Will we ever be free of the tyranny of dog owners?

Dogs in restaurants: is this going too far in the pampering of the nation's pooches? <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
Dogs in restaurants: is this going too far in the pampering of the nation's pooches? (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

I seem to disagree with most everything Mark Smith writes. He certainly didn’t think much about cyclists in his recent article on roundabouts (“Traffic lights are in trouble – time for a roundabout revolution on roads”, The Herald, December 8, 2025) and I would be surprised if he wasn't one of the many self-righteous dog owners who have taken over all dual-use paths with their untrained animals ("Environmentalists are coming for our dogs. It’s the wrong target", The Herald, January 10).

Their dogs, "free of analysis and worry", dart around bikes because they can’t figure out that getting run over by one can be dangerous both to their unthinking self and the cyclist. To be fair to most of them, they’re not aggressive. That’d be because the owners have had their pets’ bits cut off so as they become nicely laid-back and less annoying. They have indeed created these stupid creatures for their own ends, a bit like eunuchs back in the day.

It’s not just whilst cycling that we must endure them now. Many a time I’ve seen owners put dogs on to tables in restaurants. They’re nearly always on the seats and not on the floor. They’re also on the seats on buses and I heard a dog fight in a shopping mall the other day, a place where they’re definitely not supposed to be. No doubt they were peeing in there as well.

The rest of us endure your dog, Mr Smith, when it jumps onto our clean clothes, and when we sit on bus seats, because we must and because dog owners are so pervasive and assume we also love their little creatures. Dog owners enforce their standards on the rest of us.

Angus MacEachran, Aberdeen.

 • I am always delighted when out walking or cycling when respectful dog owners make their well-trained dogs sit at the side of the path to allow others to pass. I always make a point of thanking them profusely. There seem to be three stock phrases which are used by dog owners when a dog jumps up or races around in circles at my feet. One is "he’ll no’ touch you" or "he just wants to be friendly" or "he thinks everyone should be his friend". I have seen joggers and cyclists nearly having accidents as they are impeded by unpredictable dogs and their careless owners.

I do not think it is having a "self-righteous attitude" as suggested by Mark Smith to be cautious about any unrestrained canine who races toward me. Having had trousers torn and a nip by a Jack Russell and a bite to the bone by an untrained collie, not to mention meeting dog owners who don’t seem think it is any concern of theirs if the dog jumps up and leaves me with muddy clothes, I don’t consider it to be an overreaction to be nervous around badly trained dogs. In England and Wales, police recorded approximately 32,000 to 32,568 dog attacks in 2024. These are only the recorded attacks. Others probably don’t bother to report them, as the attacks seem to continue with impunity anyway.

Irene Munro, Conon Bridge.


Read more letters


Money-grabbing at the airport

I'd like to take exception to Eric Melvin's suggestion (Letters, January 9) that "Edinburgh Airport is quite simply not fit for purpose".

It's 100% fit for purpose, which is depriving holidaymakers and other travellers of as much money as possible, be it via parking charges, drop-off fees, tat for sale, overpriced sandwiches and drinks via a number of outlets or even via coffees that are now self-service at one emporium, but only once one has queued and paid for a cup.

This business model for departures seems largely to be achieved through a combination of monetising as much space as possible, rendering free space (or any sense of it) and non-spending-orientated seating at a premium. And on the latter, said seating appears to have been designed to be as uncomfortable as possible.

It's a shame that in the country of Robert Louis Stevenson his phrase "to travel hopefully is a better thing than to arrive" has been utterly inverted.

Kenneth Reid, Edinburgh.

Points on percentages

Iain McIntyre (Letters, January 12) is confused between percentage reductions and percentage point reductions. A reduction from 20% to 5% is a reduction of 15 percentage points but also a percentage reduction of 75%. This is because the baseline for calculating the latter is not 100 but 20. If the risk of an event occurring reduces from 20% to 5%, that is a 75% reduction in risk since the event now occurs only one quarter of the times it previously did.

In a long professional career handling statistical data, I learned early that the greatest risk with percentages was applying the wrong baseline. I also learned that surprisingly few people really understand percentages, which is no doubt why politicians love bandying them about misleadingly and confusingly.

No AI was involved in the writing of this letter.

(Dr) Dave Gordon, Perth.

Edinburgh Airport has come in for criticism in these pages of late (Image: Newsquest)

World Cup: sorry, but I can't wait

R Johnston (Letters, January 12), advises recording the opening match in Scotland's World Cup campaign then "watching it at leisure". I must congratulate your correspondent on having nerves of steel, but I would suggest that "in the real world" – in the real Scotland – lesser mortals, ie much of the population, will be glued to the nation's televisions, and while they may well also be recording Scotland's return to the World Cup after an absence of 28 years, they won't want to miss a live second of the action, and perhaps down a dram or two, for medicinal purposes only, of course.

Ruth Marr, Stirling.

Freedom to follow Wallace

Stuart Hindmarsh (Letters, January 2) needs to man up. He has little to worry about if he's "genuinely perplexed" about Scottish men wearing shorts in January.

What would he dare say to William Wallace, Rob Roy MacGregor and the like wearing kilts a few centuries ago  and, presumably, like fur-clad Morningside ladies, wi' nae knickers either?

I'd be generally perplexed if these two Scottish heroes were dressed in "coat, hat and gloves" a la Mr Hindmarsh.

From a shorts-wearing 68-year-old.

James Mill, Glasgow.

A dead loss

Anent the recent passing of Sir Tom Stoppard, a box office reported a telephone call from a lady who asked for "two tickets for that new play about two characters from Shakespeare's play, Hamlet". "Ah, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead," was the helpful reply. "Oh dear. I'm so sorry. I didn't know."

She rang off and was never heard from again.

Donald M Manson, Prestwick.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos