Exclusive

New Scottish musical which turned critics away pulls Scottish tour

New Scottish musical Ceilidh was staged at Pitlochry Town Hall last month before transferring to Shoreditch in London. <i>(Image: Matthew Murphy)</i>
New Scottish musical Ceilidh was staged at Pitlochry Town Hall last month before transferring to Shoreditch in London. (Image: Matthew Murphy)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The producers of a new Scottish musical which Scottish theatre critics were asked not to review in Scotland have pulled a planned Scottish tour of the production.

Planned runs of Ceilidh in Edinburgh, Aberdeen, Dundee and Glasgow have been put on hold just two months after they were announced.

The show, which is billed as a celebration of “one of Scotland’s oldest and most beloved traditions”, will instead have an extended run in London for the next three months.


Read more:


The entire UK tour of the Pitlochry Festival Theatre show, which opened in the Perthshire town last month, has vanished from the official website of the production.

A spokesperson for the musical, which has been backed by producers in London and America, as well as Pitlochry, told The Herald a UK tour of Ceilidh would be rescheduled.

However, no new dates or venues have been announced by the production.

The Herald was told the planned dates were pulled to “make space” for an extended run of shows at Shoreditch Town Hall, where Ceilidh transferred last month after its UK premiere in Pitlochry.

However, there has been no official announcement that the UK tour is not going ahead as planned. It is understood that critics who were planning to see the show in Scottish venues have not been alerted to the decision by the show’s producers.

Alan Cumming, who was appointed artistic director of Pitlochry Festival Theatre in 2024, announced Ceilidh as a centrepiece of his first season of shows last November.

The musical, created by Scottish songwriting duo Scott Gilmour and Claire McKenzie, is inspired by the ceilidh dance scene in Glasgow.

The pair, who run musical theatre company Noisemaker, secured crucial backing to develop their idea for a musical from American producers Beth Williams and Barbara Whitman in 2018.

An initial run of performances were staged at Cottiers in Glasgow two years ago before the show was officially launched in Baltimore last autumn, shortly before Cumming, who has been listed as a producer of the show since its US premiere, revealed it was heading to Pitlochry.

The show was billed by the Perthshire theatre as “a joyous, irreverent, heart-pounding celebration of Scotland's culture, community and the power of gathering together”.

An extensive UK tour of Ceilidh, running from mid-November until the end of March, was announced in September, a month before it was due to open in Pitlochry. Venues included the Corn Exchange in Edinburgh, the Music Hall in Aberdeen, the Caird Hall in Dundee and the Barrowland Ballroom in Glasgow.

At the time the UK tour was announced, Cumming said: “It’s only fitting that a show so beautifully entertaining and Scottish to its very core should start its journey here in Pitlochry, before it reels its way down to Shoreditch Town Hall and across the rest of the UK.

“It is a gorgeous, heartfelt story wrapped up in an unadulterated night of joy, dancing, music and pure Highland magic.”

However, days before Ceilidh’s UK premiere last month, Scottish theatre critics were asked not to review the show, now backed by London-based Trafalgar Theatre Productions, when it was launched at Pitlochry Town Hall.

They instead asked arts journalists who wanted to cover the UK launch of the show to travel to Shoreditch.

Pitlochry Festival Theatre told critics who were planning to attend the UK premiere that the show’s producers felt the show would not have “many of the technical elements designed by the creative team” during its initial run in Perthshire.

Journalists were told at the time: “The producers want it to be reviewed in its full form at the nearest possible opportunity, which happens to be London, purely due to how the tour dates have been arranged.

“Were the show to have stopped at Glasgow or Edinburgh next, that is where it would have opened to the press.”

Writing in The Herald, theatre critic Neil Cooper said: “By locking out Scotland’s critical fraternity suggests that both they and Pitlochry audiences might be regarded as being treated as second-class citizens.”

He added: “Put simply, if any theatre spends a penny of Scottish taxpayers’ money on a show, it needs to be held to account.

“Not for the show to be dissed, but to be scrutinised, dissected, and, hopefully, to see work created by Scotland’s artists such as Noisemaker celebrated and praised.

“In not giving those attending Ceilidh in Pitlochry the opportunity to read about the show in Scotland-based publications does everyone a disservice, including those making what may well be a very good production.”

The London run of Ceilidh is being promoted as “a foot-stomping, joyful, heart-warming party brought to life every night with a company of 16 actor-musicians”.

The official website for the musical states: “Step through the doors of Shoreditch Town Hall, grab a drink, and leave the cold behind. Come alone, bring friends, or gather the family. You’ll laugh, you’ll cry, and you might even choose to join a dance.”

A spokesperson for the musical told The Herald: “Following such a wonderful response, we’ve been given the opportunity to extend Ceilidh’s run at Shoreditch Town Hall until February 28.

“To make space for these extra London dates, we’ll be rescheduling our UK tour, with more details to follow soon.

“If you already hold a ticket, your point of purchase will be in touch directly.”

Pitlochry Festival Theatre has asked critics not to review Ceilidh in Pitlochry months after the Royal Lyceum Theatre in Edinburgh told critics writing for UK titles not to review its new musical One Day because a run was being planned in London's West End.

The move was criticised as "divisive" and "London-centric" in an open letter signed by 15 theatre critics based in Scotland.

The open letter said: "As critics, we all recognise the vital and enriching role that co-productions now play in Scotland’s theatre life, and warmly welcome them.

"However, when co-production leads to the exclusion of leading Scottish-based critical voices from that public debate, we believe that a line must be drawn; and we trust that the London-centric attitudes reflected in this week’s decision will play no part in the future thinking and planning of Scotland’s leading producing theatres.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos