The suspension of three senior staff - including one director - from the Scottish Government's troubled heritage organisation Historic Environment Scotland (HES) has put the spotlight again on the organisation and what lies head for it and its 1600 staff.
HES has rarely been out of the headlines for the past year and a half and in recent months has lost it chief executive Katerina Brown and its chair Sir Mark Jones. An interim ceo and interim chair were then appointed.
Culture secretary Màiri McAllan approved a "settlement agreement" for the departing chief in September, The Herald revealed on Tuesday this week following this paper's revelations about the three suspensions on Monday.
The two stories have no doubt made uncomfortable reading for the current HES leadership and ministers who want to see the body on a calmer footing.
Back in September, when First Minister John Swinney set out his aim in his Programme for Government to "substantially reduce" the number of public bodies, I wondered then if he had the heritage organisation in his sights.
Read More:
- McAllan signed off 'settlement agreement' for HES chief
- Holyrood 2026: SNP vows post election shake-up of HES
- HES faces shake-up as ministers identify 'options'
- HES: McAllan leaves door open to new shake-up under reforms
However, no mention was made of HES as he unveiled his plans to MSPs in the Holyrood chamber that day to radically reshape the structure of public services over the course of the parliament.
Instead, in terms of public bodies, under the Scottish Government's proposals published that day in terms of reducing the number of public bodies, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA), Nature Scot, Zero Waste Scotland, and potentially Scottish Forestry, would be merged into a single environmental organisation. Later ministers decided that Scottish Forestry would not be amalgamated into the larger body.
The documents also set out plans to bring Transport Scotland into core Scottish Government; merge the Scottish Food Commission and the Scottish Pubs Code Adjudicator and bring into Food Standards Scotland; and embed Architecture and Design Scotland within More Homes Scotland.
It was surprising, to my mind, that nothing had been said about what would happen to HES under the cull.
Not only because its controversies had been rarely off the front pages of Scotland's leading newspapers, but because Mr Swinney's own party manifesto before the Holyrood election explicitly stated a commitment to review its structures.
Katerina Brown resigned as chief executive of Historic Environment Scotland in September. (Image: PA)
Under the heading heritage, the SNP manifesto states: “Through our public sector reform programme we will review the structures of Historic Environment Scotland and take any necessary steps to ensure the recent work of the new chair is supported and can be embedded for the future.”
Months after the election I asked the Scottish Government what it was doing to adopt the SNP manifesto's commitment on HES.
At the end of July, a Scottish Government spokesperson told me: “Work is ongoing to identify options for Public Service Reform in line with the Scottish Government’s commitments.
"We will be making further announcements on work to be taken forward in due course.”
The answer, as readers can see, gave little away in terms of what the Scottish Government's intentions were for HES.
Ms McAllan was also rather opaque on what a review "of the structures of HES" may look like.
She was pressed on the issue when she gave evidence to Holyrood's culture committee on September 8 and appeared to leave the door open for a possible future shake up.
"I'm unclear at the moment whether the government has a clear sense in mind of whether that organisation will recover in its current form or whether other options are on the table in terms of of how those functions are carried out," committee convener Patrick Harvie asked.
Ms McAllan noted the Scottish Government's plans to reform public bodies as she replied: "I suppose underpinning this whole answer with the fact that every public body in Scotland is part of our assessment of the landscape and has to be challenged and to challenge itself on its functions and how best it is working."
She then went on to say that "despite the well-documented problems that HES has faced", her government's commitment was to "get it back onto a stable footing of governance".
The cabinet secretary also noted changes in how HES operates have already been made with the body allowed to operate more commercially in return for less public funding.
"That's an example of how public service reforms already working within HES, but in terms of structure, my priority is that HES get itself back to the excellent levels of governance and functioning that we we expect and indeed that the employees of his deserve to face every day," she added.
It may be that the Scottish Government is still deliberating on what to with HES. It would seem that its current priority is to work with the existing structures of the organisation.
The big test for HES and for the government is whether the organisation can return to "excellent levels of governance and functioning".
Stephen Boyle, the Auditor General for Scotland, will be quizzed on Thursday morning by Holyrood's public audit committee, on where the organisation now stands almost a year after he delivered a highly critical report citing "unacceptable" weaknesses.
Since his initial assessment last December, HES commissioned an independent organisational and cultural review as part of its response to the 2024/25 audit. The review was published in June 2026.
But last week Mr Boyle's latest Section 22 report found HES still had "more work to do" to implement the 30 recommendations it made as well as those by Audit Scotland.
Whether HES survives in its current form or faces a major restructure could well depend on how it well and how quickly it can implement these measures.
Share