Alan Milburn’s review of youth unemployment suggests cutting young people’s access to health and disability-related social security while increasing mental health and job-seeking support.
He’s right that young people need better access to mental health support and more help getting jobs, but cutting their benefits because they’re young smacks of discrimination. It’s not like their food costs less in the supermarket or their rent’s cheaper – assuming they can actually afford to move out – so why should they get less help from the state?
This kind of thinking – dismissing young people’s needs because they’re young – is exactly what our latest campaign, Show Up, is trying to address.
In a recent survey, more than seven in ten adults (72%) said they think that young people are too quick to label life’s challenges as mental health problems. This is despite Scotland’s young people having poorer wellbeing and being two and a half times more likely to experience symptoms of mental ill health than older adults. They’re more stressed at work and four times more likely to feel lonely than people aged 65 or over. This is not a so-called ‘snowflake’ generation – this is a generation growing up significantly more mentally distressed than the generations before it.
Read more:
- Alan Milburn welfare report puts Labour on collision course over benefits
- Inside the town divided by a battle of the Business Improvement District
- Scotland’s NHS reform offers chance to transform mental health care
- John Swinney’s council overhaul could be the shake-up Scotland needs
The pace of life as a young person today is relentless. Social media means that they are constantly exposed to news and information, as well as to unsettling events – like politics, war and climate change – over which they have no control, and for which adults are responsible. There is much more social comparison, with unrealistic and unattainable lifestyles being presented as legitimately aspirational, or even normal. And that pace, that constant access to everything that’s going on in the world, means there’s much less time to mentally rest and recover.
Yes, as adults we also now experience much of that. But we’re not experiencing it in our formative years. We’ve already had the time and space to learn more about who we are, what we want to do with our lives, and what helps us to live well and feel comfortable. We also have more scope to switch off and choose not to engage with endless scrolling and noise. For many young people, their social lives depend on being online, and being offline can bring its own anxieties.
Think about how often you’ve said how grateful you are not to have grown up in the fully digital age. The messages we passed in class stayed there, and the photos of our terrible haircuts and bad fashion choices are in an album under the bed. For young people today, their mistakes are online forever, and the fear of that lives with them.
By and large, we want to help. Almost nine in 10 (88%) adults in Scotland say they would make time ‘there and then’ to support a young person who came to them wanting to talk about their mental health. The thing is, only half of young people said they thought this would be the case. Worse, a quarter of them felt that their concerns would be dismissed as ‘just part of growing up’, or they’d be told ‘how much better’ things are for young people today.
Why the gap? When we spoke to young people, they told us that too often adults in their lives just don’t take them seriously when they’re worried about their mental health. Part of this might be because their problems do not seem familiar; they’re different from what we as adults remember from when we were growing up.
Despite this, young people don’t think that being fobbed off always comes from bad intentions. In fact, they recognise and appreciate that the issues they’re dealing with today are not the same as those the adults they’re trying to talk to might have faced as kids, and acknowledge that adults are usually doing their best.
So our campaign is asking parents, carers, teachers, healthcare professionals – any trusted adult – to reflect a little on how we can better respond when a young person in our life comes to us having a hard time.
Young people’s lives aren’t necessarily harder than ours were. We had our worries too. But theirs are different from ours, and we shouldn’t judge what they’re going through now by what we experienced in the past. The thing that’s worrying them might seem small to us, with more life experience, but for them, it could be the most difficult or confusing problem they’ve faced in their life so far.
We might not always be able to understand what young people are going through when their challenges look different from the ones we remember at their age. And there’s no question we should do more to help them into work, as Milburn says. But we should reject the idea that our young people are somehow dramatic, weak or incapable. And we can all listen, be compassionate, and make a commitment to Show Up for young people’s mental health.
Billy Watson is Chief Executive of SAMH (Scottish Action for Mental Health). You can find out more about the Show Up campaign at www.samh.org.uk/show-up.
Share