Holyrood votes down motion opposing Rosebank drilling

Scottish Green MSPs joined campaigners to take part in a Stop Rosebank protest outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh, as MSPs prepare to debate the oil and gas field. Picture date: Wednesday November 18, 2026. PA Photo. Photo credit should read: <i>(Image: Jane Barlow)</i>
Scottish Green MSPs joined campaigners to take part in a Stop Rosebank protest outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh, as MSPs prepare to debate the oil and gas field. Picture date: Wednesday November 18, 2026. PA Photo. Photo credit should read: (Image: Jane Barlow)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A motion opposing drilling at Rosebank has been voted down at Holyrood, despite protesters against the controversial oil and gas field gathering outside the Parliament.

Environmental campaigners had gathered outside the Scottish Parliament on Wednesday ahead of a Scottish Green debate, which came as the UK Government continues to consider where Rosebank should get the green light.

The field, which lies to the north-west of Shetland, is the UK’s largest untapped oil field, and Green climate action spokesman Mark Ruskell insisted that drilling there would spark a “race towards climate breakdown”.

However, Scottish Government energy minister Stephen Gethins stressed that as the UK and Scotland “will continue to rely on fossil fuels for years to come”, oil and gas produced from the North Sea would have a lower carbon footprint than fuels imported from overseas.

As a result he said “that is a resource that should be utilised”.

Campaigners take part in a Stop Rosebank protest outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh, as MSPs prepare to debate the oil and gas field. Picture date: Wednesday November 18, 2026. PA Photo. Photo credit should read: Jane Barlow/Press Association (Image: Jane Barlow)

Mr Gethins spoke out as a government amendment, which stressed that new licences for oil and gas “must be compatible with climate legislation” was passed by 78 votes to 40.

The energy minister had stressed that domestic oil and gas was “preferable to importation”, and also was in the interests of both energy security and “protecting Scottish jobs”.

Stressing the Scottish Government’s continued commitment to achieving net zero by 2045, he added: “Sourcing our oil and gas from domestic resources matters for our climate objectives as well as our energy security.”

Conservative North East Scotland MSP Liam Kerr meanwhile told MSPs voting for the Green motion opposing Rosebank was “not an environmental policy” and was instead “an act of economic and environmental self-sabotage”.

The Tory energy spokesperson added: “Production emissions from Rosebank will be around 12kg of carbon dioxide per barrel, that is less than half the average of current UK oil production and around a third of the global average.

“Any environmentalist who is genuinely interested in reducing emissions should be demanding we produce oil from Rosebank, rather than higher emitting alternatives.”

Reform UK MSP Duncan Massey also spoke in favour of developing the North Sea, claiming the Green amendment would “impoverish” Scotland and “destroy jobs” while making the country more dependent on imported fuels.

“Under all possible scenarios the UK and Scotland will need oil and gas for decades,” Mr Massey said.

“Domestic production, and especially Rosebank, is extremely important for the country. We know we are dependent on oil and gas, we know we are facing high prices due to disrupted supply. And we know emissions are lower for domestic production.

“We should all recognise this and we should all back our oil and gas industry.”

However, protesters outside spoke out against drilling, with climate campaigner and author Sandy Winterbottom insisting there was a “huge groundswell of opposition to Rosebank, up and down the country”.

Campaigners take part in a Stop Rosebank protest outside the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh, as MSPs prepare to debate the oil and gas field. Picture date: Wednesday November 18, 2026. PA Photo. Photo credit should read: Jane Barlow/Press Association (Image: Jane Barlow)

The campaigner said: “People need their elected representatives to take the climate crisis seriously, given the very real impacts we’re already facing from wildfires and drought to worsening flooding.

“Rosebank is not compatible with safe climate limits – it would just make these impacts worse for us and future generations.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos