LETTERS

Electoral reform is a must. Here's why Yes voters should back it

Is it time to reform the voting system for Scottish elections? <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
Is it time to reform the voting system for Scottish elections? (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Mark Smith's article on voting trends ("I’m a proud part of the 40% that will decide the Scottish election. What on earth should we do?", The Herald, March 9) and the letter (March 9) from Sandy Slater serve the very important purpose of demonstrating how the Additional Member System (AMS) as used in Scotland is unfit for purpose and is in need of reform.

At its most simple, its worst feature is the presence of the second Regional List vote, which encourages tactical voting, and has the effect of allowing a second vote to a single voter. The abuse of the system is a distorting factor which benefits some parties disproportionately – there is evidence all over social media in the form of recommendations, for example, on how supporters of independence should vote. So a simple solution would be to restrict voting in Holyrood elections to one vote and then for top-up seats to be awarded proportionately to votes cast for the candidates of the respective parties.

Even better, however, would be to reform the system completely and to make it as truly representative of votes cast as possible. My own preference would be for the compromise suggested by Mr Speaker Lowther [Speaker of the House of Commons between 1905 and 1921] for Westminster elections (incidentally even more in need for reform than Holyrood) – that is to say Single Transferable Vote (STV) in urban areas and Alternative Vote (AV) in sparsely inhabited areas.

Nationalists should also note that electoral reform that results in a truly representative Scottish Parliament would be an outcome that could work in their favour: instead of trying to manipulate the flaws in the system to create the lowest fence to jump, they would be able to say to Scotland's Westminster government: "Look, we have the backing of a true majority of voters in Scotland" – which is a lot more powerful than "well, we got a majority of seats but some of those are based on people gaming the system". This could then be the platform for a very reasonable proposal to devolve a unilateral power to hold Indyref2 – for example, if Holyrood was to approve it with the backing of two-thirds of MSPs representing two-thirds of the voters.

I became convinced about electoral reform when I heard the late Robin Cook speak on the subject, and he made two striking points. The first was that if a party or cause wished to make radical and transformational change, it should only attempt to do so if it had the clear and demonstrable support of the electorate to do so. How could Scottish independence not meet that requirement? The other point was that if First Past The Post (FPTP) was supposed to deliver strong government, he was sick of it – having the policies of a minority forced down the throat of the majority. This was in the time of Margaret Thatcher, but the same applies to the SNP now and in the recent past. So let us have a truly proportionate electoral system at Holyrood. It is in the hands of the Scottish Parliament itself and no-one else.

Peter A Russell, Glasgow.


Read more letters


Why the List vote is fair

Mark Smith's article compares voting percentages for the Holyrood constituency vote, declaring (amongst other things) that "a 36% vote for the SNP would make it the biggest party in Holyrood... but that should not be a mandate for another referendum on independence. Ha ha ha".

He then totals the constituency votes for unionist parties, coming up with a figure of 55%, which he presumably thinks supports his point.

But if he wants to use our constituency first past the post vote as the decider, then winning the single largest number of seats does give a mandate, regardless of the number of votes. Just like Westminster where, as Mark Smith reminds us, "at the General Election in 2024 Labour turned 34% of the vote into 63% of the parliament" – including a mandate to deliver its manifesto.

A reminder for Mr Smith. Not all parties that support independence are fielding constituency candidates. Some only stand on the Regional List, where parties supporting independence took more than 50% of the vote between them at the last Holyrood election.

So we are where we are, and in two months' time we'll work with the system in place. If that gives the biggest party for independence a mandate for an independence referendum based on the biggest number of seats, so be it. If not, I guess we'll have another go at the next Westminster election. Same rules as worked in 2024 for Labour – a majority of Scotland's Westminster seats for the SNP gives the mandate.

Then again: if Westminster stopped refusing permission for a new independence referendum, Mark and others in his 40% might find it easier to decide how best to use their Holyrood MSP vote?

Ian Waugh, Dumfries.

The process explained

In response to Sandy Slater's appeal (Letters, March 9) for an explanation of the list vote counting system, although I am not an esteemed Herald columnist perhaps I can help. The simple consequence of the D'Hondt system is that a party winning "X" constituency seats in a region has its regional list votes immediately scaled down by a factor of "X+1" in the count to allocate the first list seat. Parties with zero constituency seats enter the list count with a scale factor of "0+1" and therefore have every vote counting until they are successful in gaining a seat after which their scaling down factor would become 1+1 in the next count. This process continues until all available seats have been allocated and means that if a party is very successful in the constituency ballot most – or even all – list votes cast for that party may be wasted, whereas they could have allowed other smaller parties to win list seats.

It's not rocket science, just simple arithmetic – unless you think the "X" factor makes it algebra – but it is important to those of us who put nation before party.

Willie Maclean, Milngavie.

Yet more SNP virtue-signalling

The SNP and Scottish Greens are busy posturing about banning US aircraft from Prestwick ("Swinney ‘could ban US military flights’", The Herald, March 9), yet seem reluctant to show the same moral clarity about the regime at the centre of this crisis.

If John Swinney truly cares about “state behaviour”, he should start with Iran’s record. It is widely documented as a regime of executions, censorship, repression of protest, systematic discrimination against women, persecution of minorities, and brutal punishments.

Second, this is becoming a pattern. Holyrood is quick to issue grand statements on international conflicts, while ordinary Scots face rising council tax, struggling local services, and politics that too often feels like performance rather than delivery. People want competence, not theatrics.

A serious government focuses on core duties, stands firm against tyrannies, and restores trust by doing fewer things better. Scotland deserves less virtue-signalling and more leadership that reflects common sense.

Alastair Majury, Dunblane.

John Swinney is reported to be considering the role of Prestwick Airport in US operations (Image: PA)

Migrants: know your history

Clark Cross (Letters, March 9) trundles out the usual rhetoric of migrants being housed in hotels at taxpayers’ expense and "provided with sexual health clinics”.

I’d bet my house on my belief that he’s never met or engaged with one asylum seeker. I have and helped them adapt to a new life in a new country, Scotland, after fleeing violence and persecution in their own, namely Iran, and this was before the current war.

Does Mr Cross, and others like him, not know their own history?

When Scots were cleared out of the Highlands more than 200 years ago they were welcomed in America as immigrants and many went on to make their names and fortunes.

Then in the 1940s we were offered the chance to go to Australia for £10. Many did and prospered.

What problem does Mr Cross have with people from other countries coming here and doing the same?

Andy Stenton, Glasgow.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos