Scotland's Prisons

Prisoners should have the chance to rewrite their life stories

Singer song writer Jill Brown, 2nd from left, pictured with the band she performed with at the chapel at Barlinnie Prison <i>(Image: Colin Mearns)</i>
Singer song writer Jill Brown, 2nd from left, pictured with the band she performed with at the chapel at Barlinnie Prison (Image: Colin Mearns)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

James has spent every birthday for the last decade in the same place. Prison. He hasn’t been in jail continuously during this time but, like so many others, has been in and out with predictable regularity, so much so that he has had always ended up back inside as the year turns to mark the anniversary of his birth. He was 29 on his last birthday and I meet him in HMP Barlinnie in Glasgow.

Softly spoken, with a thick Glasgow accent, the mandatory red jumper, which signifies that he has been convicted - as opposed to the blue worn when awaiting trial -  hangs loosely on his thin frame. His fluorescent trainers are one of the few visible ways in which he can demonstrate his individuality in an institution where you’re given a number. The figure reflects where you come in the chronology of prisoners admitted to the jail.

I’m in the prison to help deliver today’s lesson, which is hip-hop. Not a subject taught in schools, but then many of the men I work with haven’t had much of a formal education. Instead, they’ve learnt lessons during their young, formative years that most of us can’t begin to imagine and certainly wouldn’t want for our own children.

For those who are unaware, hip-hop is a form of music where you don’t need to be able to sing; instead the words are spoken. James is glad about that. “Am no really a singer,” he says, shyly, looking down at his bright feet and giving his nose a quick wipe on the sleeve of his jumper.

James might not be a singer, but he’s certainly a writer. We give him a notebook and he takes up the pen and starts scribbling furiously. Line after line, the pages fill up quickly - there is no dearth of material. One line is particularly striking: “My mum was an addict and so was my dad.”

The sloping, minuscule handwriting sheds light on a bigger picture, one of a chaotic, troubled and abusive childhood. James’ story isn’t unique, but he most definitely is. I look forward to hearing his wry sense of humour and keen observations from week to week. A seasoned ‘criminal,’ I’m struck by James’ childlike vulnerability. “You’ve come back Miss,” he says, as I return for our workshops every Tuesday.


Read more:


Prisons are full of people like James. People who have experienced trauma. Around 80% of those in jail have mental health problems, some more severe than others. Their psychological issues and scars are only exacerbated in jail, not a place intended to tackle well-being.

I’d been volunteering in Barlinnie, on an ad hoc basis, for around a decade before I set up Conviction Records, Scotland’s first record label for ex-offenders, a few years ago. Funding from Creative Scotland has enabled the label to run hip-hop and songwriting workshops in the prison which have been hugely successful.

“Why waste your time on folk who don’t deserve it?,” is a rhetorical question with which I’m extremely familiar. It is interesting how quickly we are prepared to dismiss and, often demonise, people while expecting that those whom we’ve wronged in some way should give us a second chance.  After all, we believe we deserve it. The same sense of justice that entitles us to another opportunity is not something we afford to others.

Singer song writer Jill Brown performing in the chapel at Barlinnie Prison, Glasgow.Singer song writer Jill Brown performing in the chapel at Barlinnie Prison, Glasgow. (Image: Colin Mearns)

I love working with people in prison. As a musician and someone who has also experienced trauma, I have more in common than you might think with those who attend our workshops. Suffering has to come out, somehow, and writing lyrics and melodies with the support and encouragement of people who believe in you, can be a life-changing experience.

Bernie explains: “I have been lucky to survive, I have been in dark heavy places…This sentence has helped me. I have changed a lot in here, the workshops and the staff have made me feel more like a human being. I am trying to change the guy that I was when I came in…I want to be a real member of society and become employable. I want to set a good example for my daughter… this music space…helped me socialise and helped me with people skills. Music can make you feel amazing and bring everybody together.”

There will always be people who say of those who end up in prison that “they should be locked up and the key thrown away.” Other arguments aside, this is not a solution to overcrowded jails and the expense of repeat offending on victims and as well as the public purse.

As Becci Wallace, the hip-hop tutor who led our workshops in Barlinnie said of offering our time and expertise to prisoners: “If they are continuing to make the same mistakes over and over again and coming back here, then why not try something new?”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos