Scotland’s health board cull could make Scotland’s NHS “less safe” if SNP ministers use it simply as a cost-cutting exercise, doctors have warned.
In an open letter penned to the Scottish Government, the country’s leading medical organisations have warned staff wellbeing cannot be an “afterthought” in a restructuring process.
As revealed in The Herald, First Minister John Swinney confirmed the number of regional health boards in Scotland will be cut from 14 to two as part of the biggest shake-up of the NHS in decades.
Deep concern has been raised regarding the merger plans, which were part of Tuesday’s Programme for Government announcements.
The open letter, shared exclusively with The Herald, reveals significant concerns among the medical community, including the British Medical Association (BMA), the Royal College of General Practitioners, Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow and the Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland (MDDUS).
The letter warned the health board cull would “only succeed if it improves, rather than undermines the conditions in which doctors are able to care for patients”.
It warned Scottish ministers that a restructuring programme which treats wellbeing as an “afterthought” will not save money and instead “will simply move the cost elsewhere, while making patient care less safe”.
The groups have demanded the Scottish Government incorporates Wellbeing by Design within the reforms – plans to make the health service safe and effective for doctors.
Read more
-
Scotland split into two under John Swinney's major NHS shake-up
-
Doctors accuse SNP of wasting millions on controversial GP walk-in centre extension
-
'Rats on a sinking ship’: Doctors warning of NHS burnout as consultant vacancies soar
-
Whistleblower doctor warns NHS Scotland still puts reputation before patient safety
A recent survey by the BMA Scotland found around 80% of doctors were at high or very high risk of burnout, while MDDUS found seven in 10 GPs experienced “compassion fatigue”.
“These pressures did not appear because Scotland has too many health boards, and they will not disappear because it has fewer,” the letter said.
“If boards are merged and services reorganised, doctors and other healthcare workers who are already stretched will be asked to absorb yet more disruption, often for years at a time.”
The letter, signed by Dr Iain Morrison, Dr Chris Provan, Dr Katharine Jones and Dr Jo Galvin, said every part of the reforms must be tested against its effect on doctors’ workload and rest, while “protecting continuity of care”.
“The aims of these changes include less duplication and more consistency in how safe staffing is protected across Scotland,” the letter added.
“These will only be realised if those delivering care are treated as partners in this process, rather than a workforce to be managed through it.
“Across respective organisations, we are ready to help get this right. It is crucial that the Scottish Government works with all interested organisations and, indeed, the public to deliver its aims, with staff wellbeing at the core of all its proposals.”
Meanwhile, Roz Foyer, the general secretary of the STUC, said that on the face of it, the merger appeared “bold”.
John Swinney. (Image: Colin Mearns)
But she said: “Crushing down Scotland’s health boards into two may seem bold on paper but further centralising power when local communities are crying out for health and social care services tailored to their needs seems more reckless than revolutionary.
Read more
-
Anger over 'dangerous' corridor care as hospital A&E exceeds capacity by 225 per cent
-
'Not delivering': Watchdog advised ministers to scrap Scotland’s maternity taskforce
-
'Past point of no return': Nurses warn patients are receiving unsafe corridor care
“This is not the way to do public sector reform. Before the axe is swung on any public service, whether health, council or social care, Scottish Government ministers would do well to engage meaningfully and purposefully with the workers who deliver on the ground. This cannot be done in the timescales outlined.
The Scottish Government has said it is determined to engage with stakeholders at every step of the merger process, but wider details have yet to be made available.
The change comes as health board leaders came under increasing scrutiny with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde condemned over deadly infections at the flagship Queen Elizabeth University Hospital.
There have been seven deaths explicitly linked to the scandal, including 10-year-old Milly Main.
The chief executive of the health board earns up to £200,000 per year.
Meanwhile, NHS Tayside faces scrutiny over the case of rogue brain surgeon Sam Eljamel, who left hundreds of patients with lifelong injuries after performing botched surgery at Ninewells Hospital.
During the Programme for Government, Mr Swinney confirmed Scotland’s four territorial health boards will be scrapped and replaced with just two Strategic Health Boards.
He described this as "the most significant structural reform of our NHS in the devolution era."
He said it would mean more joined-up delivery, better patient access to care, and reducing inequality between patients caused by "health board boundaries."
Share