LETTERS

How are we supposed to make an informed choice in the list vote?

Is the voting system for the Scottish Parliamentary elections fatally flawed? <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Is the voting system for the Scottish Parliamentary elections fatally flawed? (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

I have always understood that when I vote in an election, I am choosing the person I want to represent me. Their personal values and integrity are more important to me than the party they represent, although that party’s manifesto is a relevant consideration.

For the Scottish Parliamentary elections, I can assess the candidates standing in my constituency through local media, campaign materials and hustings. However, it is far harder to find meaningful information about those standing on the regional lists.

I have examined the top three candidates for the six main parties in the Highlands and Islands region. Of these 18 candidates, five are former MSPs whose records can be judged. A further 10 are candidates in other constituencies in the region, often in areas far removed from my own. I can find very little information about them. For the remaining three, beyond a name and photograph on a party website, there is virtually nothing. This makes informed scrutiny by voters difficult and weakens the direct accountability we should expect of elected representatives.

Consequently, once elected, some list MSPs may consider themselves more accountable to party structures than to the electorate. There is frequent comment on the poor quality of debate at Holyrood and I think there may be a link. MSPs relying heavily on speeches and questions prepared by political advisers may, in doing so, demonstrate greater loyalty to their party rather than to those who elected them.

A system based entirely on a larger number of constituencies, using the Single Transferable Vote, could retain broad proportionality while ensuring every MSP has a direct electoral mandate from identifiable voters. That would strengthen both accountability and engagement in our parliamentary democracy.

George Rennie, Inverness.


Read more letters


So many are in denial

We have a choice on May 7: to vote for a party proposing constitutional change or to tacitly accept decline instead of harbouring hope. Staying at home will not arrest the UK decline which is dragging Scotland down, and voting for the Tories, or ex-Tories, or wannabe-Tories, will only accelerate that decline.

UK Government low-tax policies coupled with austerity have bankrupted councils in England while all councils throughout the UK are struggling to provide even the most basic services such as filling pot-holes in our roads. Even in England which has been slow to adopt a more holistic approach to education, PISA test scores are falling. Admittedly the NHS is better staffed in Scotland and performing best in the UK across many comparable statistics while the Scottish Government also has a greater commitment to social care and welfare, but there is still much scope for improvement in our public services overall. The Liberal Democrats appear content to spout the need for electoral reform but would rather say nothing about fundamental change, even federalism, than upset their cosy standing within the failing UK constitutional status quo.

Of course Brexit accelerated the decline of the disunited kingdom but instead of confronting this reality, sadly much of the population remains in denial (as evidenced in many letters published on these pages) and would rather pick at plukes than lance the malignantly-swelling boil at the heart of Britain’s demise.

Stan Grodynski, Longniddry.

Celebrities squared

Regarding actors getting involved in the election campaign (Letters, April 27), I seem to remember that a month before the Scottish independence referendum in 2014, 200 celebrities signed a letter urging Scotland to vote No. Signatories included Dame Judi Dench, Sir Mick Jagger, Helena Bonham Carter, and Sting.

I don't recall anyone from the unionist Better Together campaign complaining about that.

Ruth Marr, Stirling.

• Perhaps the most high-profile SNP supporters are actors Alan Cumming, Brian Cox and Martin Compston. The party places much value on their support, which is unsurprising given the trio’s talent for portraying fiction and fantasy as fact.

Mark Openshaw, Aberdeen.

Norway shows the way

Norway has confirmed the procurement of at least five UK-designed frigates in a £10 billion deal to enhance its naval capabilities.

The deal is expected to support approximately 4,000 jobs in the UK, including over 2,000 at BAE Systems in Glasgow.

Ian H C Stein (Letters, April 25) asks: “Does Scotland, alone, have the revenues necessary for the protection of our coastline and offshore energy sources?”

He concludes that he is a “realist who certainly won’t vote for any party which pretends that an independent Scotland would be capable of defending itself, whether in or out of the EU and Nato.”

May I suggest that a realist would question how we arrived at this parlous state of affairs and why Westminster hesitates whilst Norway acts?

Alan Carmichael, Glasgow.

Misleading manifestos

We recently experienced peak manifesto: glossy brochures, shortly to be consigned to the recycling bin, along with promises long forgotten, delivered in a wave of political spin. Call me cynical but just check out the 2021 SNP manifesto and you will see a plethora of undelivered promises across the board. We were promised independence, A9 dualling, ferries aplenty, a new social care system and so on but sadly not delivered.

That said, each party in turn tells us that its manifesto promises are "fully costed", which seems to be the manifesto phrase du jour. Sadly, fully costed means absolutely nothing, the question is whether their collective promises are actually affordable. As the years progress many of the promises will be randomly discarded at the altar of the annual budget.

Within the SNP manifesto John Swinney has added £1.4 billion of annual costs. I think we should be told which promises will inevitably be first to bite the dust. I'm betting his potty food cap will be the first to go but not without a grievance with Westminster. However, we will not be told but expect much non-delivery of the glossy brochure promises. Tell me I'm wrong…

Ian McNair, Cellardyke.

Where are the serious policies?

So, goodies or gimmicks? Is that as much as the various parties can offer the electorate for the forthcoming election?

Where are the properly costed, serious policies? Where are the properly competent, serious candidates?

After decades of wasteful expenditure, the SNP makes great play of new walk-in GP clinics for the NHS, while cutting the actual GP budget by five per cent. Labour struggles to get rid of the Starmer millstone round its neck. The only thing on which I agree with Reform is that change is needed, but not with someone like Nigel Farage as its leader, especially with all the failed Tories now having jumped ship.

I despair for the outcome of this election. At least we have the LibDems for a protest vote. Perhaps they might just come through.

John NE Rankin, Bridge of Allan.

Brian Cox is a celebrity supporter of Scottish independence (Image: Colin Mearns)

Starmer must change course on EU

Economist John Maynard Keynes is credited with saying “When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?”

It appears that, to some extent, Prime Minister Starmer is aware of this as he seeks to pursue a "reset" of the UK-EU relationship and build closer links across economic, security, and energy sectors.

However, he is categorically ruling out a return to the EU, the single market, or the customs union.

While he cites the long-term economic damage from Brexit as the reason for stronger ties, he is bizarrely rejecting rejoining the European Union.

This runs counter to public opinion: recent polling indicates that around 55 per cent of people in the UK would support the country rejoining the EU, while only 33 per cent oppose.

Brexit has been estimated to cost the UK up to £90 billion in tax revenue, money that could have gone towards improving public services.

It has been a disaster, costing jobs, raising prices, and harming our economy. Only last month, Chancellor Rachel Reeves highlighted estimates that Brexit has reduced UK gross domestic product by as much as eight per cent.

The damage from Brexit is far from over, and the current Gulf war is simply adding to our woes. For Keir Starmer to reject rejoining the EU, which is clearly in the public interest and supported by it, is highly reckless and irresponsible.

Alex Orr, Edinburgh.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos