Mark McGeoghegan

Plaid Cymru beat Reform - will Scots back the SNP to do the same?

Leader of Plaid Cymru, Rhun ap Iorwerth applauds after Plaid Cymru's Lindsay Whittle is declared winner for the Caerphilly Senedd by-election <i>(Image: Andrew Matthews)</i>
Leader of Plaid Cymru, Rhun ap Iorwerth applauds after Plaid Cymru's Lindsay Whittle is declared winner for the Caerphilly Senedd by-election (Image: Andrew Matthews)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

In the wake of Plaid Cymru’s victory in Caerphilly and Reform UK’s reshaping of the political landscape, Scotland’s unionists need to rethink whether tactical voting can still contain the SNP, writes Herald columnist Mark McGeoghegan.


Labour’s defeat in last week’s Welsh Senedd by-election in Caerphilly came as no surprise to anyone who had been paying attention to the contest, but it was still crushing. They came a distant third behind Plaid Cymru and Reform UK in a seat they had held comfortably since the Senedd was established in 1999, and a part of Wales where Labour have won every general election since 1918.

What was somewhat surprising was the scale of Plaid’s victory, beating Reform by 47% of the vote to 36%. A poll of the constituency had previously suggested that Reform would win, and they were bullish going into the count on Thursday night. In the end, an anti-Reform voted coalesced not around the Labour incumbents, but Plaid, delivering them victory.

Caerphilly marked the emergence of a relatively new phenomenon in British politics. We’re used to tactical voting against parties like Reform, but not those tactical votes shifting in such a dramatic manner to a party with no history of success in a constituency.

Plaid presented the by-election as “a clear choice for Caerphilly” between them and Reform, between left and right, and between two nationalisms, Welsh and (essentially) English. They dispatched Labour easily, blaming the Labour governments in Cardiff and London for the high cost of living, the failures of the Welsh NHS, and the visible decline of Caerphilly itself. But the real contest was with Reform, and here a significant change in the pattern of tactical voting got them over the line.


Read more:


In Caerphilly, wanting to punish their usual choice but keep Reform out, disillusioned Labour voters swung to Plaid. Two-fifths of Labour voters in last July’s general election voted for Plaid’s Lindsay Whittle, and their motivations were clear in doorstep conversations throughout the campaign. In a conversation recorded by the New Statesman, a Caerphilly voter told Mr Whittle that “I don’t want to allow Reform in, but the party that represents my interest most is the Green Party.” Following an awkward attempt to persuade her of Plaid’s green credentials, she closed the conversation out by saying that “my plan is to vote for you, just definitely not Reform.”

The polarisation between Plaid and Reform was palpable both online and physically. At a town hall debate, one local voter took Reform’s candidate, Llŷr Powell, to task for his party’s rhetoric. Alison Vyas, whose husband and sons are of mixed minority ethnic background, said that Reform had made her family “never feel so unwelcome in our own hometown,” adding, reportedly to rapturous applause, that “quite frankly, Mr Powell, I blame you for that.”

That voters in such a long-loyal constituency could abandon Labour to vote for Plaid to keep out a Reform MS tactically is a sign of how low Labour’s standing has fallen since coming back to power last year. A recent poll by YouGov put Labour on just 17% of the vote across Great Britain, the lowest they have ever recorded. In Wales, polls suggest that Plaid and Reform are neck-and-neck ahead of the Senedd elections in May, with Labour on just 14% of the vote in a nation whose politics they have dominated for over a century. A Labour defeat in May would be far more seismic than even their defeats in Scotland in 2007 and 2011.

The same pattern is occurring in Scotland, too. Reform are now polling in second place north of the border, ahead of Labour but still trailing the SNP by double digits. If the polls are accurate, Reform is on course to be Scotland’s largest opposition party come next May.

Which provokes the question: who should voters keen on keeping out Reform vote for, and might that be a key factor in the upcoming Holyrood elections? We are no strangers to tactical and strategic voting in Scotland. Much of Labour’s Scottish landslide last July came thanks to anti-Conservative and anti-SNP voting. The Conservatives themselves were elevated to being Scotland’s largest opposition party by anti-SNP voting.

Several Scottish Parliament constituencies, including the Dumbarton seat held by Labour’s Dame Jackie Baillie, really ought to have been won by the SNP in recent elections but have been held by unionist parties thanks to tactical voting. In 2021, Dame Jackie beat out the SNP’s Toni Giugliano by less than 4% of the vote, but the SNP beat Labour on the list vote in her constituency by over ten points.

Tactical and strategic voting in Scotland has been defined by the constitutional issue since 2014, and to a lesser extent by anti-Conservative voting last year. This has mitigated the SNP’s ability to win a Scottish Parliament majority (if they had won Dumbarton in 2021, they would have won a majority). But times are changing. Independence is no longer the be-all, end-all it once was, and the rise of Reform is transforming the political landscape.

What happens when left-leaning Scottish voters, finished with the Conservatives, disillusioned with Labour, fearful of Reform, are confronted with a choice between Reform and the SNP, between left and right, and between two nationalisms, one Scottish and one English? Do they vote Labour in the Central Belt, and Conservative in the North East and South Scotland, in the hopes that those parties can garner enough votes to keep out both the SNP and Reform?

It’s more likely, I think, that they hold their noses and vote for the SNP. As I’ve written before in these pages, next May’s election will be defined by the question of who voters want to keep out, not who they want to govern. There are also around 15 constituencies that currently look like knife-edge, three-way marginals between the SNP, Reform, and either Labour or the Conservatives. If tactical voting can help the SNP come through the middle in those contests, a Holyrood majority is not out of the question.

The UK has not seen a realignment of its party system for roughly a century, when Labour supplanted the Liberals. The realignment we are living through right now is far more extensive, with the emergence of truly multi-party politics. The outcomes are inevitably unpredictable, including the impact on patterns of tactical and strategic voting. But if Caerphilly is anything to go by, it’s time for the unionist parties to rethink whether they can continue to rely on anti-nationalist voting to contain the SNP.


Mark McGeoghegan is a Glasgow University researcher of nationalism and contentious politics and an Associate Member of the Centre on Constitutional Change. He can be found on BlueSky @markmcgeoghegan.bsky.social

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos