ALAN SIMPSON

How cold, hard cash may just solve the depopulation crisis

Typical Highland scene in Kinlochleven, Lochaber.Photograph by Colin Mearns <i>(Image: Colin Mearns)</i>
Typical Highland scene in Kinlochleven, Lochaber.Photograph by Colin Mearns (Image: Colin Mearns)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Offering cash incentives to entice young professionals to live in rural Scotland could just solve the depopulation crisis and should be considered, argues Herald columnist Alan Simpson.


Rural Scotland is rightly lauded across the world and attracts hundreds of thousands of visitors every year to enjoy the history and the all-round splendour.

Most of us urban dwellers will say that we enjoy regular trips into the ‘countryside’ for a bit of R&R as often as we can.

There is nothing better than breathing in the clear, fresh air in the Scottish countryside to reinvigorate the soul after all.

 Most of us probably have a wee pipe dream too about buying a house somewhere and living out our lives in splendid isolation.

But in reality could we city dwellers really hack it in a rural setting?

The answer to that is undoubtedly no and partly explains why rural areas suffer from chronic depopulation issues. 

We like the convenience of things being nearby if we’re honest, and the thought of travelling for hours just for a hospital appointments is one that would fill us with dread.

I guess, the only people that can really feel totally comfortable living in remote areas are those that are born and raised there, but even a lot of them leave at a young age for better lives in cities.

And who can blame them?

All of which, of course, leaves the serious problem of depopulation which threatens the very existence of some - how do you beat that?

Bid to lure people to rural Scotland with half a million cash pot

Brian Wilson: Only radical action on land and housing can save rural Scotland

Brian Wilson: Want to revitalise rural Scotland? Here's how to do it

Father and farmers unite in concern over mental health support in rural Scotland

Well, this week a new report came up with a few suggestions that should be considered very carefully by politicians.

The ideas include writing off the student debt of young professionals or offering them financial incentives to move.

Ministers are being urged to follow Norway and Canada and consider the move for certain “priority professions” to encourage more young people to settle in areas facing the greatest challenge, including the Highlands.

Canada has implemented a programme of “golden handshakes” and student loan forgiveness for health professionals who choose to move to remote and rural communities for work.

The approach mirrors action taken in Norway to write off student debt when filling rural vacancies in certain professions.

The country has also created bespoke tax arrangements for individuals moving to areas facing depopulation.

Scottish Land & Estates says Scotland must draw on international best practice to urgently tackle the problem in Repopulation Priority Areas (RPAs).

An action plan put together by the rural business organisation suggests the Scottish Government could target certain roles including health, social care, early years, trades and engineering.

The scheme would have a maximum amount that could be written off and a maximum number of years it may be claimed for.

The average student debt for Scottish students entering repayment in 2022-23 was approximately £15,430, with interest rates at 6.25%.

It is no surprise that rural Scots are angry about public transport

It feels like we're back in the 1980s - and I don't mean that in a good way

Ministers should stop fining CalMac until they get new ferries

The 400,000 reasons that Argyll locals can finally rest and be thankful

Cameron Gillies, head of external affairs at Scottish Land & Estates, said: “The reality is that rural depopulation is already reshaping the social and economic fabric of Scotland.

“Schools are closing, services are being withdrawn and employers are struggling to fill roles. Unless we change course, many communities will simply not have the critical mass they need to survive.”

“This student loan write-down proposal comes from both Norway and Canada so there are examples internationally of where they have spoken to people about what would incentivise them to return to a rural area or consider living there for the first time. That was something that kept coming up. It’s something that hangs over people and is clear incentivisation for people to move and is has worked internationally.”

The report also calls for the creation of a Rural Homes Accelerator programme, employer incentives and the decentralisation of public-facing civil service jobs to rural areas. 

It highlights action already taken to boost populations in Argyll & Bute, where Luss Estates Company launched a 10-year land use and development plan in 2023, including the provision of more than 100 housing units.

Sixteen recommendations in total are made within the report, with SLE estimating an annual cost of between £80 million and £150m, depending on how many of the proposals are enacted.

It suggests that grants could be made available to protect fragile commercial services including shops, fuel stations, post offices, pharmacies, GP services and schools, emulating a scheme operating in Sweden.

Canada’s Rural and Northern Immigration Pilot, launched in 2019, allows designated small communities to recruit and retain skilled newcomers to settle permanently. “Canada has trialled some visa incentivisation schemes looking at the kind of workers they want to bring to remote and rural areas,” said Mr Gillies.

Last year, The Herald embarked on a new series investigating an issue which has been raised repeatedly in our coverage of exclusive stories, impacting on Scotland’s Highlands and Islands.

Local people, affected by issues surrounding transport, infrastructure and opportunities, have described the region as being in the midst of “New Highland Clearances”.

The latest population statistics show most council areas projected to decline in population are in the west of Scotland, and many island and rural areas are expected to see either decreases or growth below the national average.

What is quite clear is that something needs to be done - and quickly. Doing nothing is not an option.

Offering lucrative cash incentives seems to be an obvious solution but the problem goes much deeper than a lack of young professionals.

Rural Scotland, particularly in the remotest parts, are badly served by most politicians who don’t seem to understand the problems are, far less try and find solutions.

But it’s probably a bit too easy just to blame politicians as the issue has been happening for many generations.

Most young people are forced to move for college or university and are unlikely to move back after graduation as the decent jobs are most likely to be found in the cities.

Living in rural areas as a teenager can also be pretty boring I would imagine, so it is easy to understand how they would get lured away by the bright lights as soon as they can.

Who wouldn’t after all?

The biggest single issue I suppose is a lack of decent employment prospects and this is a very hard problem to solve.

It’s all well and good offering incentives to teachers, nurses or doctors but they are in a very small minority. Bank branches are closing all over Scotland let alone in rural parts. so there goes another source of decent job prospects.

Aquaculture is one area which offers good jobs as does the whisky industry but neither are particularly labour intensive.

These have helped to plug the gap caused by the demise of traditional jobs such as fishing or farming but not totally.

Regardless, some clever thinking and cold, hard cash needs to be deployed and hopefully the latest report’s ideas will be put into practice.

It’s the least that should be done.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos