LETTERS

How bad does BBC Scotland have to be before we demand control?

Is BBC Scotland failing in its Scottish news coverage? <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
Is BBC Scotland failing in its Scottish news coverage? (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

It was disappointing that Reporting Scotland on Sunday evening did not report Robert MacIntyre’s win, in highly challenging conditions, over the weekend, in the Alfred Dunhill Links Championship ("MacIntyre toasts double Scotch after conquering Old Course", Herald Sport, October 6).

It was a travesty that the BBC and Reporting Scotland did not provide any update on the plight of the Scots kidnapped in international waters and illegally imprisoned by the IDF ("John Swinney calls for 'immediate return' of Scots on Gaza flotilla", heraldscotland, October 6).

How poor does the BBC’s Scottish coverage have to become before the general public demand devolution of broadcasting?

Stan Grodynski, Longniddry.

When will MSP numbers be cut?

I agree with Mark Smith’s view on a “dog-stealing law” being progressed in the Scottish Parliament that there is no need for it as the current law caters perfectly well with the issue ("Be warned: MSPs have had yet another terrible idea for a law. We need change", The Herald, October 6). It does not shed a good light on the function of our parliament which has 129 MSPs; a very high, disproportionate number when compared to Westminster. Perhaps they are simply looking for something to do to justify their existence and dogs and seagulls help pad out their time? I recall when the Scottish Parliament was first constituted that there was considerable comment on the number of MSPs and the response was that such a high number was necessary to administer the workload associated with disentangling many UK issues to a devolved Scotland but that when that work was over, the number would be trimmed down appropriately. I am still waiting for that day but have no faith that the turkeys will vote for Christmas.

What next, a law to ban toffee apples and candy floss?

Duncan Sooman, Milngavie.


Read more letters


In praise of higher taxes

George Morton (Letters, October 2) makes a point that goes to the heart of the question of proper levels of taxation. He writes, in the context of state dirigisme, "we can never know in any detail what folk would have spent their money on, had it not been prised out of their pockets by finance ministers".

This assumes that the money in our pockets is exclusively earned by, and belongs morally to, ourselves. I disagree: the money in my pocket was partially earned by the nurses and doctors who keep me healthy, the bus driver who got me to work, the farmer who put food on my table, and many others. Taxation is only a recognition of that. Anyone who thinks that they got where they are exclusively by their own efforts is wrong, in my opinion. I have also noticed that the happiest, healthiest, and most successful economies almost always have higher taxation than the UK.

John Jamieson, Ayr.

Second homes tax raid is foolish

The foolish tax raid on second home owners is going to encounter the same problems that happened when Welsh councils also tried it.

"Wealthy second home-owners pushing up house prices and forcing out local people" is a tedious cliché constantly trotted out by politicians as they search for convenient scapegoats, but when punitive 300% council tax premiums forced second home owners in Wales to sell up, none of the local people they were supposed to be helping to acquire property wanted to buy the newly available homes no matter how much prices fell.

The fact is that not even second home owners are so rich that they have unlimited money to waste on maintaining complete attractive multi-bedroom family dwellings plus garages and gardens just to use on holidays. The overwhelming majority of "second homes" are actually small cabins and apartments with limited facilities and which are entirely unsuitable for full-time living. Driving away second home owners is a counterproductive policy that benefits no-one – local people don't get anywhere else to live while the local economy suffers from reduced visitors. The tax raid on second homes has no relation to evidence or sense and is just stubbornly and mindlessly ideological.

Robert Frazer, Dundee.

Let our young understand faiths

There is no denying the legitimate interest of the Scottish Secular Society in the Scottish Parliament’s bill offering opt-out from school religious activities. However Neil Barber’s unworthy jibes at the Rev Stephen Miller’s contribution to the debate (Letters, October 4) cheapen the dialogue and are unworthy of serious adult discussion.

At a time when the country is reeling from the Manchester atrocity the case for mutual understanding of the diaspora of religions and cultures in Britain is of paramount importance.

The vast majority of the population react with revulsion at the Manchester shooting; it is not an exclusively religious response. Yet, arguably, the whole foundation of British society – including its moral and democratic values – have been shaped by Christianity.

Instead of promoting ill-informed remarks about faith positions being anti-science and anti-progress Mr Barber would be better advised to familiarise himself with, for example, Tom Holland’s seminal work Dominion, which traces the indelible "shaping" of western society through Christian roots and influence. Giving our young people the opportunity to understand those roots and their associated values is of immense importance – much more so than feeding them ill-conceived negative stereotypes about religion.

Iain Morris, Motherwell.

Does the Scottish Parliament have too many MSPs?(Image: Getty)

How to rescue Langholm

Marc McLean’s article covering Langholm residents being let down over lack of housing ("Langholm residents let down over lack of housing in town", The Herald, October 3) is of great concern.

Langholm needs a development plan which will take into account what is required to provide future infrastructure. This plan should not only include housing and care facilities but improved public transport links.

The proposed extension of the Borders Railway from Tweedbank to Carlisle should be routed through Langholm, giving the town a new lease of life. The cost of this will not be significant relative to the overall cost and the benefits to the town would merit this investment. Will this be considered or will it become another missed opportunity?

Charles Scott, Edinburgh.

Scrap mettle

What a headline on the front page of The Herald today (October 6): "Tories’ Findlay ‘up for scrap’".

Will it be blue recycling bin ? Are there salvageable parts? Or will he just be written off?

Alastair Clark, Stranraer.

• Russell Findlay states that Scotland is "a laboratory for weird and wacky policies". So what's new? Margaret Thatcher started it when she piloted her experimental Poll Tax in Scotland in 1989.

David Hay, Minard.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos