Magnolia. When I was growing up, there was a lot of it about (the paint, that is – I never set eyes on the flower).
Folk stuck with magnolia for their interior decor year after year, decade after blessed decade. Why? Because it was inoffensive and familiar. Magnolia did not enhance your life much, but it was OK. It went with your rattan chairs and your tan sofa. I can see it now, glowing beigely in the light of a 60-watt bulb. Something else might well be better, but what?
The SNP is our magnolia. We’ve had the party for nearly 20 years. It is a faded version of itself. Enthusiasm for it has evaporated, but opinion is divided over what to go for instead. The nation is stuck in a rut painted off-white-with-a-hint-of-despair.
The SNP are not what most voters want. “Victory” – emerging as the largest party in next year’s election and getting first dibs at trying to form a government – is a hollow term if more than two-thirds of the population want you gone. On current polling, that’s how things stand. The SNP is on course for its worst result in 18 years, but looks likely to form the next government anyway. Being a minority government with much-diminished authority won’t feel like a famous victory.
But voters are split over who they would like to see running the country instead. While only 30 per cent of folk want John Swinney’s party, Scottish Labour is at least 10 percentage points behind. Labour is not precluded from forming a government by being in second place, but its position is greatly weakened by being so far behind. Alas for Labour, Reform is taking more of its precious support than the SNP’s (11 per cent compared to four per cent, according to recent analysis by the Scottish Election Study).
The bigger issue for Anas Sarwar, however, is the UK Government. Scottish Labour’s fall in support since last July has more to do with disillusion and the winter fuel payment than with Reform.
Read more from Rebecca McQuillan
- A world of yachts and slums is a powder keg waiting to go off
- Americans will fall out of love with Trump
Labour insiders were until recently insisting that the benefits of Labour’s economic and industrial policy will start to be seen within a year, but given the global economic shock created by US tariffs, all bets are off. The only certainty is that the Government will have less money than it thought it would, making more “tough decisions” necessary. The Institute for Fiscal Studies suggests the Chancellor might have to increase capital gains tax or impose pension taxes come autumn – six months out from the Scottish election. Those are better options than cuts, but won’t make Sarwar’s job any easier.
So the future looks magnolia. The SNP is not a bad government – we know what a truly bad government looks like after Brexit, the illegal prorogation of parliament, Partygate and Liz Truss – but it hasn't been a very good one either.
Over-budget ferries and botched recycling schemes have gone alongside a series of broader failures. Scottish public services are creaking. Targets are important to drive progress and no leader meets all their promises, but with this government the guff-ometer has been off the scale. It was going to “eradicate” long-term waits in the NHS. It was going to “substantially eliminate” the attainment gap. It was going to ensure every child “met their potential”. It was going to lead the world in slashing carbon emissions. It was going to recruit 800 more GPs. It was going to eradicate child poverty by 2030.
It milked every one of those announcements for its PR value, but is miles off achieving any of them.
The number of whole time equivalent GPs has actually fallen since 2018; more than 37,000 people were waiting more than a year for NHS treatment on last reckoning; the attainment gap is still a chasm and increased last year; the 2030 climate target has been dumped; the 2030 child poverty target is unreachable. If it seems churlish to mention all this, bear in mind that the SNP asked to be judged on these things. Drugs deaths are once again the worst in Europe; Scottish schools are falling down the international tables in maths and science, and the Government seems at sea about how to fix it; teaching unions are in despair about violence in schools; local services have been pared back, partly because regressive council tax freezes were maintained for too long.
It is surely reasonable to expect better than this, especially from such an experienced government.
There is a positive side to the balance sheet. The Scottish Child Payment and free school meals are proud gains. Free bus travel for young people is a strong pro-equality measure (though it’s actually a Green Party policy). Free childcare? Well, that’s available in other parts of the UK too. Some items are historical facts. Free prescriptions came in 14 years ago. The SNP still talks about abolishing tuition fees (actually, the Labour-Lib Dem coalition did that – the SNP abolished the graduate endowment the coalition decised to pay for bursaries) but the system is struggling due to plummeting numbers of foreign students who cross-subsidise the Scottish ones, the Scottish Government having underfunded universities. What will ministers do about it? Your guess is as good as mine.
Anas Sarwar has a big job on his hands (Image: PA)
This is a government that has struggled to take on significant problems. Policy ambition is admirable, but if you know you can’t afford it, it’s misleading. Whatever else you may think of Labour, it can’t be accused of taking the easy path.
The world has “fundamentally changed” says Keir Starmer. Defence costs and an international economic storm are forcing the UK Government to make unpopular decisions they never wanted to make. Any opposition politician demanding endless spending increases or lower taxes against this backdrop is in the snake oil business.
But unless Labour can better convince voters of how the cutbacks and pain will benefit us all in the end, it faces a tough election next year. John Swinney’s party has one big advantage – people know what they’re getting from them. Labour? Not so much.
Rebecca McQuillan is a journalist specialising in politics and Scottish affairs. She can be found on X at @BecMcQ and on Bluesky at @becmcq.bsky.social
Share