First, a confession: “patriotism” in politics gives me the ick. It has connotations. I think of men in red and white Crusader tabards, or Americans in MAGA hats whooping and cheering at a Trump rally. Even sentimental Scottish nationalists swaying to Caledonia, tears cutting lines through their blue face paint, are a turn-off to me.
I’m Scottish born and bred, but the child of English parents, married to a man with varied European heritage. People who invoke patriotism or national identity, whether Scottish, British, American or otherwise, often seem to me to be drawing boundaries around their community that include some and exclude others. It often seems arbitrary; it can feel unpleasant.
Not everyone would agree, of course, but discomfort about the concept of patriotism is pretty widespread. The leaders of parties on the centre and left of politics, with the exception of the SNP, have historically bodyswerved the language and symbolism of patriotism.
But suspicious though I am of it, I’m starting to recognise what a mistake that has been. Patriotism is a malleable term. What the left probably should have been doing is embracing the term and actively redefining it.
Enter Michael Marra, the brand new leader of Scottish Labour. What stands out from his first 48 hours in post is his attempt to reclaim the idea of what it means to be Scottish, explicitly invoking patriotism.
Read more:
- Michael Marra sees off Joe Fagan to become Scottish Labour's 11th leader
- Michael Marra: My biggest concern about Labour leadership is impact on family
- John Curtice: Michael Marra's problem is that half of Scotland wants independence
- Michael Marra’s open-door plan to let voters shape Labour’s Holyrood agenda
Here he is on BBC Scotland: “We need to get a stronger Scotland that we can all be proud of. That, for me as a patriotic Scot, is the essential part.”
“Patriotism” here is being used to describe a “proud” Scottish identity that’s distinct from nationalism, one that leverages good relations with Westminster in the service of Scotland. Marra’s definition of Scottish values isn’t groundbreaking, fairness, solidarity, hard work and dignity, a list that the SNP press office might well come up with, but it doesn’t really matter. What he’s saying is that Scottishness doesn’t belong to the nationalist party.
The argument that you can love your country and back Labour instead of the SNP, that being a nationalist party doesn’t make the SNP particularly good at standing up for Scotland and Labour could do better, is one that could well find an audience. The SNP has presided over declining public services and Labour believes the moment is ripe to redefine what it means to be a patriotic Scot.
Other party leaders are also seeking to reclaim patriotism. In an interview in March, the leader of the Scottish Lib Dems, Alex Cole-Hamilton, tried to reframe it, arguing that “patriots love their country but nationalists hate their neighbours”. That’s a rather antagonistic view, but Cole-Hamilton was quick to acknowledge the SNP’s civic nationalism, calling this a “reasonable proposition”. He did, however, point to “outriders of the SNP and wider nationalist movement” who are anti-English and “betray” Mr Swinney’s project.
It’s a fair point and he should know, since the police came knocking at his door advising him to carry an attack alarm because of the anti-English hatred he was receiving.
That, I suppose, is the problem with nationalist movements. They always have a bitter fringe who place undue weight on the importance of identity. Those who don’t fit the profile, even if they don’t encounter overt abuse, can feel like they’re not welcome.
But this isn’t just about Scotland’s endless constitutional question. The bigger issue here is xenophobia and racism. In countries around the world, the concept of patriotism has been co-opted by the far right to define who is friend and, more importantly, who is enemy, with immigrants increasingly demonised.
Prof Michael Kenny of Cambridge University and a leading authority on English nationalism, told me in an interview a few years ago that the unwillingness of liberals to engage with questions of nationalism had allowed the hard right to inhabit that space. He was talking in the context of English nationalism, but the co-opting of patriotism by far-right groups has taken place across Europe, including a bit in Scotland, where we’ve seen Saltires mingling with Union flags at anti-immigration demonstrations supported by the far right.
Patriot Platform, the anti-immigrant protest group that descended on Dover and Portsmouth this summer, blatantly equate their beliefs with patriotism. Patriot Platform is run by Daniel Thomas, self-styled as Danny Tommo, who has served time in prison for attempted kidnapping and whom Shabana Mahmood calls “a far-right and outright racist”. All in black, faces covered, they looked intimidating, almost like a militia, which is very much the point.
Clearly it’s ludicrous to suggest that Patriot Platform embody love of country. They embody a narrow, white, xenophobic view of what the country should look like. But the far right have had a clear run at colonising the idea of patriotism because no one’s tried to stop them. Reform UK have fanned the flames, with their Gorton & Denton candidate Matt Goodwin suggesting that UK-born people from minority ethnic backgrounds were not necessarily British.
What a place to end up. We now have Rishi Sunak, the UK’s first non-white Prime Minister, warning that there’s “a risk that we start equating skin colour with nationality”.
He said: “If you’re not white, it no longer matters who you support at cricket, because you can never be English. It’s a test no non-white person can ever pass.”
This is how the idea of patriotism is being abused. Gordon Brown and Keir Starmer tried in their own ways to counter this phenomenon, but the problem has grown. It requires a fresh response.
We’re kidding ourselves if we think this is just an English problem. The SNP government’s friendly, inclusive nationalism has certainly made it harder for the far right to co-opt Scottish identity, for which the party deserves credit, but we are not immune to it, as we’re already starting to see.
And so we need to reclaim patriotism by rejecting all this bile. You can be a patriotic Scot without being a Scottish nationalist or having a Scottish accent. You can be a patriotic Brit if you or your parents were born elsewhere. And the idea that skin colour has a bearing on nationality is as silly as suggesting you can’t play football if you’re a girl.
Patriotism, said Samuel Johnson, is the last refuge of the scoundrel. It’s time to take it back.
Rebecca McQuillan is a journalist specialising in politics and Scottish affairs. She can be found on Bluesky at @becmcq.bsky.social and on X at @BecMcQ.
Share