Few Scots would now consider voting Labour in the upcoming Holyrood elections as Anas Sarwar’s hopes of becoming First Minister continue to fade, but their predicament is all of their own making, writes Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan.
Is the 2026 Holyrood election result already a forgone conclusion? Scottish Labour certainly hope not and would like to think that, as the election approaches and the electorate’s focus turns from Westminster to Holyrood, dissatisfaction with the Scottish Government will see Scottish voters abandon the SNP and shift back to Labour to kick out the sitting government.
We’ve seen something similar happen in the past. In January 2011, Labour were sitting pretty in the polls, on 49% of the constituency vote. In May, the SNP won an overall majority. Significant shifts can and do happen, but for them to happen, voters need to be open to changing their minds in the first place, and it now appears that most Scots are not.
A YouGov poll released earlier this week found that just 23% of Scots would consider voting for Labour in the upcoming elections. 77% would not. In fact, more than half of Scots who voted for Labour in last July’s General Election would not consider voting for them at Holyrood. More Scots would consider voting for the Greens or the Liberal Democrats than would consider Labour.
In contrast, 37% of Scots would consider voting for the SNP. That’s not great, as it suggests that they may be polling near the absolute ceiling of their potential support. But it currently looks like more than enough to get John Swinney and his government re-elected, extending the SNP’s period in power to 34 years by the time of the 2031 elections.
Read more:
- Labour’s looming tax U-turn risks fuelling Britain’s politics of anger
- Trump’s peace deal is real — but he shouldn’t win a Nobel
- Starmer finds his voice — but Sarwar still faces the silence of voters
- With this, Nigel Farage showed how unfit for office he is
Underpinning these figures is disapproval of each government and voters’ views of the party leaders. The Scottish Government has a net approval rating of -31, and the UK Government a net approval of -66. The big problem here for Labour is that while the Scottish Government enjoys a +45 approval rating among SNP voters, the UK Government’s net approval with Labour voters is -49.
John Swinney is the least unpopular party leader in Scotland, with a net favourability rating of -19. Anas Sarwar is the most unpopular of the Scottish party leaders, on -34. Sir Keir Starmer fares even worse, languishing on -53, and is now less popular in Scotland than Kemi Badenoch or Nigel Farage.
As the adage goes, oppositions don’t win elections, governments lose them. What that actually means is that voters won’t consider putting an opposition party into power until they’ve decided they’re done with the existing government, not that the unpopularity of a current government guarantees that they’ll lose an election. Opposition parties also must be seen as worth considering because they’ll likely do a better job, or at least could do no worse than the incumbents.
In Labour’s case, over the course of the past 16 months, they’ve given Scots little reason to think they’d do better than the SNP. In recent Ipsos Scotland polling, even fewer Scots said they have confidence in Labour’s economic strategy for the UK than said they have confidence in the SNP’s economic strategy for Scotland. Scots might have overwhelmingly disapproved of the SNP’s record across most devolved policy areas, but less than one-in-five thought Labour could do a better job, and nearly a third thought they’d do an even worse job than the SNP.
So yes, maybe things can turn around for Anas Sarwar and Scottish Labour before May. Perhaps as the election approaches, Scots will indeed pay more attention to the SNP’s record and decide they’ve had enough. But even if they do, it’s unlikely that they’ll then take a punt on Labour.
Ultimately, Labour’s predicament in Scotland is of their own making. The record of the Starmer government has been one of repeatedly shooting itself in the foot. Its most high-profile errors have been one-off mistakes, such as its cuts to the Winter Fuel Allowance late last year. But it is also making broader, strategic errors.
Take, for example, the just transition from fossil fuels to green energy. The just transition in Scotland is dying by a thousand cuts. At the heart of a successful just transition has to be a purposeful industrial strategy that creates new jobs in emerging industries by encouraging inward investment, and helps workers transition to those new jobs in an orderly fashion.
We should have learned this lesson from the industrial revolutions and energy transitions of the past. There are enough communities across Scotland permanently scarred by the disorderly transition of the 1970s and 1980s to know that we can’t allow this transition to follow the same pattern. And indeed, in rhetoric, our politicians acknowledge this. But it is not reflected in policy.
The announced closure of ExxonMobil’s Mossmorran plant, putting around 400 jobs at risk, is the latest in a long line of failures of industrial policy throughout the energy transition, including the collapse of BiFab a few years ago. These reflect the two sides of the botched just transition – the chaotic closures of traditional energy infrastructure leading to the loss of thousands of jobs, and the failure to transition to infrastructure that would allow renewables supply chains to be based in Scotland, missing out on thousands of jobs.
ExxonMobil noted government policy as a key reason for closing its Mossmorran plant. Of course, ExxonMobil would say that if it felt it would absolve them of responsibility for the damage that closure would cause, and Scottish Labour MPs have been sticking to the party line that this is a commercial decision that the government cannot effect, but this is just one of many examples of government policy and regulatory agencies standing in the way of a just transition.
The Scottish Government is not innocent in this debacle either – there have been warning signs at Mossmorran for some time, and sufficient action to support an orderly transition and preserve jobs has not been forthcoming. It would be unfair to place all the blame on the UK Government and Labour, but there’s enough blame to go around.
And that’s the problem for Labour. Yes, the Scottish Government is unpopular right now, and there is little faith in the SNP as a governing party, but voters don’t see Labour as representing a positive change. They look at Labour and see more of the same. As long as that’s the case and Labour continue to fail to deliver positive change, they’ll be getting nowhere near Bute House.
Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics, an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change, and an incoming Research Associate at the Centre for Public Policy. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social
Share