LETTERS

Keep pupils in school at lunchtime – for the sake of their health

Children enjoying nutritious school meals: is this reason enough to keep younger secondary pupils on the school premises at lunchtime? <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Children enjoying nutritious school meals: is this reason enough to keep younger secondary pupils on the school premises at lunchtime? (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Why is it wrong for Dumfries & Galloway Council to seek to keep younger secondary pupils on the school premises at lunchtime ("These council budget options show how bad things are for the future of education", The Herald, November 8)?

The suggestion that this is simply a money-making exercise overlooks the fact that school meal provision in more councils than Dumfries & Galloway is running at a significant loss due to lack of uptake, yet schools must still provide meals for those who are entitled to free meals. A larger number of pupils taking school dinners would bring about economies of scale and could even reduce the increase in prices, as well as ensuring the least well-off pupils can get a decent meal.

However the main reason for keeping pupils within the school premises is to protect their health by restricting their access to junk food, at an age where they do not yet have the judgement to make healthy choices, as well as facilitating their learning, as teachers will confirm that pupils who have lunched on fizzy drinks, crisps and chocolate are almost unteachable first thing in the afternoon.

I am advised that in England pupils remaining on the school premises at lunchtime is the norm. It may be no coincidence that obesity rates amongst youngsters south of the Border are lower than those in Scotland.

Jane Ann Liston, St Andrews.


Read more letters


Keep the poppy humble

In recent years the small humble red fabric poppy worn for Remembrance Day has changed and evolved and perhaps not for the better.

Many decades ago,with my classmates, I paid my penny for my little red fabric poppy which I was happy to wear. I am confident that most of us knew the significance of the poppy and the special day.

But then our teacher would appear wearing a larger, more ornate and probably more expensive poppy, and other adults also wore different and again bigger poppies. As a child I sometimes wondered if there was some unspoken challenge to see who could buy the biggest and the most luxurious.

Since those days other more ornate and different poppies have been worn: for example, white, blue, yellow each for different related meaning and significance. Then metal poppies, some looking more like brooches than emblems, were added to the mix.

All this seems to have interfered with the original purpose of the red poppy; red for blood shed in our name and also hope for future peace.

But the significance of the humble poppy to me also denoted the fact that the Great Leveller does not make exceptions for the class, race, rank or gender of all those lost in conflict and all poppies should be the same to emphasise this fact.

Next year I would love to see only the little humble red fabric poppy reintroduced exclusively for sale by the Royal British Legion and no one else. No other poppies should be made or sold.

The price should be a donation of any denomination, and in this way the donations would be increased and used in the original intended manner.

Tina Oakes, Stonehaven.

• Following Neil Mackay’s thought-provoking comment on the wearing of a poppy ("The poppy has been hijacked by the far right – this is why I won’t wear it", The Herald, November 6) Ian W Thomson (Letters, November 8) tells us that “his not wearing a poppy will likely make others believe either that he does not believe in remembrance or that he does not care”.

No one should feel obliged to wear a poppy or any other badge or symbol for fear that others may misinterpret their reluctance to do so.

David Clark, Tarbolton.

Fun in the Necropolis

I was intrigued by Mark Smith’s article on Glasgow's Necropolis ("Tear down that wall – the case for change at the Necropolis", The Herald, November 8). As a child of the 1940s, I was born in Firpark Terrace, hemmed in between Tennent’s Brewery, Ark Lane and the said graveyard. I was hence very familiar with it as a playground as all we had to do was sklim over the wall (I am surprised that Mark Smith found it so difficult) and dreep down into the 37 acres where it became the ideal setting for our Wild West shootouts, our hide and seek, and picnics of “ginger” and penny chews on the generously-provided stone tables and chairs of some of the monuments.

We were warned by our parents not to go into the Necropolis (no doubt they had good reason) but, as young primary school-aged kids, that is exactly where we went. Our entry point was from a piece of unbuilt-on land just opposite the primary school which we called “The Rockies” by virtue of an outcrop of rock no bigger than a metre high. Gaining entry and egressing during the day was easy enough but as twilight fell or the winter afternoons closed in, these benign daytime tombstones could take on a menacing perspective. Long shifting shadows played tricks with our minds and a rustle from blown leaves made us run for the safety of the wall, but never wanting to be the first to take flight in case of being thought of as a sissy. Many skinned hands and knees were suffered in the scramble to get over to safety from the imagined dangers lurking in the shadows.

Needless to say, we were completely oblivious to the names or the messages of the inscriptions on the stones. Even the headstone of William Miller, who was born in Ark Lane (now swamped by the brewery), was of no consequence to us, being only concerned with enjoying the freedom of the expansive park – even if a bit intimidated and frightened by it. Surely that was part of the reason for being there in the first place?

As for a new East gate: that would be no fun.

Ken Kennedy, Stornoway.

A view of Glasgow's NecropolisA view of Glasgow's Necropolis (Image: Newsquest)

When police were dog tired

BBC Radio Scotland recently carried a story about Cowdenbeath Football Club having season tickets for dogs. The article, although true, was rather tongue in cheek but it reminded me of football games not so long ago before all-seated stadia. In the west of Scotland, it was not uncommon for someone to smuggle in a dog, usually what could best be described as a “Heinz 57 varieties”, on to the terracing and at a suitable point in the match, the poor animal was tossed on to the pitch. The traumatised dog then ran about and caused interference with play. In those days, Glasgow’s finest policemen patrolled trackside and the real amusement was watching “the polis” chasing a frantic dog, usually including a few face plantings. It fairly provided amusement for thousands of fans.

It is also worth saying to avoid football tribal rivalry, I witnessed this spectacle at Rangers, Celtic and Partick Thistle with equal enjoyment and remember that it was probably the only time opposing fans were in unison.

Duncan Sooman, Milngavie.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos