling violence against women and girls are substantial commitments.

But they arrive against a sinister and worrying backdrop: the SNP has already spent more than 15 years producing substantial commitments on precisely this issue.

That is what makes Scottish Rape Crisis Alliance review so damaging.

Get Scotland's top politics newsletter straight to your inbox.

It audits more than 15 years of Scottish Government action and repeatedly finds that ambitious laws and strategies were undermined by weak implementation, poor evaluation and insecure funding.

Its argument is not that governments have lacked ideas. Quite the opposite.

Scotland has modernised sexual offences law, produced national strategies, criminalised coercive control, invested in prevention and repeatedly reformed the justice system.

The problem has been what happens afterwards.

The 2009 Sexual Offences Act transformed the law around consent. Yet survivors supported by rape crisis centres are now waiting four years for some cases to reach court.

Equally Safe put prevention at the centre of government policy. Yet the alliance says its delivery plan lacked “robust evaluation” and measurable evidence that attitudes and behaviour were actually changing.

The 2018 domestic abuse legislation was hailed as pioneering. Yet the review says it did not “change practice to the extent intended”.

Emergency domestic abuse protections were legislated for. Key police powers were then left unimplemented.

That is not a failure of ambition. It is a failure of government.

And it makes some of Tuesday’s promises look uncomfortably familiar.

Mr Swinney says he will end the “postcode lottery” in specialist services. But the Programme for Government does not explain precisely how.

He promises a new multi-year fund – an obvious response to years of complaints about precarious funding – but gives no figure. Rape crisis organisations are now waiting for the Budget to discover whether the money matches the rhetoric.

The public health campaign aimed at misogyny among boys and young men could be important. But after campaigners explicitly criticised previous prevention programmes for lacking measurable outcomes, there is little detail yet about how ministers will establish whether this one actually changes behaviour.

Then there is the Misogyny Bill.

It may prove significant, but even opposition politicians noted on Tuesday that legislation in this area has been promised before. Jackie Baillie pointedly described this as the third parliamentary term in which such action has been discussed without being delivered.

The irony is that Mr Swinney appears to understand the problem.

His wider Programme for Government repeatedly talks about frontline delivery, accountability and changing public services which are “not delivering as we need them to”.

Violence against women and girls will be a sharp test of that philosophy.

Because another strategy cannot shorten a four-year court wait by itself. A pledge cannot provide a rape survivor with a counsellor. Legislation sitting dusty and unimplemented on the statute book protects no woman from their abuser.

The review from the Scottish Rape Crisis alliance puts it more bluntly: “Policy alone does not deliver change.”

That is the danger for Mr Swinney now. Ambition may be politically necessary, but ambition without delivery quickly becomes another promise added to the pile.

As Macbeth warns of “vaulting ambition, which o’erleaps itself / And falls on th’other”.

Mr Swinney has supplied the ambition. His real test is whether his government can finally deliver the change.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos