Edinburgh council officers have refused to reveal the extent of their efforts to recover hundreds of thousands of pounds in unpaid business rates by gift shops at the site of the Princes Street fire.
Under Freedom of Information legislation, The Herald had asked for electronic copies of any correspondence between the council, landlord Criterion Capital, and tenants Urban Emporium Ltd, Kitfox Ltd, and Bwn Beverage Ltd pertaining to non-domestic rates between July 2024 and the blaze on July 9, 2026.
However, the request was rejected under an exemption which restricts the publication of information if it “would, or would be likely to, prejudice substantially the commercial interests of any person”.
The council previously used this exemption to block the disclosure of the names of businesses with unpaid non-domestic rates.
The Herald had requested information about businesses on Princes Street, George Street, and the Royal Mile, but this request was similarly rejected on the grounds of prejudice to commercial interests.
The fire took place overnight on July 9, 2026. (Image: Jane Barlow / PA)
Regarding the specific correspondence with Criterion and the tenants, information officers wrote: “The council cannot release commercially sensitive information relating to the landlord and tenant.
“Disclosure would be likely to harm their commercial interests, as there would be no reasonable expectation that information about its financial affairs would be placed in the public domain.”
While the council acknowledged that there was a public interest case for releasing the information, it concluded that “disclosure of this information would be likely to cause substantial harm to the commercial interests of the landlord and tenants”.
As such, the response stated: “The council therefore considers that the public interest in disclosure is outweighed by the need to protect the confidentiality of its business dealings and avoid exposing these companies to undue attention.”
On Wednesday, The Herald revealed that the tenant at the time of the July 9 fire, Bwn Beverage Ltd, had failed to file its accounts with Companies House on time.
The company's current registered director, 30-year-old Rumi Chowdhury, is a Bangladeshi national with no apparent connection to Edinburgh.
The Herald reported earlier this month that the firm is liable for more than £300,000 in unpaid non-domestic rates.
Reacting to the latest development, Edinburgh Conservatives group leader Iain Whyte suggested that the rules around Freedom of Information legislation should be amended to avoid becoming a “shield for dodgy businesses”.
“I can understand why the council hasn’t fully answered this FOI as there are lots of competing legal obligations to consider,” he said.
Emergency services were called to the blaze at the old Debenhams building in the city centre at 2.52am on Thursday. (Image: Jane Barlow)
“However, I am sure most members of the public will be furious that legal protections needed to necessarily protect people’s personal data have also become a shield for dodgy businesses who fail to pay the tax they are due.
“These rules need to be reviewed so that wrongdoing can be publicly exposed and persistent offenders named and shamed. Although I suspect that would need a change or clarification in legislation from the Scottish Government to allow the council to do that.”
Read more:
- Thousands of capital's firms fail to pay full business rates, council confirms
- Part of £5m Edinburgh fire fund earmarked for 'likelihood' of legal challenge
- Overdue accounts for London-based firm behind Princes Street fire gift shops
On Wednesday, The Herald reported that more than 3,000 businesses have yet to pay all of their non-domestic rates for the 2025/26 financial year.
Additionally, 2,300 firms, or 10 per cent of the capital's businesses, are facing “formal recovery action” by council officers.
Despite this, The Herald revealed last month that no one in Edinburgh had been charged, prosecuted, or convicted under section 29 of the Non-Domestic Rates (Scotland) Act 2020 since at least the 2024/25 financial year.
Section 29 criminalises the provision of false information to local authorities or the Scottish Assessors, with convictions carrying a fine of up to £1,000. It does not criminalise simple tax avoidance.
The Herald will appeal the council’s decision.
Share