There are many words you could use to describe the current system of business rates in Scotland (not all are printable in a respectable newspaper), but “clickbait” wouldn’t usually be one of them.
However, the reaction to The Herald’s Reset the Rates campaign – launched to much acclaim last week – shows that it’s an issue that resonates with a large section of the business population.
For years, small businesses across Scotland have been telling us that the system isn’t working for them. A tax which should provide certainty and support thriving local economies has instead become, for many, a source of anxiety, unpredictability and mounting cost.
Recent revaluations have pushed many businesses out of relief schemes that were specifically designed to protect them. Too often, firms find themselves facing large increases in their liability despite no corresponding increase in turnover, profitability or ability to pay.
Read more:
Relief, when it is there, can be patchy, opaque or unknown. And no-one seems to take any responsibility.
The Herald is right to shine a spotlight on these problems. It is also right to focus on practical solutions, rather than simply highlighting the shortcomings of the current system.
Take the campaign’s calls around restoring the effectiveness of the Small Business Bonus Scheme. This rates relief initiative has been one of the Scottish Parliament’s genuine success stories, but revaluations have steadily eroded its reach.
Businesses that would once have qualified for full relief are increasingly being pulled into rates liability. As we’ve consistently argued, restoring the thresholds to their old levels and indexing them thereafter would address this issue at a stroke.
Read more:
It’s equally important we have a system which businesses can navigate. Scotland’s network of multiple rates assessors and patchwork of reliefs can leave busy business owners struggling to work out what they should be paying. Bringing all that under one roof – our own view is that the assessors should be merged into a single national body, looked after by Revenue Scotland – would reduce the administrative burden and strengthen accountability.
The campaign also underlines something that small firms know only too well: rates do not exist in isolation. Your rates bill arrives alongside a catalogue of other payment demands, which have also risen dramatically in recent years.
Energy costs remain stubbornly high. Staffing costs have risen sharply. Taxation is placing increasing pressure on already tight margins. Meanwhile, revenues are falling for most small businesses in Scotland, with the latest FSB research showing three in five saw revenues drop last quarter.
The price of all this is that Scottish small business confidence is now around its lowest level since Covid, and twice as many small employers are planning to cut staff as to hire.
Read more:
All of this sets a rather tricky stage for the major event of this week: the first Budget from Andy Burnham’s government.
This Budget arrives at a crucial moment and it already feels like there’s a lot riding on it. The government has repeatedly, correctly, emphasised the importance of economic growth. Small businesses are central to achieving that ambition, yet growth won’t happen if the firms being relied on to create jobs and invest are weighed down by ever-increasing costs.
The good news, though, is that there are, as ever, concrete measures the Chancellor can announce that would make a genuine difference.
He could, say, substantially increase the Employment Allowance (which currently allows employers to reduce their National Insurance Contributions by £10,500). He could then index the allowance in line with the National Living Wage to ensure the support keeps pace with rising wage costs and makes hiring staff more affordable.
Read more:
Staying with employment costs, a Statutory Sick Pay rebate for small employers would make sense, helping them to hire and support people with health conditions.
Another smart move would be to raise the VAT registration threshold to £100,000, thus keeping more of the smallest enterprises out of a fiendishly complicated and bureaucratic tax. It would also boost economic activity as fewer business owners deliberately restrict their turnover to avoid being pulled into VAT registration.
Of course, if the Chancellor announces any extra business rates relief for firms in England, that will generate extra sums in consequentials for Scotland. In such a case, there will be a clamour for those funds to be spent on easing the cost burden on Scottish firms when the Scottish Government’s Budget is unveiled in December.
What better way to fund the Reset the Rates campaign calls?
Colin Borland is Scotland Director for the Federation of Small Businesses (FSB).
Share