Kristy Dorsey

Overhaul to bridge Scotland's skills gap is long overdue

If the workforce can't be trained and retrained quickly enough to reverse declining productivity, Scotland's economy risks losing investment, talent and market share in high-value sectors such as green energy <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
If the workforce can't be trained and retrained quickly enough to reverse declining productivity, Scotland's economy risks losing investment, talent and market share in high-value sectors such as green energy (Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The road to ruin is paved to a great extent by slabs of good intentions lacking durable foundations, quickly creating stumbling blocks and pitfalls along the path to a better future.

This has led to a paradox at the heart of Scotland's economy as we head into 2026. On some measures, business confidence has improved despite several bruising years of rising costs and feeble customer sentiment. But while most firms understand the way forward, many are caught in a trap where they simply can't do what needs to be done.

The clarity of purpose when it comes to skills and training is reflected in survey results from the latest business barometer produced by the Bank of Scotland, in which 46% of Scottish firms reported that they will be focussing on upskilling their people in the coming year. Another 44% will be looking to enhance their use of technology.

Despite the investment froth around AI, artificial intelligence is delivering some productivity improvements and will continue to do so.

New research published today by accountancy group Deloitte's found that 59% of finance chiefs across the UK have become more optimistic during the past 12 months on the potential for AI to boost the performance of their organisation, up from 39% in the third quarter of 2024. But employers also increasingly understand that output, competitiveness and innovation ultimately depend on their people, and their ability to put technology to its best use.


Read more:


Upskilling is no longer an afterthought but 42% of those surveyed in the Bank of Scotland's monthly survey said this is the area where they most need external support. In turn, policymakers have acknowledged that structural challenges including inflation, labour shortages, supply chain disruption and rapid technological change all demand a more agile skills system.

In 2023 the Scottish Government published its independent review of the skills delivery landscape, a sweeping assessment of how the country trains, retrains, and supports its workforce. The review called for a simpler, more coherent system that employers could more easily navigate. The Scottish Parliament’s economy and fair work committee has since held evidence sessions to track progress and push for alignment with industry needs, including the rapidly-growing demand for green skills.

Businesses and government leaders are no longer debating whether to invest in training, but rather how to do it fast enough. The problem is that awareness is not the same thing as action, creating dislocation between rhetoric and reality.

While many firms say they are prioritising training, the follow‑through is uneven. Small and medium-sized businesses (SMEs) in particular face tight margins and limited cash flow, with consumer prices approximately 20% higher than three years ago. In such circumstances, training budgets are often the first to be squeezed.


Read more:


Meanwhile, the 2023 review was blunt in its assessment that Scotland’s skills landscape is cluttered with overlapping agencies, unclear responsibilities, and inconsistent funding streams. SMEs, which rarely have dedicated HR or training departments, find this especially challenging. As one business owner put it during a parliamentary evidence session: “It’s not that the support isn’t there – it’s that you need a map and a translator to find it.”

Fast‑moving sectors such as tech, renewables, and advanced manufacturing report persistent shortages in mid‑level technical skills. Colleges and training providers are working to adapt, but the pace of change is slow compared to the speed of industry transformation.

Why the struggle? In addition to the financial and structural pressures mentioned above, labour shortages have created a vicious cycle at the centre of Scotland's skills crisis.

Whether by choice or necessity, far too many firms are habitually operating on unrealistically low staffing levels. One unexpected event – illness, an accident, or merely a cancelled flight when returning from holiday – that takes a single employee out of action cascades into a crisis for a remaining team already labouring at maximum capacity.


Read more:


Even on a day-to-day level such organisations find it difficult to spare staff time for proper training required for future growth. The result is stagnation: firms tread water instead of swimming forward.

Failure to invest for the long-term has frittered away research and industrial infrastructure that at one time was the envy of the world. The same is true of Scottish and UK workers too frequently called upon to "up their game" without the tools to do so, and the cost is significant.

Scotland has long lagged behind the UK and OECD averages in productivity growth. If the workforce can't be trained and retrained quickly enough to reverse this trend, the country's economy risks losing investment, talent and market share in high-value sectors such as financial services, life sciences, green energy and the burgeoning space industry.


Read more:


Large firms are generally better-equipped to absorb training costs and plan multi-year workforce strategies when compared to the SMEs that account for more than half of all private sector employment and the vast majority of private sector companies in Scotland.

A widening gap in training provision between large and small companies is therefore a threat to Scotland's broader economic resilience, and justifies detailed examination of targeted support for SMEs. This could include grants, tax incentives or wage subsidies delivered via a simplified system that is easier to access and understand.

Most of the discussion around work-based training is focused on young adults at the beginning of their careers, and this too must be re-examined. In a world of rapid change upskilling cannot be a one-off intervention, but rather a continuous process embedded in the country's economic DNA.

As Martyn Kendrick of Bank of Scotland put it, “Scottish businesses are putting people at the centre of their investment plans”. The question now is whether Scotland’s skills system – and its policymakers – will match that commitment .

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos