Conference season is upon us. Rejoice all those who survive on coffee, free food at fringe events and the inevitable traverse to hotel bars and pubs. For the delegates, it’s an opportunity to shape and inform policy. Political parties are quick to remind their members of their democratic credentials; that it’s the card carrying, subscription-paying supporters who get to decide the direction of their party.
That, of course, isn’t necessarily the case. There’s a plethora of examples of motions passed at party conferences that largely get ignored, irking the ire of those at the grassroots. Take the work of the SNP trade union group. For a not too inconsiderable amount of time, they’ve been attempting to push the party in a positive direction – getting policies adopted by the party on progressive taxation, a publicly-owned energy company, achieving a just transition and further devolution on migration and tax.
Most of which, despite overwhelming support within the SNP, have been given the rubber ear by the party hierarchy. From a party whose membership could be described as trade-union curious rather than, what used to be, trade-union averse, the hierarchy of the SNP would do well to notice all those taking a keen interest in our movement’s work.
We saw this for ourselves. The STUC was live, on the ground in the cavernous P&J arena for the SNP Conference. With good reason too. The Scottish Government’s public service reform agenda was one of the leading issues for delegates and speakers. It would be a quasi-dereliction of duty from trade unions not to have been in the room, unashamedly and, yes, unabashedly telling decision makers the folly of their plans.
Read more
- 'We must not allow Scottish Government to dilute its Fair Work First policy'
- Programme for Government 2026: Scotland needs action, not policy by press release
- Roz Foyer: What’s in the AI data centre explosion for working people?
It wasn’t just us either. Teachers, public servants, council workers and even the SNP’s own councillors were in open “revolt” with the plans according to The Herald’s Hannah Brown. Little wonder. From a Scottish Government that tried to radically reshape social care for years with their now, rightly, abandoned National Care service plans, they now want to produce plans to fundamentally alter the size and shape of state infrastructure – the NHS, social care, local government and other public agencies – within a consultation period lasting just three months.
You can be forgiven for thinking that, with such a rushed through deadline, the Scottish Government want to enact plans that may already be predetermined. I will give the Cabinet Secretary for Public Service reform his due.
By all accounts, he showed up, took the feedback on the chin, with the rather robust feedback from UNISON’s Scottish Secretary Lillian Macer, accusing him of being “disrespectful” when differentiating between different roles in the public sector. He should be mindful, if not wholly consumed with the fact, that as he proceeds with this apparent cuts and closures agenda, public sector worker livelihoods are on the line here.
The trade union movement won't relent in fighting for every worker across every workplace and UNISON were entirely correct to intervene on the Cabinet Secretary.
What’s also interesting were the howls of condemnation and critiques from elected members of the SNP towards their own party’s plans for public sector reform. Councillor after councillor, at Fringe events across the weekend, made clear their opposition. We’ll find out in mere weeks whether the Cabinet Secretary has taken this on board or not.
The First Minister, as he has done throughout his engagement with trade unions on reform, struck a conciliatory tone. He also presented to his party a conference speech with purpose and with several ideas that, as trade unionists, we could get on board with, not least of all bus franchising ambitions. Whilst we don’t (and won’t) accede to public sector reform proposals that could cut 20,000 workers, we are willing to engage on proposals that could make public services better.
That engagement has begun. From direct meetings with various Cabinet Secretaries, public debates and challenging conversation, the Scottish Government shouldn’t be accused of, at least, not putting the hours in. But that can only stretch so far when we find ourselves up against the clock and with Ministers showing no desire to delay their own timetable on reform.
Read more
- Ivan McKee accused of being ‘disrespectful’ over NHS reform plans
- Is Ivan McKee in control of Scotland's public sector reform?
- Scottish Government: Unions won't dictate hybrid work policy
- Union warns SNP may weaken no compulsory redundancy policy
But in an attempt to reset the clock, we’ve taken the debate straight back to the shopfloor; who better to ask about reform of the public sector than the workers themselves involved in service delivery. That’s why, on day one of SNP Conference last week, we launched The Workers' Inquiry. It’s the campaign from public sector unions from across our affiliation, collating the views of public and private sector workers, in order to develop a set of worker-led demands for public service improvements as an alternative to the Scottish Government’s proposals.
When these plans were announced – the quashing of health boards, the kiboshing of local authorities and the forced mergers of public bodies – I described it as “reckless rather than revolutionary”. I stand by that. In fact, I’d go further.
At a time when we need more labour within our workforce – when we see skill shortages in our renewables, social care sector and more – putting public sector workers on to the unemployment line is barbarous. Thus, if the Scottish Government want to stay true to their word – that they value the role and function of trade unions within the civic fabric of Scotland – now’s the time to show it. They should therefore welcome this consultation and publicly commit to encouraging workers, employers and public sector agencies to take part in the campaign.
We do not accept that the only way to reform public services is through job losses, cuts and closures. It’s reductive at best to embark upon a radical transformation of the state from the perspective of cash saving. If this is truly about better public services, then direct investment, proper planning and using the experience of Scotland’s public service workers offer a much better way forward than cuts cosplaying as coherent progress.
It’s abundantly clear too that, if the Cabinet Secretary doesn’t tread lightly, he’ll not only incur the wrath of unions but the rank and file within his own membership too.
Share