ANDY MACIVER

Unlikely allies could save the SNP - and the push for independence

The SNP once again has a commanding lead in the opinion polls, with support roughly double that of Labour <i>(Image: Danny Lawson)</i>
The SNP once again has a commanding lead in the opinion polls, with support roughly double that of Labour (Image: Danny Lawson)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Ahead of the SNP conference in Aberdeen this weekend, Andy Maciver argues the party - and the cause of independence - might be saved by an unlikely ally


If we accept, as Harold Wilson said, that a week is a long time in politics, then a year feels like an eternity. It must certainly feel like a long year for both the SNP and its opponents. When the party gathered for its 2024 annual conference in Edinburgh, it was more of a wake than a celebration of a party in government. Timed for August as a pre-election rally ahead of an anticipated November election, it instead fell just a month after the SNP was practically wiped out by a resurgent Labour.

As First Minister John Swinney gathers his members together in Aberdeen tomorrow, very little in the way of doom and gloom will be observed. The SNP once again has a commanding lead in the opinion polls, with support roughly double that of Labour. Reform is the party on the rise in Scotland, but not in such a way as to challenge the SNP for victory. Indeed, Reform’s rise looks likely to give the SNP a leg-up, at least in the Scottish Parliament’s 73 constituencies, where it may fracture the vote in some Conservative constituencies and allow the SNP to make gains.

This is not to infer that Mr Swinney is encountering no speed bumps in his journey towards another term of office for his SNP. Firstly, he will himself concede that, although the SNPs poll ratings have recovered to some degree since he and his Deputy, Kate Forbes, assumed the leadership, they are nowhere close to the result at the previous election in 2021. He remains nearly 15 per cent from that peak, and his lead is largely owed to the masochism of the Labour party. He can credible claim to have bumped the SNP up by perhaps five per cent, but the high water mark remains well above his head.


Read more by Andy Maciver


Secondly, his summertime announcement that he accepts the need for an SNP to win an outright majority before Westminster can be expected to grant a second independence referendum has been received poorly by many in his party. Looking at the polls and seeing it as unachievable, they are aghast. Jam tomorrow isn’t sufficiently sweet for your average member of the SNP.

And, when he does go into more granular detail about the shape of a future independent Scotland, as he did on Wednesday in a new prospectus for an independent Scotland, there is no shortage of economists and commentators standing ready to pick holes in the theoretical financial arrangements.

Twas ever thus, and of course it is excruciatingly hard for a pro-independence leader to be completely frank about the reality of a post-independence Scotland, which is that there would be several years of massive spending cuts and wholesale public service reform before Scotland could become a fiscally stable, prosperous independent state in the mould of its similarly-sized European neighbours.

All that said, barring some unforeseen thunderbolt, John Swinney is your First Minister after May next year, and the only relevant question for his members to contemplate in Aberdeen this weekend is how many seats he wins, and therefore how much help he needs from others to govern.

And this is, legitimately, a very interesting question. I take the view that Mr Swinney knows that his chances of achieving the majority required to execute his referendum plan is vanishingly small. I would suggest that the strategy is not designed with this election in mind, but is in fact laying the foundations for the election in 2031.

A young voter leaves a polling station after casting her vote in Edinburgh, Scotland, on September 18, 2014, during a referendum on Scotland's independence(Image: LEON NEAL)

If independence is to be a realistic prospect in the medium term, two simultaneous characteristics need to be present. The first is that the Scottish Government needs to do significantly better at its day job. To say there is room for improvement in schools, hospitals, transport, housing and the economy would be to dramatically understate the gravity of our current state. Mr Swinney’s team reckon things are getting, and will continue to get, better. They’ll have to be right.

The second necessary condition lies a few hundred miles south. Independence needs Nigel Farage; nothing will be better at driving centrist indy-sceptics into the hands of Mr Sensible at Bute House than Mr Farage walking through the doors of Downing Street. His policies have some resonance in parts of Scotland, for sure, but as a quintessential English nationalist, he does not.

That is a few years away, though, so Mr Swinney needs to tread carefully in the intervening period. Choosing friends to help him govern will be especially important.

He is likely to have two choices; the Greens or the Liberal Democrats. He should choose the Lib Dems.

This is not designed as a slight against the Greens. In fact, I think the new Green leadership of Ross Greer and Gillian Mackay will usher in the best we have seen from the party. They are intelligent and articulate, and their positions are well thought out, and they appear more pragmatic than their predecessors.


Read more


Nonetheless, they make no secret of the fact that their positions sit well to the left of the SNP leadership, and that also places them well to the left of the country.

Memories of the previous coalition between the SNP and the Greens are fresh. We can spend a while re-litigating it, but perception is king and the perception of centrist voters, especially those of a pro-UK disposition, is that it was a wacky experiment gone wrong.

The sort of voters who did not vote for independence last time, and who need to vote for independence next time, are simply not in the market for more of this. They will run a mile.

The Lib Dems are a safer choice. They look likely to swell in number to a similar size to the Greens, so choosing them would not reduce the Parliamentary majority. Moreover, working cross-constitutionally with the Lib Dems is a good look for Mr Swinney, as it was for him when the Lib Dems passed his Budget earlier this year.

Most of all, though, the Lib Dems will help put Mr Swinney precisely where he needs to be if independence is to become a reality; in the good books with centrist unionists.


Andy Maciver is Founding Director of Message Matters, and co-host of the Holyrood Sources podcast

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos