Scotland’s care charities are stretched beyond the limit

Social care graphic <i>(Image: Derek Mcarthur)</i>
Social care graphic (Image: Derek Mcarthur)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Sara Redmond, Chief Officer of the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland, explains why Scotland’s care charities are no longer just under pressure but at risk of collapse and what the Scottish Government must do next.


To say there is a funding crisis in social care and the third sector in recent years is a bit of a cliché. But something has changed for the worse in the last few months.

When talking about health and social care most people think of the NHS and government-run services.

However, a far-reaching amount of the work is managed by third sector organisations - charities, voluntary groups, and social enterprises.

Direct support, like Community Links Workers, taking the pressure off GPs, or social care professionals, providing practical, emotional, and personal support to diverse groups like the elderly, children, or those living with mental health conditions.

Alongside this, support groups, community hubs and foodbanks play a vital role to keep people well in communities.

Put simply, the health and care system wouldn’t run without us.

In August, the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland (the ALLIANCE), in partnership with the Coalition of Care and Support Providers (CCPS) wrote to the First Minister to raise concerns. More than 200 third sector health and social care organisations signed the letter – as exclusively reported in the Herald on Sunday – and it laid bare the dire and intolerable state of affairs.

This was no small step, and a sign of the pressure organisations are feeling.

Yet, this situation is a pressure cooker that’s now boiled over. In the summer of 2024, based on a survey of our members, the ALLIANCE warned that third sector health and social care organisations were ‘stretched to the limit’.

Eighteen months on, the situation would more appropriately be described as being ‘stretched beyond the limit’.

In our last survey, around half of respondents described their finances as ‘insecure’.

When we asked them again this month, this had risen to almost two thirds of organisations. Just 4% described their funding as ‘very secure’.

One ALLIANCE member described their organisation and staff as being at “breaking point”, and “no longer sustainable”.

This stretching beyond the limit is due to a toxic combination of factors.

Sara Redmond is calling for action at next month's budget (Image: Sara Redmond, Chief Officer of Development Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland. By Colin Mearns)

A majority of ALLIANCE members who responded to our survey reported their organisations’ operational costs had increased, there was an increased demand for their services, and their core grants had been cut.

They also had to absorb a rise in employers' National Insurance Contributions, placing further pressure on their finances.

A significant number had to cope with cuts to service contracts as well.

One member told us they had “restructured, reduced our costs, and changed work practices to become more efficient. We cannot do anything more without reducing services or staff”

With the Scottish Government’s Budget due in the first few weeks of January, how will our sector and the individuals we support be affected?

Without action organisations will continue to be at risk, and the impact of this will be felt on individuals and communities across Scotland.

In our joint letter to the First Minister, we outlined four ways this crisis can be reversed using the Budget and Spending Review.

Firstly, and most immediately, there must be a substantial cash injection into third sector providers of health and social care to fill the holes caused by being overstretched. This needs to include full cost recovery for the employer’s National Insurance increases.

We recognise this is a decision of the UK Government, and one which the Scottish Government has rightly condemned. But condemnation alone will not save organisations pushed to the brink.

As well as this immediate action, our sector needs a medium-term fully funded recovery plan. Although the crisis has reached a limit, it is decades in the making, caused by repeated failures to invest in third sector health and social care providers.

This commitment is needed to make sure there is still a sector in the future to meet the growing need for the services we deliver.

A key part of this is making sure the funding delivered covers multiple years and includes increases to reflect inflation.

It is not possible to deliver high quality support to people if organisations are continually facing an annual cycle of waiting to see if they have the funding to continue operating.

Finally, it’s not all about the money – it’s about being equally valued.

The Scottish Government needs to make a firm commitment to fully include the sector when decisions are made about planning and delivering services.

Our sector can be part of the solution to this crisis, and should have a seat at the table, alongside other key decision makers.

As we look ahead to 2026, third sector health and social care organisations face an uncertain and fearful future.

Will this be the year we are stretched beyond breaking point? Or will the Scottish Government ensure that it is a Happy New Year for the tens of thousands of people who rely on us?


Sara Redmond is the Chief Officer, Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos