This article appears as part of the Lessons to Learn newsletter.
This week, the latest stage in the rebrand of the SQA got underway. We are now, officially, expected to use the name ‘Qualifications Scotland’.
The people in charge are still trying to convince us that this isn’t a rebrand, but rather the birth of an entirely “new organisation”, one that has been – to use the phrase that has popped up on their press releases – built ‘from the ground up’.
So before going any further, let’s just deal with this once and for all.
It is obviously untrue to claim that Qualifications Scotland is a new organisation, and the more its leadership – and some politicians – say otherwise, the more ridiculous they look.
Almost all of the same people are doing almost all of the same jobs as they were before. The organisation has all the same powers that it had before. It is run from the same offices as it was before.
There is a new chief executive, a few new management positions, and the bit at the end of everyone’s email has changed.
It might even turn out to be the case that some cultural changes have been achieved as well.
But a new organisation, built from the ground up? Don’t be ridiculous.
In fact, things are becoming so ridiculous that the SQA is effectively trying to rebrand its rebrand and, in keeping with its performance in recent years, doing so in an entirely inept fashion.
Why are they so desperate to stick to this line, and to have you all believe that black is white? Presumably it’s because they know these changes don’t even come close to what was recommended to the Scottish Government, but are hoping that you don’t notice that.
Sign up for a weekly expert insight into Scottish education.
To recap, a few years back, the Scottish Government was desperate to distract people from the contents of an OECD review into Scottish education, largely because it raised massive (and as yet unanswered questions) about the judgement and policy direction of former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon and, by extension, the current First Minister (and former Education Secretary) John Swinney.
Politicians announced that they would scrap the SQA, and commissioned Professor Ken Muir to review the operation of the main organisations in Scottish education. He and his team analysed the current situations for the SQA and Education Scotland, and came up with a number of recommendations to make things better for pupils and teachers.
They advised that the SQA be completely broken up, a move that would tackle the obvious conflict of interest that allows the exam board to effectively be its own regulator, while also exerting control on the wider qualifications system.
The new organisation – and in these circumstances it would have been something genuinely new – would have been a slimmed down body with a far tighter focus on the job everyone actually expects it to do. This would have increased the chances of the exam board being competent (which would be a nice change), effective, and respected, while tackling the glaring arrogance that came to define the SQA’s view of itself.
Some claim the latest changes to the SQA do not constitute a rebrand (Image: vcvc)
Instead, we have the rebrand, and even that hasn’t started very well.
The new SQA is happy to tell you that it has learned lessons from the failures of the old SQA, but it won’t tell you what those failures were.
The new SQA is keen to chat about the things that are going to be better this time, just don’t try to ask questions about what went so wrong before.
The new SQA also wants us to believe that it is a bold and ambitious organisation, but have a look at their proposals for changes to some exams and you can see that this isn’t true either.
Take, for example, the proposal for Higher English, which I taught for more than a decade. The course as it stands needs a very radical review.
The proposed changes involve a slight rejigging of the marks in one of the three exam papers.
It is unambitious tinkering but, for those of us who’ve been around this block a few times, it is also entirely unsurprising.
We’ve heard this reform tune before, just like we’ve heard the one about working in partnership, improving engagement with the teaching profession, or showing more respect for the young people whose entire lives can be affected by the outcome of their school exams.
Maybe this time is different.
Maybe this time the changes being promised will really materialise.
Maybe this time the people involved will be competent.
Maybe this time we won’t have to deal with an organisation that aggressively rejects even the idea that it has made very serious mistakes.
Maybe.
But the fact we’re starting with all the ridiculous spin about a ‘new’ organisation, instead of a bit of genuine humility, doesn’t bode particularly well.
Share