The Highland A9 corridor certainly looks that way flanked by miles of bleak, treeless, uninhabited bog. It’s easy to conclude nothing could ever grow here. Easier still to conclude that millionaire ‘sporting’ landowners have done Scots a big favour by taking this hopeless land off our collective hands.
Easy but wrong.
Broad-leaved trees thrive almost anywhere sheep, deer and muirburn are excluded.
But with honourable exceptions – big landowners choose not to do that. And the Scottish Government looks the other way.
The proof is the A9 above Blair Atholl. Between the usual barren-looking heather heathland there’s a thick, verdant mixed woodland in the central reservation – because deer won’t cross the busy dual carriageway.
Every time I pass that spot, I think of Ron Greer.
I first encountered this tenacious, obsessive DIY ecologist 15 years ago on one of his ‘Lupin Patrols’ - Ron was single-handedly spreading seeds Arctic Lupin seeds on eroding gullies to help fix bare slopes. The authorities were not amused.
But Ron didn’t give a toss.
He already had experience of being right when all the ‘experts’ were wrong.
The evidence lies on the barren wastelands of Loch Garry by Dalnaspidal where Ron and fellow conservationist Derek Pretswell grew a broad leaf forest from scratch, in a sub-arctic winter climate on sterile-looking land that resembled a golf bunker.
The experts insisted it couldn’t be done.
But Ron persevered.
Brought up in 1950s Govanhill Ron first visited Loch Garry in 1973 when he was monitoring the loch’s Arctic Charr population for the Fisheries Laboratory in Pitlochry. He quickly realised something was far wrong. Without trees on the shoreline, few leaves fell into the loch to feed bugs eaten by the fish – and that stunted their size.
So, Ron began a one-man planting campaign, hitchhiking 16 miles from his home in Blair Atholl with a backpack full of fencing material and tree saplings.
Zoologist Derek Pretswell joined Ron’s tree planting crusade in 1983 and soon the two-man band became the Loch Garry Tree Group, with 130 members determined to restore the fish population and faltering ecology of the whole treeless glen.
Read More:
Nicola Sturgeon shrugs off 'rip off' questions over SNP conference book signing
The Scot helping women driven out of Afghanistan by the Taliban play football again
But in some areas, fencing out sheep and deer was not enough.
After a century of overgrazing, the soil needed a revival.
So, in six plots, Derek and Ron used ‘succession planting,’ mixing lupins and broom with broad-leaved saplings. There was method in their madness. The lupins and broom fixed nitrogen in the soil, provided shelter for growing plants and raised soil temperatures so the trees could take root and flourish. Two years into their experiment it looked as if the lupins had won. But twenty-five years later, when I walked along Loch Garry with Ron and Derek to write about the Tree Group, those first protective species had mostly disappeared, replaced by wild raspberries, insects, herbs and flowers blossoming under tree species chosen to provide daylight under open canopies and leaf litter for bigger, healthier trout and Arctic Charr in the loch.
Suddenly the DIY Tree Group was big news. Billy Connolly visited on one of his TV tours. And in 1999 – after winning a Times/Radio 4 conservation award, the Tree Group got grant funding from the Forestry Commission, and Millennium Forest to apply their successful planting techniques on Meall na Leitrach on the other side of Loch Garry.
Local sheep-farming tenants backed the plan. But the landowner refused - and that was it.
Today that treeless hill - mapped as forest by General Roy in 1755 - is scarred by massive erosion gullies.
The land is capable – but we are not.
Ron and Derek’s next project was New Caledonia – a big restoration project that combined housing, agriculture, tourism and wildland backed by Scottish Enterprise but stymied by ‘institutional inertia and sectional vested interests.' Why?
Who knows. Ron has no university conservation qualifications. Just half a century of successful experience and a tendency to call a spade a spade - which rarely appeals to the great and good.
But retracing that Loch Garry walk again for our film this summer, it was clear those precious woodlands are under threat again. Protective fences were removed earlier this year - within months the lush undergrowth had disappeared and the trees had become damaged and ‘lollipop’ shaped with trunks constantly gnawed by sheep and deer.
According to Killiecrankie-based filmmaker Steve Rawson; ’if we’d have listened to Ron and Derek 40 years ago Scotland would look very different today. That's why I made this film. These two were ‘visionaries’ – and it's not too late to learn from their experience.'
Revive’s Big Land Question shows Scots also want large landowners to be more accountable for the way their land is managed.
Amen to that.
“Scotland’s Missing Forests” will premiere at REVIVE: What Scotland Wants - Real Land Reform. Then free on https://www.youtube.com/@Lesley_Riddoch and @lettochfilms
Share