Roisin McGoldrick

Creating a monopoly in secure care is a dangerous step backwards

'Open tendering and competition within the sector is clearly the best way to achieve best value' <i>(Image: PA)</i>
'Open tendering and competition within the sector is clearly the best way to achieve best value' (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

The Scottish Government’s decision to fund a single secure care provider has sparked alarm among sector leaders, who warn it risks creating a monopoly, driving up costs and undermining care quality, warns Roisin McGoldrick.


The Secure Care sector in Scotland is generally unsung and mostly unknown. It provides, through a small number of charitable organisations secure & intensive care services for vulnerable young people. In June, the Minister for Children and Young People, Natalie Don-Innes, commended the “care and professionalism” shown by the sector which she rightly described as “vital and valued”. The Good Shepherd Centre (GSC) is one of those providers, we work collaboratively with the Scottish Government to supply high quality and secure care.

In October, days after we updated the Minister and her officials on our available capacity and our plans to expand and invest, in line with the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Act which will come into full effect next year, we were blindsided when decades of collaborative working appeared to be abandoned by the government in favour of funding a single monopoly provider. Natalie Don-Innes’ announcement that the Scottish Government would invest substantial amounts of public funding in the Kibble Campus in Paisley, was as shocking as it was unexpected.

The Minister’s decision to abandon partnership working, and instead, enter into a “partnership” with a single provider is hugely concerning for several reasons: Public funding is at stake, high quality secure care is expensive, and politicians are duty bound to make best use of taxpayer’s money. Open tendering and competition within the sector is clearly the best way to achieve best value.


Read more:


We are all too painfully aware of what happens when government chooses favoured providers, as happened with the construction contracts for Cal Mac’s recent ferries. The spectacular cost over runs of more than £321m for these vessels will have to be paid for by Scottish taxpayers. It's very hard to see how best value can be achieved through a decision-making process which appears opaque, shrouded in mystery and utterly lacking in transparency or accountability.

The existence of a range of providers is a strength of the Scottish secure care system, not a weakness. The creation of a monopoly or majority provider who could inflate the fees charged to the public purse, leaving the state without any recourse to alternative providers, obliged to pay significantly more for care has always been avoided by the current system.

A plurality of providers brings further benefits in care quality too. Every provider strives to ensure that the care they provide, matches or exceeds that of their colleagues elsewhere. As the standard of care is measure through the independent work of the Care Inspectorate, a virtuous cycle of competitive comparison is created. This of course would be lost, were a single provider to receive majority funding.

Additionally, the move to build, at taxpayers’ expense, three additional four-bedroom secure care houses at the Kibble campus, creating a facility with 31 secure places flies in the face of the “Reimagining Secure Care” report recommendations, which called for dispersed provision through flexible secure units located in community settings. Centralising or concentrating provision on one site brings a range of challenges that are wholly avoidable. The experience of the secure care providers is that there are often young people who require to be in different locations perhaps because of involvement in the same offences, danger of exploitation or other valid reasons.

The development at Kibble does not include any extension of educational or recreational facilities and therefore dilutes and stretches the existing resources which were designed for 18 rather than potentially 31 young people. This development risks being backward rather than forward looking and in no sense appears to address the future proofing that has been said to be at the core of government thinking. Since the secure care sector has been operating under capacity for some time, during which time the Minister has made three clear Statements to Parliament, highlighting the Scottish Government’s determination not to create “over capacity”, the award of significant funding, without public process, appears likely to do just that.

The Scottish Government has long championed a collegiate and ‘sector’ approach to secure care and has asked and expected that despite being pitted against each other in a spot purchase framework, the secure care centres collaborate in the best interest of the children that we serve. While the Good Shepherd Centre endorses this approach, our trust and confidence in the government to achieve it is now jeopardised, leaving us feeling confused and disenfranchised.

I remain hopeful that the secure care sector can continue to provide the care and support which has been its hallmark, through an open process of transparent, fair and even-handed Scottish Government procurement and collaboration. I urge the Scottish Government to consider very carefully the dangers and risks of dismantling a system which can serve the needs of our country now and in the future.


Roisin McGoldrick is Chair of the Board of Directors, Good Shepherd Centre

 

 

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos