SNP Government failure to deliver promised boom in renewables brought into focus as Iran war fuels surge in energy bills in Scotland
First minister John Swinney cultivates an image of sober reasonableness but has shown himself to be a hypocrite of the first order in his latest attacks on the UK Government.
Mr Swinney accused prime minister Sir Keir Starmer of “dithering” in his response to the surge in fuel oil prices triggered by the US-Israeli war on Iran amid fears that thousands of Scots will be hit hard.
The criticism looked like a crude attempt to turn the war to the SNP’s advantage, particularly given the fact there was nothing to stop the Scottish Government offering help.
In the event, Sir Keir unveiled a £4.6m package last Tuesday. The Scottish Government waited until the following day to trump that by announcing it would make £5.4m available to supplement the UK response, which it said did not go far enough.
Accompanied by displays of faux outrage, Mr Swinney’s attacks on the PM were pretty lame.
However, they reflect serious failing on the part of SNP Governments which have claimed to be of a stronger moral calibre than Westminster administrations they have lambasted.
Read more
- SNP Government hopes for renewables bonanza sinking off Scottish island
- Just Transition Fund farce deepens as Scots firms fight over windfarm scraps
- Scotland counts cost of North Sea oil giant's huge investor payouts
- Scottish energy heavyweight vindicated after spat with US investors
The failings include displays of hypocrisy that are especially glaring in the case of energy policy.
It was notable that SNP energy minister Gillian Martin announced the fuel oil funding days after she had called on the UK Government to scrap the energy windfall tax, which she claimed was accelerating the decline of the North Sea oil and gas industry.
The call was unfortunately-timed to say the least. It was made three days before the US and Israel launched their assault on Iran. The price of Brent crude has soared since then leaving motorists in the UK facing steep increases in petrol prices and North Sea firms in line for a huge boost to earnings.
A dramatic increase in natural gas prices will likely result in a £300 plus rise in average annual household energy bills when the price cap is reviewed in July.
What made Ms Martin’s claim to be the guardian of the North Sea oil and gas industry especially galling was the fact that SNP Governments were happy to betray it in the wake of the 2014 independence referendum, after deciding to court the green vote.
The draft energy strategy that former FM Nicola Sturgeon unveiled in 2023, months after it was due to be released, recommended a presumption against further oil and gas exploration in the North Sea.
Ms Sturgeon opposed plans for the Cambo oil field development West of Shetland, which supporters say could provide a huge boost to the Scottish economy.
Ms Sturgeon’s immediate successor, Humza Yousaf, then denounced the UK Government for its decision to approve the Rosebank oil field development West of Shetland, which could support thousands of jobs in Scotland.
Days after Ms Martin made her call for the windfall tax to be scrapped the Israeli-owned North Sea firm leading work on Cambo, Ithaca Energy, posted a $2 billion profit. Ithaca also underlined its belief in the commercial potential of the proposed Cambo development and of Rosebank, which it has a stake in.
The SNP has been in power for 19 years that have been marked by dithering about energy matters which has left Scotland in a pickle.
SNP leaders have spent years banging on about the potential for Scotland to become a clean energy powerhouse but left the country with a dependence on imports of oil and gas that makes it acutely vulnerable to developments in international markets.
The delay in developing the policies needed to put Scotland on firmer foundations when it comes to energy reflects a mixture of cynicism and incompetence.
When Ms Martin made her fuel oil funding announcement the SNP Government had kept people waiting for the publication of the final version of the energy strategy issued more than three years.
Since the power-sharing agreement struck by Ms Surgeon in 2021 with the Scottish Greens fell apart, in 2024, ministers have tried to find a way of rebuilding SNP in the heartlands of the oil and gas industry in North East Scotland without alienating tree-huggers.
Amid the SNP’s criticism of the windfall tax, Mr Swinney has dodged questions on whether the UK Government should approve revised plans for Rosebank.
Opponents in Conservative ranks have gleefully pointed out the contradictions involved.
To his credit, Mr Swinney has highlighted failings in the performance of SNP Governments that he has accepted reflect a tendency to make grand policy announcements without thinking carefully enough about how they can be implemented.
This has been obvious in the energy sphere as SNP ministers have spent years dithering about how to deliver on key pledges.
A succession of ministers have repeated claims that Scotland can develop clean energy sources on a massive scale and that these will provide a huge boost to growth in the economy.
Lots of windfarms have been constructed in rural Scotland to the dismay of many locals in the areas affected but the drive to develop offshore wind on a large scale appears to have petered out. None of the firms that bid for leases in the landmark ScotWind round in 2022 have developed windfarms on the acreage concerned.
Overseas investors have enjoyed most of the benefits generated to date and the number of jobs created has fallen well short of expectations.
At the same time, the flagship £500m fund launched in 2022 to support a ‘just transition’ to a clean energy world in areas that depend on oil and gas has had minimal impact.
A report found the fund created just 120 jobs in its first two years after an outlay of £43m.
The fund was closed to applications for months while ministers dithered about how to revamp it - without appearing to reach any significant conclusions.
In the week after the US and Israel attacked Iran the Scottish Government announced that the fund had been expanded without making it clear in what form.
Ms Martin said a whopping £17 million could be made available to help create green jobs, support innovation, diversify energy supply chains, and enable workers to transition into low-carbon roles.
Her breathy announcement included the revelation that some of the funding will be used to help people to develop the skills needed to apply for just transition grants.
If the SNP Government were to remain in power after the Scottish Parliament elections in May, it would be no surprise if the next round of the Just Transition Fund included grants to train people to train people to apply for awards.
Share