REBECCA McQUILLAN

Pick the right leader, Labour, or we'll have the SNP in power for ever

Either Michael Marra (left) or Joe Fagan will be announced as Scottish Labour leader on Saturday <i>(Image: PA)</i>
Either Michael Marra (left) or Joe Fagan will be announced as Scottish Labour leader on Saturday (Image: PA)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Recovery for Scottish Labour is not guaranteed. That's the toughest lesson the party has learned since leaving office 20 years ago.

The SNP has lost its shine and much of its popularity, which should have helped Scottish Labour claw its way back to relevance, but still the party of Donald Dewar declines, following a pattern that began in 2003.

Successive Scottish Labour leaders have worked hard to persuade voters their party can better safeguard Scotland’s interests than the nationalists; many voters just aren’t persuaded. But this slow death isn’t written in the stars. Labour may never out-Scottish a nationalist party but they could inspire where the careworn, exhausted veteran SNP Government disappoints. It could offer a vision that reflects people’s thirst for fundamental systemic change. A canny, far-sighted leader could boost the party. But will they get one? Or will the SNP be in government forever?

On Saturday, Scottish Labour will unveil its new leader, following the resignation of Anas Sarwar. The winner will be taking over a once-great party heading for minnow status in increasingly crowded electoral waters where predation is ruthless. Scottish Labour still remains by a whisker the most realistic choice to replace the SNP – at the head of a minority coalition – but even that assumption disintegrates if its poll decline continues from here.


Read more by Rebecca McQuillan


What the party can’t afford to do is to elect a manager dealing in retail policy offers, rehashing Tony Blair’s pledge card ideas, in an era of visceral identity politics and anger at the system. Endless criticism of NHS waiting lists and falling attainment isn’t enough. If the party is ever again to challenge SNP dominance of Scottish politics, it needs a galvanising, persuasive leader who can develop and communicate a distinctive identity, connect with fed-up communities and present a clear plan to change the system. Even then there’s no guarantee of electoral success, but without it, Scottish Labour is heading into irrelevance.

The two candidates – Michael Marra, a seasoned MSP, and Joe Fagan, a newbie to Holyrood – do not offer a radical choice. Leftist voters lost their candidate when Monica Lennon had to withdraw due to a lack of support from Labour MPs, saying as she went that the party was “stuck in the past” and that her departure limited debate about how Labour becomes “a modern political party for …working class communities”.

She was right, of course, it has limited debate. The two remaining MSPs largely agree with one another, including on taxation (too much being paid by middle earners), Rosebank oil field (they’re for it) and trans rights (they disagree with the provisions in the Gender Recognition Act). Not much there for the radical left, which may come to be a problem.

But Marra and Fagan are not identical twins. Marra, a thoughtful experienced parliamentarian, is widely seen as the Labour establishment choice, while Fagan, until recently the leader of South Lanarkshire Council where he worked in partnership with the Liberal Democrats, is a voice from what was once Labour’s heartland. If the mark of a potential vote winner is projecting a strong connection with working class communities, Fagan may have the edge. Whoever wins, though, it’s clear that they cannot continue with the status quo. They need to create some excitement around a Labour alternative to the SNP.

Keir Starmer’s depressive effect on poll ratings was certainly partly to blame for Scottish Labour’s poor performance in May but the party would be deluding itself to see Starmer as the sole author of their misfortune. The campaign itself wasn’t good enough. The strategy of focusing on constituency battles and largely ignoring the regional lists has come in for criticism, but a bigger concern is that the manifesto failed to offer voters a vision for how inequality and unfairness in Scotland could be tackled that went beyond the conventional.

Modern Scottish politics is painted in strident colours; it’s no place for the bland. In May’s election, Labour did not stand out from the pack; it was more at pains to point out SNP failures than to market innovative solutions to Scotland’s problems. Many frustrated left-wing voters preferred the Greens.

The new leader can make a virtue of having a Labour Prime Minister in Downing Street. The former Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale has made the point that Anas Sarwar didn’t talk enough about the benefits to Scotland of a UK Labour government, such as strengthening workers’ rights, cheaper mortgages due to falling interest rates or the fact that extra spending in England was bringing more money to Scotland through so-called Barnett consequentials, a foundation stone of the devolution settlement. After so many years of Tory government when left-wing unionist politicians in Scotland tended to fear Westminster as a liability, Scottish Labour has learned to be wary. That’s allowed the SNP a clear run at presenting the Union as a problem instead of the source of financial security and stability it usually is.

Andy Burnham has shown the power of personality in politics (Image: Getty)

Andy Burnham’s devolution agenda, championing regions and localities around the UK, turns the tables on an SNP that complacently assumes the right to speak for Scotland while having centralised power within it. This is Labour’s chance to become the champions of local communities that feel overlooked and misunderstood by Edinburgh. But above all, Labour needs a leader who gets noticed for having a plan. The “Burnham bounce” underlines the oversized impact personality has in the current uncertain and threatening political climate. The incoming boss needs to look and sound like someone who understands the problems voters are facing and inspires trust in his capacity to solve them.

This will be the 11th Scottish Labour leader of the devolution era; a sickly pigeon could have outlasted some of them. The incomer will be hoping to take the party into the 2031 election. There should be no ceiling on Scottish Labour’s ambition: with Reform and the Conservatives polling far too low to consider creating a government together, and the Greens and Lib Dems too small to lead a coalition, Labour is still the bookies’ favourite as the source of Scotland’s next First Minister. The SNP Government is facing its toughest term of office yet, with £4.7 billion to save by 2030. Independence is a radical option all right, but doesn’t have the same appeal coming from a party that’s making cuts. The new Labour leader has an opportunity: this time, they can’t afford to waste it.


Rebecca McQuillan is a journalist specialising in politics and Scottish affairs. She can be found on Bluesky at @becmcq.bsky.social and on X at @BecMcQ

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos