Have you noticed the slump in attendances at the Conservative Conference?
What about that opinion poll result where 64% of Conservatives think that they should form a coalition with Reform?
Did you see Mel Stride's conference speech ("Tories plan to save £47bn", The Herald, October 6) where he laid great emphasis in a slash and burn way on the reduction of the welfare budget, ending his speech with his war cry that "we are the future"?
Does the country really want to go back to the future of 14 years of economic incompetence and chaos which left our country in tatters, under the supervision of those who presided over that collapse?
Add to that Kemi Badenoch's clutching at the straws of the Trumpian policy of removing immigrants in massive numbers so that we can clear the decks for a new Britain unencumbered by the presence of families who have established themselves here. Just how many jumbo jets will we need for what will be the equivalent of a military operation to export our unwanted strangers?
It all reeks of the last throw of the dice in desperate circumstances.
Even the contemplation of a coalition with Reform lets us know that the Tories are fully aware that otherwise they are on the verge of extinction, but they should take heed that the more powerful personalities of Reform are more likely to swamp the voices of the less exciting figures on the Conservative side with their more compelling but less rational rhetoric. In such a coalition, the tail would wag the decrepit dog.
Ms Badenoch boasts about being an engineer but all she has been engineering during this conference is the downfall and demise of what used to be considered the most successful political party in Europe.
Do the Tories think that the people will forget their performance in government so quickly and will be gullible enough to fall for their presentation of unenforceable policies?
Denis Bruce, Bishopbriggs.
Read more letters
- As Jews we beg you: do not let the Manchester attack be weaponised
- How bad does BBC Scotland have to be before we demand control?
- Facing the music – it’s time to tune out green policies
Please, anyone but Farage
In seven months a significant number, hopefully, of us shall be voting for whoever we wish to represent us in the Holyrood Parliament. Polls are currently showing Reform and Scottish Labour as being neck-and-neck in second place, well behind the SNP. For whom do I vote? I don’t yet know.
As a social democrat I recognise that the SNP and the Scottish Greens are the parties with a distinctly social democratic agenda. The Liberal Democrats' agenda contains much in common with these two parties, apart, of course, from independence about which I myself am unenthusiastic unless it becomes unavoidable with an onward march of Reform in England which Scotland manages to avoid.
There is of course a persistent element of social democracy within the Labour Party but it remains to be seen to what extent it can become more influential in developing Labour’s direction in Scotland with Starmer still in power.
Jeremy Corbyn’s party will not have established itself sufficiently north of the Border to have made a vote for it an option. But its time may come. In the next Westminster election?
The Scottish electorate hopefully will reject in no uncertain terms the possibility of Reform becoming the main opposition party in Holyrood. In doing so we will demonstrate our determination to retain the Scottish values of fairness, decency and compassion.
I suggest that the cry be “Anyone but Farage”, bearing in mind that the Conservative Party has become a complete irrelevance.
John Milne, Uddingston.
Enough of the sneers
It was so predictable to hear the Scottish Conservative leader call policies like rent control, a four-day working week and universal basic income “weird and wacky" ("Tories’ Findlay ‘up for scrap’", The Herald, October 6). I would argue that the current rent-control measures in Scotland don’t go nearly far enough. Allowing councils to cap rent increases at inflation plus 1% (up to a 6% maximum) is progress, but many renters remain vulnerable due to exemptions, uneven enforcement, and a housing supply crisis that keeps landlords in a position of leverage.
The Tories love to talk about cutting benefits, but perhaps we should be concentrating instead on creating enough jobs that pay liveable wages, rather than propping up low wages with the benefit system. Many people claiming Universal Credit are already in work, but their earnings don’t stretch to cover rent, bills, or childcare. In Scotland, between 2023 and early 2025, around 33% to 38% of Universal Credit claimants were in work.
If we actually ensured living wages, secure contracts, affordable housing, many fewer people would need to rely on benefits – and fewer families would be living hand to mouth.
Calling such policies “wacky” isn’t just dismissive rhetoric – it’s a deterrent. It sends the message: “Don’t imagine things could be better; don’t expect more from your leaders.” For many Scots, especially younger people, renters, those in insecure work, or in precarious sectors, these aren’t idealistic fantasies but proposals grounded in necessity.
Scotland has already shown leadership: exploring UBI pilots, introducing rent caps, engaging in serious debate about work-life balance. These are not fringe demands – they reflect lived realities. Scotland deserves a politics that meets those realities with solutions, not sneers.
Linda Thompson, Glasgow.
A way to help finance society
Neil Mackay has, as ever, in his article about "wetware" computing ("Growing brains in labs to power computers: this is like a horror movie", The Herald, October 7) let us all know how foolish our governments are, as they blithely hand over all our futures to despots, demagogues and billionaire parasites, whose "intention is to one day put us all out of work". The argument is that people in work cost companies money, and, after all, companies are instructed by law to increase the value of the owners' and shareholders' stakes.
This leads to the fallacy that health and social services, education, lightly-used transport services and affordable housing "lose money". They don't. Sure, they cost money but this cost is the price we all agree to pay, collectively, to live in a safe and just society. The destruction of democracy, trade unions and opportunities for collective action in the public sphere is not new.
It began with the idea that everything should make a profit, but for whom? The Beeching evisceration of the railways, one-person operation of trains, buses and trams, the removal of staffed checkouts in shops, unstaffed car parks, railway stations and public toilets (if there are any left), the closure of libraries and the lack of local policing all tend to keep us at home, alone and fearful of what were once public spaces.
We need more people in work. It's a right and it will cost money. Who's going to pay? Well, how about a one penny tax on all transactions in the City, or a penny for every inquiry on a search engine, or even a levy of 10p an hour spent on social media sites? No individual user would be asked to pay much, but the financial sector particularly would be able to live up to its name, and help, for a change, to finance society. Worth a try, surely.
AJ Clarence, Prestwick.
Russell Findlay speaking during the Tory Conference(Image: PA)
Dictionary corner
Wouldn't it be helpful if we could come up with some sort of system whereby we all agreed that words have a specific and universal meaning?
Sophistry, deliberate obfuscation, pretence, distortion and lies would never again cloud our thinking or make us believe in deranged concepts.
The idea is that words would convey a particular and indivisible meaning and not be open to individual interpretation or preference. We could call it a dictionary.
It would contain such words as murder, genocide, starvation, occupation, theft, colonisation, brutality, immorality and much more. The first editions could be given to the very smart and important people in the world today to assist them in relating to reality. I think Donald Trump, Keir Starmer, Benjamin Netanyahu, Ursula von der Leyen and other politicians would benefit, as would news organisation like the BBC and most of the mainstream media.
Don Ferguson, Kirkintilloch.
Zut alors: who's next?
The fifth leader since the start of 2023, like those before him, is gone. Intractable issues have not been addressed and the situation has not been turned around. There is widespread disquiet and protests on the streets.
Perhaps President Macron should now consider appointing Steven Gerrard to form the next French government.
George Rennie, Inverness.
Share