Is a nice meal on a CalMac ferry worth hundreds of millions?

Passengers survey food options onboard the Glen Sannox <i>(Image: Getty)</i>
Passengers survey food options onboard the Glen Sannox (Image: Getty)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Roz Foyer’s brave attempt to set out a positive prospect for CalMac’s future ("Ferry services could have a bright future – if we grasp it", The Herald, April 14) is worthy of comment.

Like her, I have found the company’s catering staff to be unfailingly friendly and helpful and no doubt the “much-loved” macaroni cheese served in the cafeteria of the larger vessels is tasty. The problem is that these ships are provided with around a dozen catering/retail staff within a total complement of between 27 and 34, mostly on runs of an hour or two with many employees involved in berthing at the terminals. Compare the Norwegian ferries of similar capacity serving the three and a half hour open Atlantic crossings to the Lofoten Islands with total crew complements of not more than 13, including two or three caterers and no terminal personnel.

Bear in mind that each ship is served by two and a half crews, working fortnight on, fortnight off with up to 10 weeks' holiday, that’s some 70 to 80 personnel per ship, plus shore personnel, when other operators do the job safely and efficiently while providing a better service to the communities they serve with a third of that number. That is just one measure of the appalling productivity inherent in the CalMac system that is costing the Scottish public purse literally hundreds of millions that could better aid our health, education and other cash-strapped public services.

Ms Foyer mentions the round table event convened last month by Cabinet Secretary Fiona Hyslop with local authorities, community representatives and unions to look at future CalMac priorities. All very worthy, but it is doubtful if any one of those attending is in any way familiar with the most cost-effective domestic and international practice as regards provision of local island ferry services – in other words, solving CMAL/CalMac’s productivity problem to provide much better services, ie more frequency and more capacity, for significantly less public funding.

There is a group of supportive experts in naval architecture, ship broking, ferry operations and governance, shipbuilding and the requirements of island communities who have the ability to resolve the productivity issue. The Cabinet Secretary should meet with them either individually or collectively. By doing so, and acting on their advice, she could both revolutionise island connectivity while saving at least £100 million per year.

Roy Pedersen, Inverness.


Read more letters


Pubs get a raw deal

Mark Smith's article ("Something has to change: what the sub crawl taught me about the state of Glasgow's pubs", The Herald, April 14) was both perceptive and heartfelt. As a ( now retired) Glasgow publican I can share and well understand the sentiments expressed by many of the people from pubs across the city. One common feeling was that the Scottish Government "has never really helped the hospitality industry", one example given being the significantly lower grants passed on to hospitality outlets during the pandemic in contrast to those in England.

Another thing mentioned was Glasgow's decline: "the shocking state of the streets round about" and "the state of the street outside is shocking" just two quotes which must make publicans wonder what the sky-high business rates they pay are spent on.

Pubs in Glasgow and across Scotland provide employment and are unpaid collectors of tax for a government which gives them little credit or recognition for the economic and societal value they bring through hard work and service to their local communities.

Mark Smith finishes by speaking of "formidable examples of what pubs can mean to local communities" and  he is right to say that "it's under threat. A lot of it could go. And we need to offer more help before it's too late." All we can hope that someone at Holyrood is listening.

Billy Gold, Glasgow.

Monumental mistake

Cammy Day, the former leader of Edinburgh City Council, complains about having suffered “a coordinated political attack” and has also said “there are serious questions to be asked about the motivations behind an individual to bring me down” ("Police say ‘no evidence of criminality’ in Day probe", The Herald, April 14). He may be right.

But without doubt there are also very serious issues which Mr Day himself refused to address  – over the biased, partial, incomplete and unfair wording on the Melville Monument plaque that he commissioned and had installed in Edinburgh’s St Andrew Square, over the role played by Henry Dundas, Viscount Melville, during the UK campaign for the abolition of the slave traffic and slavery itself, in the late 18th and early 19th centuries.

That wording distorts history and continues to mislead residents and tourists alike, as many historians asserted at the time. The “bald truth” can often mislead if it is not “the whole truth” – hence the legal maxim in our judicial system.

John Birkett, St Andrews.

Dobbies messed up with dogs call

Why does Dobbies allow "well-behaved" dogs in its stores? Who decides on whether the said dog is well behaved?

Are the dogs there to make an objective decision on a special toy or what dog food it prefers?

This is an ill-thought-thorough decision by Dobbies purely to increase sales, and what better way to do so than to encourage dogs and their owners into their stores? No thought about dogs messing or urinating on to items for sale or the problems caused by extending dog leads that people could trip over.

The dogs no doubt have travelled to the store in a vehicle and if they require to walk them, why not in the confines of the car park rather than within the premises?

Maybe these dog owners lead hectic lives and require the services of a dog walker through the week and the only quality time they can have with their dogs is at the weekend?

Neil Stewart, Balfron.

The controversial Melville Monument plaqueThe controversial Melville Monument plaque (Image: City of Edinburgh Council)

Untidy with a shaggy nose

Alan Fitzpatrick (Letters, April 12) wonders if the apparently fanciful tasting notes for costly malt whisky are just a marketing gimmick.

I couldn't say, but I must concede that in the following notes about a wine in his catalogue, Gerald Aster's frankness about temporal deficiencies inspires confidence in his judgment as a whole:

"Rather a jumbly, untidy sort of wine, with a big shaggy nose that is at present all over the place, fruitiness shooting off one way, firmness another and body pushing about underneath. It will be as comfortable and comforting as the 1961 Nuit-St-Georges once it has pulled its ends in and settled down."

Robin Dow, Rothesay.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos