Mark McGeoghegan

The far right may try - but they won't manage to steal the Saltire

Protesters demonstrate outside the Cladhan Hotel in Falkirk, which houses asylum seekers <i>(Image: Getty Images)</i>
Protesters demonstrate outside the Cladhan Hotel in Falkirk, which houses asylum seekers (Image: Getty Images)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The St George's Cross has appeared on lamp-posts and roundabouts across England. Now, right-wingers are hoisting the Saltire at anti-migrant protesters in Scotland. Here, Mark McGeoghegan looks at whether the St Andrew's Cross will become a symbol of division


In most nations around the world, flying the national flag is far from controversial. Travel to the United States, for example, and you’ll see the Stars and Stripes virtually everywhere. Such flag-waving, as much as some might look down on it, is a broadly uncontroversial display of national pride for the vast majority of people.

Not so in England. In recent months, the St George’s Cross has been cropping up on lampposts and is being painted on roundabouts across swathes of England. The trend has been partly organic, with individuals inspired by what they’ve seen on social media. But it has also been fuelled and organised by the far right, and against the broader context of sometimes violent protests outside hotels housing asylum seekers, the English flag has once again become a symbol of division and intimidation for some.

This is understandable, and it would be whether the organised far right was involved or not. As Tim Marshall, former Sky News Foreign Affairs Editor and author of Prisoners of Geography, has argued, the historically understated nature of English national identity and only occasional use of the flag, combined with its hijacking in the 1970s by the far right, has infused the symbolism of flag-waving with associations with racism and division.

That’s not to say that symbols of English, or British, national identity cannot be unifying. I was living and working in London during the 2018 World Cup, when England reached the semi-finals. Displaying England flags was a symbol of support for their team, something everyone in England could get behind, and it helped that their manager, Gareth Southgate, articulated an inclusive and compassionate vision of Englishness.


Read more Mark McGeoghegan


Something similar happens whenever England, or Great Britain, competes in international sport. As Tim Marshall notes, Euro 1996 was the moment at which the English mainstream really began to reclaim the flag. London 2012, particularly its opening ceremony, dripped with symbols of Britain and Britishness. Polling found that 68% of Britons who watched that ceremony said it made them feel proud to be British, including a majority of Scots.

But this is precisely the problem Tim Marshall points to. The use of symbols of English or British national identity by the mainstream is sparing, and vacating those symbols between occasional spurts of unifying patriotism allows them to be co-opted by the fringes.

Which is precisely what has happened in England over the past month or two. As I mentioned, the sudden appearance of the St George’s Cross across England has been partly organic, but only partly. The primary national campaign is Operation Raise The Colours, co-founded and organised by Andrew Currien.

Mr Currien was a member of the English Defence League leadership’s bodyguard and now runs security for Britain First, a far right political party founded by members of the British National Party, best known for “invading” English Mosques in the mid-2010s. He was convicted of affray in 2009 for his role in a racist brawl that led to a man being crushed to death by a car.

Other well-known extremists run many of the local campaigns. The Nottingham campaign, for example, is run by a former member of the English Defence League who now works for Stephen Yaxley-Lennon’s media operation. Britain First has itself donated at least three-quarters of its flags to groups in Manchester and the West Midlands, according to its leader.

Anti-migrant protesters have more typically used the Union flag rather than the SaltireAnti-migrant protesters have more typically used the Union flag rather than the Saltire (Image: Jeff J Mitchell) Beneath the surface veneer of moderate patriotism motivating the installation of flags across England is a network of far-right activists whose interests lie not just in inspiring patriotism, but in imposing a particular vision of Englishness rooted in blood and soil nationalism, and they are co-opting symbols of English national identity to further that aim.

This is what happens when the mainstream vacates such national symbols. Similar efforts to co-opt Scottish national symbols like the Saltire and Lion Rampant, which you’ll see at almost every anti-migrant protest north of the border, and which I’ve increasingly noticed being pinned to lampposts, have largely failed.

I think there are two reasons for this. The first is that Scots are far more comfortable with Scottishness and its attendant symbols, from flags to tartan, the haggis to the thistle, than the English are with Englishness. The Scottish cringe, to the extent that it ever existed, is a thing of the past. And while we continue to argue over the direction in which to take our nation, the vast majority of us identify with it, are comfortable doing so, and are happy to lay claim to it on a day-to-day basis. In contrast, if the reams of columns and academic literature written about it are to be believed, England is in the midst of an identity crisis.

The second boils down to the nature of mainstream Scottish nationalism, which for decades now has emphasised what SNP politicians will call “civic nationalism”, defining Scotland based on shared values, principles, and commitment to our communities and institutions. This inclusive vision of Scottishness, and its dominance of Scottish nationalism – notwithstanding fringe elements holding anti-English banners outside SNP conferences – makes it exceedingly challenging to co-opt Scottish national symbols to a political agenda contrary to that vision.


Read more


The English left and centre-left frequently discuss reclaiming England’s national symbols and promoting an inclusive vision of Englishness. However, this project often results in superficial gestures, such as Union Flags at Labour Party conferences and St George’s Cross lapel pins, rather than offering a clear and vocal alternative to the far right’s vision of English identity.

When asked about the recent increase in flags being displayed across England, Sir Keir Starmer encouraged it. He stated that, at home, “I always sit in front of the Union Jack” – conjuring all sorts of odd mental images. More to the point, when Reform UK set out plans to deport hundreds of thousands of refugees, including paying the Taliban to take people they want to torture and kill, the government barely pushed back. Their line has been that the far right are right, but don’t vote for them.

The English left has singularly failed to articulate a coherent, inclusive vision of Englishness that would allow them to reclaim symbols of English national identity, and that is why it is so easy for the far right to co-opt those symbols, under the cover of patriotism, as tools of intimidation in their campaigning.


Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos