The announcement that significant plans for expansion of the Scottish Event Campus (SEC) is welcome news, as is replacement of the so-called "Smartie tube" pedestrian and cycle access across the Clyde Expressway ("Flynn hails £1bn vision for event campus expansion", The Herald, September 12).
At 47 years old, Exhibition Centre station pre-dates the SEC site by six years, is one of ScotRail's busiest stations and surely due for a major upgrade to deal with existing and future passenger loadings, particularly during major concerts and festivals.
Consideration should be given to forming a third through platform by adapting the present carriage siding to allow supplementary services to be operated. Design of the new pedestrian/cycle bridge should be used to design vastly improved access to the station via escalators and lifts.
Improvements to this presently cramped station would certainly contribute immensely to previously-declared global comparison with the likes of Lisbon, Bilbao, Melbourne, New York and London.
Craig Crawford, Howwood.
Tram switch on wrong lines
Your report on Edinburgh City Council’s £1.7 billion tram pivot ("Capital’s northern tram line plan shelved as southern route backed", The Herald, September 11) exposes a strategy destined for systemic failure. By hitching the southern extension to the new SEStransit study – a partnership between SEStran, Transport Scotland, and Network Rail – the council is entering a political quagmire. SEStran comprises conflicting regional authorities that will fiercely compete for the exact same limited funds, virtually guaranteeing long-term delivery gridlock.
While I have long supported the principle of reviving the South Suburban Railway, history offers a cautionary tale. When Professor George Hazel heavily investigated this option, a distinct lack of projected passenger numbers made the line operationally unviable. Reintroducing heavy-rail integration now multiplies stakeholder dependencies, drastically complicating the tram's economic case.
This raises a critical question: why is the council spending £30 million just to develop an Outline Business Case tied to a moving target? Transport Scotland and Network Rail may not even agree to the final set-up. Yet even if they do, projected passenger numbers remain entirely critical; if the volumes fail to justify heavy infrastructure, Edinburgh’s expensive integration plans will be rendered obsolete.
This strategic shift does not solve the tram’s financial crisis; it merely kicks it into the long grass until at least late 2027. The council is putting millions of pounds of development capital at immediate risk of becoming aborted costs, ensuring actual delivery remains a distant, unfunded prospect.
John RT Carson, South Queensferry.
Read more letters
- William and Catherine, don’t send George to boarding school
- Civil servants shouldn’t need vouchers to coax them to work
- Breaking up Glasgow could haul it back from the brink
The case for office working
I worked for Shell (UK) Exploration and Production Limited (Shell Expro for short) in the 1980s in Central London. There were 10,000 employees scattered in various offices with the giant Shell Centre on the South Bank, Shell Mex House on the Strand and a plethora of satellite offices. It was Shell Expro policy to have a free hot beverage machine on every floor of every office. In addition, Expro supplied free lunches, in part because there were not enough facilities on the streets to supply the 10,000 employee demands locally.
There was however another primary justification for these "freebies": employees stayed local and they were regarded as essential communication devices where chance meetings in relaxed circumstances, often between unrelated department employees and often between employees of the same department, promoted ideas and discussions and aide-mémoires and as such they were highly effective and acted upon very quickly when employees returned to their desk.
This was at a time when development in the North Sea was fast and furious not only in the continuous and fast expanding size of the task but also in the constant challenges in the forefront of greater technologies and harsher environments.
This would have been impossible with home working and the lack of personal daily contact that is so essential in efficiently completing daily tasks and creating new methods and routines.
This is no different in government offices where personal interaction is an important part of daily life and keeping abreast of not only the task in hand but in how colleagues combine in achieving satisfactory outcomes.
Peter Wright, West Kilbride.
Food for thought on delivery firms
Alan Simpson makes rather a meal of his opinion piece ("Is delivering food really the best use of police officer time?", The Herald, September 14). He fails to ask who is ultimately responsible for illegally modified e-bikes being used for food deliveries.
Surely the blame should be shared with the companies such as Deliveroo and Uber Eats who have deployed these riders to make food deliveries?
They should be forced to ensure that deliveries made on their behalf are conducted legally, and also provide decent working conditions for these riders.
In New York Mayor Mamdani is aiming to end criminal enforcement against e-bike riders and cyclists for low-level traffic offences, expand safety training for all e-bike delivery workers and strengthen accountability for app-based delivery companies. This balanced approach supports riders whilst protecting pedestrians and motorists.
Ian Maxwell, Edinburgh.
Has Edinburgh City Council made the wrong decision on the city's trams? (Image: Gordon Terris)
Nothing new under the sun
In a Glasgow Tourist Guide from the 1950s (found lurking in the back of a drawer), I was intrigued to read in the "Curling and Skating" section: "At Crossmyloof the finest curlers in Scotland play the Roarin' Game – they can no longer depend on outdoor ice'".
Whaur's yer global warmin noo?
Lesley Boyd, Edinburgh.
Canine connoisseur
Denis Bruce’s entertaining letter (September 14) on his Cavalier spaniel’s ostensible aversion to the sight and sound of Kemi Badenoch on television, put me in memory of a friend's rottweiler, who was affectionately known as the “You’ve Been Framed dog”. Upon hearing the famous You’ve Been Framed theme tune of a Saturday evening, the rottweiler would start jumping around the room barking before positioning himself in front of the screen.
One evening, our friend switched the television off during the theme tune, and the dog shot off into the other sitting room where our friend's wife was sitting and started barking at the screen for her to change the channel.
John G McMenemy, Milngavie.
Share